• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Westworld - Live in Your World, Play in Ours - Sundays on HBO

I wouldn't be surprised if all the 'butchers' were all hosts. The...routine violence and bloodshed would be hard to stomach for normal people. Would explain why they stick with her, instead of running to management the second shes back in the park and they are safe.

and i'm wagering the other killed girl, who is only on 'vacation' is the new host being built. Why though, is the question? Maybe ford wants another behavioral specialist in his pocket for some reason?
 
Maybe Ford's new narrative involves the park staff.

Butchers are hosts. Ford has gone full "I AM A GOD" mode and he's gonna suck the Delos employees into a sci-fi robot uprising narrative. With real death. He got tired of writing stories set in the west and wanted a change.

Mwahahahaha
 

bunbun777

Member
Hector was in the room with Theresa and Hale during that conversation.

So assuming she's not on Ford's side, she has to know that after banging Hector she needs to throw a towel over him or something. I'm convinced that the shoddy programming of Clem only really convinced Teresa. At the very least it allowed Ford the pretext to now wrestle more control away from QA and allows himself to continue with plans. Like if Hale's main interest is positioning Ford away from the park she did a pretty bad job of it.
 
Is it confirmed though? We see Dolores having flashbacks in William's timeline. So unless there are three timelines something doesn't add up.

hope not and they do a reverse flip, but so far there seems to a lot of evidence to support it. Being married and having trouble with his wife and being surprised the blonde host was not retired yet.

The whole Dolores part has be confused as hell
 

phaonaut

Member
I wouldn't be surprised if all the 'butchers' were all hosts. The...routine violence and bloodshed would be hard to stomach for normal people. Would explain why they stick with her, instead of running to management the second shes back in the park and they are safe.


Yeh, working in a mass murder facility would break you. The shower scenes are chilling enough.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if all the 'butchers' were all hosts. The...routine violence and bloodshed would be hard to stomach for normal people. Would explain why they stick with her, instead of running to management the second shes back in the park and they are safe.

and i'm wagering the other killed girl, who is only on 'vacation' is the new host being built. Why though, is the question? Maybe ford wants another behavioral specialist in his pocket for some reason?
If they are, why give them back stories where they are able to get emotional and be inefficient because if things like fear of losing their jobs, ambitions for promotion, etc. Just make mindless repair bots at that point, which clearly they aren't. I wish the bad writing didn't make this kind of speculation so necessary.
 
Yeah it really isn't confirmed.

And honestly the scene with the church being buried sort of suggests william /= mib.

That whole sequence is weird though. Dolores is clearly a very unreliable narrator by her own admission. She doesn't know what's real so it's hard to make any definitive conclusions about any timelines.

The entrance host being a part of the new narrative also doesn't confirm anything. She may have been role swapped specifically for the new narrative.

My money is on the Dolores william timeline not being 30ish years ago. There is an alt timeline but mib isn't william.
I just took it as a flashback to before the park opened when they were testing all the hosts.

Now why the town was buried in William/Dolores' time is a question, sure.

Do we know how long after the park opened that William/Logan's trip is supposed to be?
 

Teletraan1

Banned
If the butchers are hosts it seems crazy to have some of them sodomize the other "dead" hosts but it could all be just a construct to keep them in line. We have something on you so do as I say type thing. I really can't wait till the end of this season to see if things actually get explained.
 
I wouldn't be surprised if all the 'butchers' were all hosts. The...routine violence and bloodshed would be hard to stomach for normal people. Would explain why they stick with her, instead of running to management the second shes back in the park and they are safe.
Yeh, working in a mass murder facility would break you. The shower scenes are chilling enough.
That actually makes a lot of sense. The mental trauma of both needing to treat these indistinguishable-from-human beings like furniture and needing to clean, manipulate, lobotomize, etc. them on a daily basis for years would be huge
 
After reading this thread I went into watching this week's episode expecting the worst hour of television devised by mankind.

Nope, still think the show is as great as ever. The Maeve storyline has a few questionable moments, but at least they at least somewhat tried to answer that this week by having Sylvester actively try and decommission her but Felix has too many feelings for the hosts (as previously shown by his work on the broken bird) to let that happen.
 
