Will humanity ever give up eating meat? When?

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's animals, not other people.
igUbhfk2ASrTt.gif
 
The big problem is people consuming long form meat (like Beef or Tuna) where in the growth period of the animal is substantial in terms of the resources it consumes to reach maturity versus short form like chicken, which mature rapidly and don't consume massive amounts of resources.

Yes and not only that, we don't eat it responsibly.

This chart is pretty crazy, What It Takes To Make A Quarter-Pound Hamburger:
gr-burgers-462.gif


Meat consumption averages 107 pounds per year.
gr-meat-topper-462.gif

Just imagine all the meat you eat in one life on one pile...


More info here:
http://www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2012/06/27/155527365/visualizing-a-nation-of-meat-eaters
 
Even if humans found a way to create meat in a lab, the animals would most likely die off anyway. Dairy cows would be kept for milk, but the space used to rear cattle and pigs for meat would be used to grow crops etc instead. Those little piggies ain't gunna have anywhere to live

Yeah, this is a thing that the "meat is mean" folks don't quite grasp. We aren't gonna keep those things around or let 'em loose. What the hell is a "feral cow" or "feral chicken" gonna do? We domesticated them over thousands of years, and they don't flip that switch and become independent of us any more than a puppy would. Some animals can make that jump (pigs, goats), but a lot cannot, and even if they do they become pests (pigs). At best, you just stop letting them breed and feed them until they all die off, and that assumes that people are going to be willing to feed something that no longer has any economic benefit. Pigs make decent pets, but cows and chickens leave a lot to be desired. The most likely scenario is that we go out and kill them all to the last hoof rather than watch them starve. So, I guess they're saved in that there's no more of them except what's in zoos and preserves. Yay PETA.

It really annoys me that we'd still have a use for all our other meat species, but pigs are just screwed.
Pigs make pretty good pets. They're smart animals, but a certain level of obstinance comes with that intelligence. You have to keep them entertained or they will make their own entertainment. They will open refrigerators and eat what they can. They will open cabinets and eat all that shit. They can also have dominance issues, and will attempt to dominate humans and other animals if they aren't socialized and taught that the humans are "top pig" (no shit). You can train them quite easily to respond to commands, to fetch, and to walk on a leash. Basically think of them like a bulldog that isn't an incredible dumbass.
 
People will never give up eating meat, but I think in this century "no-kill meat", synthetically grown, will become more popular than farmed meat.
 
Our teeth mostly resemble that of gorilla

Our digestive system struggles with meat

We weren't designed to consume meat, we just choose to do it (sometimes have to for survival especially in freezing climates)

Just because we can process the food doesn't mean we were designed for it, they even feed pigs meat these days

Wat?
 
Yeah, this is a thing that the "meat is mean" folks don't quite grasp. We aren't gonna keep those things around or let 'em loose. What the hell is a "feral cow" or "feral chicken" gonna do? We domesticated them over thousands of years, and they don't flip that switch and become independent of us any more than a puppy would. Some animals can make that jump (pigs, goats), but a lot cannot, and even if they do they become pests (pigs). At best, you just stop letting them breed and feed them until they all die off, and that assumes that people are going to be willing to feed something that no longer has any economic benefit. Pigs make decent pets, but cows and chickens leave a lot to be desired. The most likely scenario is that we go out and kill them all to the last hoof rather than watch them starve. So, I guess they're saved in that there's no more of them except what's in zoos and preserves. Yay PETA.


Pigs make pretty good pets. They're smart animals, but a certain level of obstinance comes with that intelligence. You have to keep them entertained or they will make their own entertainment. They will open refrigerators and eat what they can. They will open cabinets and eat all that shit. They can also have dominance issues, and will attempt to dominate humans and other animals if they aren't socialized and taught that the humans are "top pig" (no shit). You can train them quite easily to respond to commands, to fetch, and to walk on a leash. Basically think of them like a bulldog that isn't an incredible dumbass.

Exactly this, too. I do wonder if many anti-meat eaters realize that they are arguing for the extinction of domesticated livestock.
 
Exactly this, too. I do wonder if many anti-meat eaters realize that they are arguing for the extinction of domesticated livestock.
Sorry, this is just black and white to the extreme. Worldwide meat consumption will have doubled in 2050.
We're as far from the extinction of cows and pigs as from reaching another solar system.
 
Exactly this, too. I do wonder if many anti-meat eaters realize that they are arguing for the extinction of domesticated livestock.
I'm going to go out on a limb and predict we'll come up with an alternative to this supposed binary dilemma whereupon factory farming and extinction are the only two choices.
 
