Currently playing the Sinking City and so far it´s really good. It´s kinda like old school Silent Hill with H.P Lovecrafts collected work as backdrop for the setting and story. I see a little bit of Dagon, Chtulhu and Innsmouth as well as other influences and they all come together nicely, and the story so far is great, really exciting with all the detective work and mapping out your route.
The atmosphere is phenomenal, with rain pouring down endlessly, spooky houses and citizens that gone bat shit crazy due to a mysterious "curse" that´s plaguing the town. You pick up evidence as you go, talking to towns folks and shoot nasty creatures in the face. The monster design is ripped straight out of Silent Hill and I love it. The combat is clunky as shit but it does the job, SH was clunky as hell too and it didn´t really affect the overall quality of the games.
I´ve been on a real Lovecraft-bender recently. I played through Call of Cthulhu, it was okay, story and characters were good but the gameplay kinda sucked and it was short too, and now it´s Sinking City. After that I will buy Sundered: Eldritch Edition and Lovecrafts Untold Stories. I´ve also ordered Castle Freak on Blu-ray which is based on one of his short stories and some books with his collected works to see and read during christmas. Love this mans stories.