That actually makes a lot of sense. The mental trauma of both needing to treat these indistinguishable-from-human like furniture and needing clean, manipulate, lobotomize, etc. them on a daily basis for years would be huge

I dunno, they could all be sociopaths like the Man in Black and doing all this doesn't bother them long as they get paid and they get to fuck dead hosts...

Nasty.
 
I dunno, they could all be sociopaths like the Man in Black and doing all this doesn't bother them long as they get paid and they get to fuck dead hosts...

Nasty.
But this episode basically showed that the MIB isn't a sociopath, and those actions/quest for the maze was only a recent development and possibly a form of coping with the death of his wife
 
If the butchers are hosts it seems crazy to have some of them sodomize the other "dead" hosts but it could all be just a construct to keep them in line. We have something on you so do as I say type thing. I really can't wait till the end of this season to see if things actually get explained.
Yeah, but why would you "need something to keep in line" hosts you have complete control over? The necroperv butcher is just another example. At best, butchers as hosts would have a standard loop like park hosts - do your job, rinse, repeat. Why would they make them do crazy stuff like bang other hosts, go into vr with hot redheads, and program birds in their free time?

Unless of course they are all Ford slaves like Bernard and they're meant to fool delos and internal staff.
 
But this episode that the MIB isn't a sociopath, and those actions/quest for the maze was only a recent development and possibly a form of coping with the death of his wife

I didn't get that impression... I mean, his wife and daughter were terrified of him even though he never did anything, and then to prove to himself what he's really like, he murdered Maeve and her daughter, and felt nothing towards them.

Seems like a sociopath thing to do.
 
Maybe Ford's new narrative involves the park staff.

Butchers are hosts. Ford has gone full "I AM A GOD" mode and he's gonna suck the Delos employees into a sci-fi robot uprising narrative. With real death. He got tired of writing stories set in the west and wanted a change.

Mwahahahaha

Ford gets tired of making "Westworld 2", "Westworld 3", "Westworld: Reach" and wants out,
 
Another bright spot of this last episode which stuck out to me: we got a lot of exposition from Ford when he's talking to Bernardbot. Ford essentially comes out as a nihilist(?) in so far as he believes consciousness is an illusion, whether it is a bunch of chemical impulses in the human brain or a set of bits in a host's memory. Either way, to him they are meaningless and can and should be altered at his behest. This makes Ford way more believable as a villain if that really is his philosophy.
 

Speevy

Banned
So happy that they are re-using that guy again. Hopefully he has a lot of scenes.

Still the best actor on the show with one scene;

This scene is scary because it suggests something that the show hasn't delivered on largely.

How can a show so understand and misunderstand what makes sci-fi great?
 

duckroll

Member
But this episode basically showed that the MIB isn't a sociopath, and those actions/quest for the maze was only a recent development and possibly a form of coping with the death of his wife

Who cares, when Teddy says that he's talking like he owns this world, he says "not just this one". OMG! #RomeWorldConfirmed #MedievalWorldConfirmed #WesterosWorldConfirmed
 

Speevy

Banned
I don't understand Wyatt. Is he a gateway to something Arnold made or a creation of Ford's?

If he is a creation of Ford's, why are he and his minions apparently unkillable by hosts and guests?
 

duckroll

Member
I don't understand Wyatt. Is he a gateway to something Arnold made or a creation of Ford's?

If he is a creation of Ford's, why are he and his minions apparently unkillable by hosts and guests?

He's just a high level raid. What's there not to get? Lol.
 
Who cares, when Teddy says that he's talking like he owns this world, he says "not just this one". OMG! #RomeWorldConfirmed #MedievalWorldConfirmed #WesterosWorldConfirmed

I took it as he "owns" the real world as he is a billionaire ("titan of industry" as he put it).

Sort of like Elon Musk lets say.
 

Ferrio

Banned
I don't understand Wyatt. Is he a gateway to something Arnold made or a creation of Ford's?

If he is a creation of Ford's, why are he and his minions apparently unkillable by hosts and guests?

They're from VikingWorld, WestWorld rules don't apply to them.

*shrug*
 

Mega

Banned
That Elsie twist is amazingly dishonest in a very dishonest show. He was just on the phone with her so we have to assume there was a time jump after the phone call???? Come on.

