I will try out both in a new anime. Whichever I prefer I go with. Find modern dubs to be really good. Hell I rewatch one piece episodes as new ones come out in dub since I caught up to episode 900 something before switching to manga and at the time the dub stopped at 500 something. Black clover, one piece, attack on titan, Dragonball, my hero academia, and several other shows I prefer dub or it's a wash and I go with my native language to get more connected emotionally with what they're saying.
Also the reason live action doesn't work for me and anime does is that the lip flaps match just as well with English as Japanese and the two actors are doing the same process. Hell the Japanese version is still a dub really as they still have to watch the animation and speak their lines into it