Sorry, this is just black and white to the extreme. Worldwide meat consumption will have doubled in 2050.
We're as far from the extinction of cows and pigs as from reaching another solar system.

It's still the end result of the vegetarian argument and the topic of this very thread.

Will humanity ever stop eating meat? If it does, many of those animals will cease to exist.

I'm going to go out on a limb and predict we'll come up with an alternative to this supposed binary dilemma whereupon factory farming and extinction are the only two choices.

I agree that factory farming is problematic. I spend most of my food money supporting local sustainable farms where the cows eat only grass.
 
The more important and realistic goal IMO is to reform factory farming practices, for both moral and sustainability ends.

I kill the meat I eat, or I will purchase it from free range, grass fed local farms.

You can too.
 
I don't have any moral objections to eating meat OP. And by that logic we shouldn't eat any vegetables as they're living things aswell.
 
Isnt there a direct correlation between animal protein consumption and human brain development?

Yep, we wouldn't be where we are today.
And Vegans still require B12, or they would have nervous system damage.
(Some probably do, cause they didn't research their ethical diet)

They get it through supplements.
Where do you think B12 is extracted from?
 
Isnt there a direct correlation between animal protein consumption and human brain development?

That's why vegans are so dumb!

I think I've heard something like that before, but never bookmarked the paper/study. I don't need scientific rationalization to enjoy meat :).
 
We probably eat too much meat in our diets, but no meat is probably even only slightly better than that. A little of meat, preferably not red, and fish, it's paramount to healty lifes anyway.
 
Yep, we wouldn't be where we are today.
And Vegans still require B12, or they would have nervous system damage.

They get it through supplements.
Where do you think B12 is extracted from?

I've read that some vegans actually do okay without the B12 supplements, because they can potentially get it from eating leafy vegetables. Why's that? Because of the insect wing and leg particulates which are never *completely* washed from the folds of said veggies. Could be bullshit, but a funny thought either way.
 
It will only happen when people forget that humans are humans and animals are animals which I highly doubt will happen.
 
Kind of interesting to see where Luxenbourg and Australia ended up being....

I live near Luxembourg, gotta ask them what the hell is up with that :D
This is a one million state that can't even produce lots of meat...
It's probably because they eat a lot in restaurants.

The more important and realistic goal IMO is to reform factory farming practices, for both moral and sustainability ends.

I kill the meat I eat, or I will purchase it from free range, grass fed local farms.

You can too.
Yes, that would be the first step. I don't really see that happening though, unless there's pressure from the state at some point. Most people (in this thread) don't even consider sustainability, so there's that...
 
I've read that some vegans actually do okay without the B12 supplements, because they can potentially get it from eating leafy vegetables. Why's that? Because of the insect wing and leg particulates which are never *completely* washed from the folds of said veggies. Could be bullshit, but a funny thought either way.

There is a way to do it, eat unwashed veggies like cattle do with grass.
It's the dirt, we usually wash that all away.
(The cattle absorbs the B12 and gives it to us)

Also Marmite is another Vegan friendly way to do it without supplements.

But how would our ancestors know how to do this?
We're only here because they ate what was needed to survive properly.
 
I think it's pretty well supported that our heavy meat diet supported our evolution to the humans we are today.

Score! Suck it vegetables.

Yep, we wouldn't be where we are today.
And Vegans still require B12, or they would have nervous system damage.
(Some probably do, cause they didn't research their ethical diet)

They get it through supplements.
Where do you think B12 is extracted from?

Isn't vitamin d deficiency also an issue for vegetarians/vegans?

That's why vegans are so dumb!

I think I've heard something like that before, but never bookmarked the paper/study. I don't need scientific rationalization to enjoy meat :).

Nor should you. If god didnt want you to eat bacon then why'd he make it so tasty?
 
Yep, we wouldn't be where we are today.
And Vegans still require B12, or they would have nervous system damage.
(Some probably do, cause they didn't research their ethical diet)

They get it through supplements.
Where do you think B12 is extracted from?

B12 supplements are largely made from modified yeast, at least it was last time I checked.
 
Isn't vitamin d deficiency also an issue for vegetarians/vegans?

You do get it more in non-vegan food.
But some fruits an veggies contain it.
Which can then be extracted and put into supplements.

Living on supplements is not a way for most people to live though.
As it's not cost effective.
It's a 1st world thing.