Of all the things nagging me, this is one is at the bottom of the list. After she called Ford, Elsie looked hunkered down in front of that computer. Different mood, pose, etc., like someone spending the night studying. It seemed quite clear to me some time had elapsed after her phone call and she had gone anywhere from 15 minutes to upwards of an hour poring over the information on that remote terminal.
 

duckroll

Member
So...after that talk Ford gave about discovering what you can be, his ideas amount to beefed up baddies? Doesn't work for me.

The beefed up baddies are just a brute force barrier, window dressing for the larger purpose of the narrative. Like, MGS2 is respected as a visionary take on information control and social media influencing society, but at the same time, you still have a part where you blow up a ton of Metal Gear Rays with a rocket launcher in a shooting gallery arena. :p
 

Mega

Banned
Man the heel turn on this show here has been unreal, just last week we were calling it the best show on TV, now everybody has 180d on it and seems to hate it, "a bad show held up by Hopkin's acting" lol.

I still think it's a good show. If it drops the nonsensical plots that stretch our suspension of disbelief and reins in the frenetic flash forwards/backwards, it could enter into the realm of greatness.
 

JesseZao

Member
I think the reception of this week's episode compared to last week's makes sense if you consider it parallel to the "Human" Protagonist Bernard's (and surrogate Elsie's) storyline. The audience identifies with Bernard and last week we/he hit a climatic high. This week was us/Bernard picking up the pieces to find our place/purpose/reality/etc.

Basically, I thought it was a lower impact episode, but I feel like it made sense why. Looking forward to the last two!
 

John Harker

Definitely doesn't make things up as he goes along.
So no ones taking me up on the MiB is the Board Director line? Or maybe I'm just too late to the theory game heh
 
Just to get this straight:

-35+..Alpha | Old Bill
-34....Beta | Hot Girl with umbrella, Dolores, Church above ground, Arnold dies
-30....Hot Girl at welcome center, Dolores + William, Church buried, EVENT
-1......MIB, Maeve + Daughter
0.......MIB quest, Hot Girl is bait, Maeve + Butchers, Church buried --> excavation started

The only thing that gets me, is the church steeple in -30 looks closer to the condition it was in at 0 than -34. Looked like way too much damage for 4 years, unless maybe there was a fire or something, but it didn't look burned. Did it? Also, why bury the whole valley and not bring in one more truck of dirt to put a little mound over the steeple, or knock it down first?
 

Mega

Banned
I believe he was chosen because he looked liked the freshest Host she came upon. They others looked gooey from years of storage.

I thought this was obvious. If she's trying to use a bot to sneak stuff out, you want the one that doesn't look like a decomposing zombie.

I wouldn't be surprised if all the 'butchers' were all hosts. The...routine violence and bloodshed would be hard to stomach for normal people. Would explain why they stick with her, instead of running to management the second shes back in the park and they are safe.

and i'm wagering the other killed girl, who is only on 'vacation' is the new host being built. Why though, is the question? Maybe ford wants another behavioral specialist in his pocket for some reason?

I personally think all of the people sculpting and building out hosts are hosts themselves. The work looks incredibly boring and tedious. Every one of them we saw looked very single-minded in their task and it may explain why none of them pay attention when Felix is giving Maeve the tour. We already had the blonde host working the floor as a tour guide so it's not farfetched to have them doing much more boring work like sculpting noses and eyebrows, dressing the hosts, teaching them basic movement, etc.
 

Chumley

Banned
Nolan himself is directing episode 10. Can't wait for that.

If only he could get the one true god to direct an episode

6726_tn.jpg
 

Corpekata

Banned
Probably discussed but the black scientist lady in Dolores' flashback is clearly young Bernard's "wife" / young Gina Torres, right?
 
Ford gets tired of making "Westworld 2", "Westworld 3", "Westworld: Reach" and wants out,

Where's "Westworld: MiB", with it's gloomy noir atmosphere/soundtrack and Nathan Fillion?

And yeah, last night's episode was more of a clunker than any of the robots. Maeve's plot continues to be the worst of the pile, and Harris and Hopkins continue to carry the show.
 
Top Bottom