Having just finished my Top 10 for 2016 in the GOTY thread, it actually impressed me greatly how varied and not homogeneous it was.
Another game that I love is Abe's Exoddus.
This cover art is so darn good. I look at it and think "exactly."It's the only serious answer.
Notice, I also said innovation, and I didn't say every single game was the same. There's a reason the years from 2007 and before are considered the golden years of gaming.
Also, look at how many remasters or games that don't actually offer anything new that are on your list and then look at the list of games in your first post of this very thread.
Wow, 1998, what a year. For me, it definitely has to be Resident Evil 2. It was my first Resi game, and the first game i ever bought for my PS1. I would watch that FMV intro over, and over. I knew it off by heart. "That guys a maniac...Whayd he bite me?!"
The sheer amount of content in it too, 4 different endings, 2 different scenarios, i played it non stop. One of the best gaming experiences ive ever had.
edit
Yall need to stop using the awful US box art for Resi 2.