I was considering being a vegan at one point, but I researched it as much as I could.
Didn't want to harm my body because of a poor diet.

The one diet I'd probably go down to is Pescatarian.
Seems pretty well balanced and more sustainable.

B12 supplements are largely made from modified yeast, at least it was last time I checked.

I put that in a post above. (marmite)
 
Meat gave our ancestors the sustinance needed for us to evolve and develop the society we live in today. Now thanks to worldwide trade you have a constant supply of vegetables that come from different parts of the world different times of the year to ensure that you have food to eat. Basically humanity and society exist currently as it is because of meat.

They also ate raw meat which we moved past. But that's not the point. The point is that nothing you write in this paragraph in any way, shape or form argues why we should eat meat now when there's options that gives us as much sustenance, especially if you start discussing ethics. Of course we're only talking about people who have the option to do so without. Your argument seems as valid to me as it would be to argue for oil instead of working for alternative energy resources (preferably working and efficient such, then) because we've used it to achieve some great things, pollution aside.
 
Living on supplements is not a way for most people to live though.
As it's not cost effective.
It's a 1st world thing.

I was considering being a vegan at one point, but I researched it as much as I could.
Didn't want to harm my body because of a poor diet.

I entirely disagree that you'd harm your body being vegan. While the cost might be a more valid point (I'm not sure, I've never researched the cost), a vegan diet with proper supplements is entirely healthy and sustainable.
 
other countries that have to live off the land are in their right. I understand their meat consumption. For the first world? never. the first world is too ungrateful and apathetic. most people have little care for their personal health. want to fill themselves with fast food (there are people on this forum that talk about new wendy's burgers in their free time). in general humanity will continue to eat meat until a corporation is able to make something in a lab that is more processed (and super cheap to produce) and give everyone cancer.
 
They also ate raw meat which we moved past. But that's not the point. The point is that nothing you write in this paragraph in any way, shape or form argues why we should eat meat now when there's options that gives us as much sustenance, especially if you start discussing ethics. Of course we're only talking about people who have the option to do so without. Your argument seems as valid to me as it would be to argue for oil instead of working for alternative energy resources (preferably working and efficient such, then) because we've used it to achieve some great things, pollution aside.

We are moving towards that though.
Lab grown meat will become more sustainable due to the land required for livestock.

Living on supplements is not the answer.

Also testing on animals has been used for so many things that helped us get we are too...
(We can now use robots, well not for everything)

Organic Vegans are in line to destroy the earth just as much as people that need land for livestock.
The land required for organic produce can't be ignored.
We'd have to ask half the human population to starve.
(they're starving already, but that's due to greed)
GMO produce is the only way we can feed our growing population...

I entirely disagree that you'd harm your body being vegan. While the cost might be a more valid point (I'm not sure, I've never researched the cost), a vegan diet with proper supplements is entirely healthy and sustainable.

I meant it that, if I didn't do the research, I'd harm myself by doing the diet improperly, like a lot of vegans do.
(Some people just jump in, not knowing how to do it properly)
 
That's why vegans are so dumb!

You should refrain from such comments, if you are only using superficial knowledge...

There isn't some magic brain-growing ingredient in meat, it was just an important factor for carb intake, combined with cooked food and other factors.

"At the core of this research is the understanding that the modern human brain consumes 20 percent of the body’s energy at rest, twice that of other primates. Meat and cooked foods were needed to provide the necessary calorie boost to feed a growing brain."

http://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...4d36de-326d-11e2-bb9b-288a310849ee_story.html

That's also why morbidly obese people don't become super geniuses...
 
I meant it that, if I didn't do the research, I'd harm myself by doing the diet improperly, like a lot of vegans do.
(Some people just jump in, not knowing how to do it properly)

Haha, oh I see. That's an entirely valid reason.

Sorry for misunderstanding.
 
You do get it more in non-vegan food.
But some fruits an veggies contain it.
Which can then be extracted and put into supplements.

Living on supplements is not a way for most people to live though.
As it's not cost effective.
It's a 1st world thing.

I was considering being a vegan at one point, but I researched it as much as I could.
Didn't want to harm my body because of a poor diet.

The one diet I'd probably go down to is Pescatarian.
Seems pretty well balanced and more sustainable.


I put that in a post above. (marmite)

Interesting. How much harder is it to follow that diet without supplements?
 
i love eating meat and i don't think its wrong in any way, the strong kills the weak, this also applies to wild animals. so why we should be any different?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom