Jex
Member
lol duckroll hounding me over a film i've already seen
Unjustified bullying strikes again.
lol duckroll hounding me over a film i've already seen
I think it might even be fair to say that KyoAni is one of, if not the best, studios at making changes to original source material for the purposes of making it into a good TV series.
So it's the best opinion?Truly the Endless Eight of Hyouka opinions.
That sounds pretty awesome actually! I want this!Waiting for the day KyoAni gets a ShonenJump manga to do, school sports club hopefully.
The second cour of Bungou Stray Dogs has stayed with me for a while now and I really need to put forth some ideas about the show just to get it out of my system..
OK. I haven't read the novel either, so I was just going of my memory of what I've heard people said about it. I've just heard a lot of people calling KyoAni an evil and/or incompetent organization that continually screws up the material they adapt, and specifically comments such as "Naoko Yamada's hobbies are promoting traditional social values and crushing the dreams of yuri fans" - an assertion that seems dubious, to say the least. I think such comments, coming from people who haven't read the original works in question and are just going off hearsay, should be kept in check. Your last sentence seems dangerously close to assuming that Takeda is unhappy with how KyoAni has chosen to adapt her work, which is something I don't see any reason to assume.
I have my own problems with Sound Euphonium, especially the second season, problems which I believe are likely due both partly to the author's original work and partly to the choices made in the adaptation process. But I think KyoAni is too often made into a punching bag for unjustified reasons, and I don't think they're incompetent or malicious or cynical, broadly speaking.
Just wanted to highlight this excellent post because it's great.
I mean I could have just saidCan everyone stop being so polite and understanding? That's not how the Internet is supposed to work.
I mean I could have just said
"But Doremi is shit."
But that would be a lie so hot I would have caught fire.
To be clear, I really did enjoy Sound Euphonium, and i'm a pretty big fan of KyoAni's works in general. I loved K-On, Hyouka is one of my all time favorite anime, and their adaptation of Maid Dragon gives me life. I'm not some bitter yuri fan, and I wasn't trying to imply that Takeda was unhappy with KyoAni's adaptation either. Their handling of certain relationship dynamics aside, they've made a ridiculous amount of improvements to the source material, and the anime (overall) is absolutely great. I just wanted to set the record straight regarding my problems with the show.
From all the series that are out there, Euphonium or LWA are not exactly where I would spend my efforts discussing.
My overall feelings for this season with 3 episodes watched of each show I'm watching (LWA I'm waiting till Netflix gets off its ass)
5 = Average
Shouwa Genroku Rakugo Shinjuu: Sukeroku Futatabi-hen: It's more Rakugo, really what else is there to say but singing its praises? 8.5/10
Gintama.: More Gintama, off to a better start then the previous season with the director learning some of what worked and didn't work last time around. 7.5/10
Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon: KyoAni is doing a great job adapting this, 90% of the changes they have made were for the best. 7/10
Kono Subarashii Sekai ni Shukufuku wo! 2: The gang of assholes are back again and even more deformed, sorta enjoying the lack of Darkness so far. 6.5/10
Demi-chan wa Kataritai: A decent adaption so far. I have some issues here and there, but since I know the source material and assume they won't stray to far I can put to rest some of those concerns. 6/10
Ao no Exorcist: Kyoto Fujouou-hen: I don't particularly like this arc in the manga and with how slow of an adaption it will need to be to make it 12 episodes doesn't help it. 4.5/10
Gabriel DropOut: It's pretty like all Doga Koba shows, but its just not translating great from manga to anime so far. 4/10
Akiba's Trip The Animation: This is trash, but its slightly fun trash that doesn't annoy me. 3/10
ēlDLIVE: CHUTA, CHUTA, CHUTA, CHUTA, CHUTA! Every single bad aspect of Hitman Reborn rolled up into a single package...at least its ending can't possibly make me rage like HR's manga did....2.5/10
Nyanko Days: I like the ending song I guess...2/10
Minami Kamakura Koukou Joshi Jitensha-bu (DROPPED): This just felt insulting to watch (yes lets make the MC girl have the mental ability of an infant!), its only plus is the pretty backgrounds. 1.5/10
Fortunately the Sound Euphonium novel will be coming out in English, so we'll all be able to buy and read it and have a fully informed opinion then.
It's still for children if that is what you are asking.Wait, it is? That's awesome.
It's an actual novel and not a light novel right?
It's still for children if that is what you are asking.
Wish Yen Press was more consistent with their ebook releases. Why isn't Rokka: Braves of the Six Flowers available digitally?
I imagine format availability is up to the licensor.
It's still for children if that is what you are asking.
Which is odd considering both are available digitally on amazon.co.jp.
Gundam IBO - 41
You. Have got. To be. Fucking kidding me. IBO pls.
I did find Sukeroku's death a little too soap opera, but that's just me. It didn't kill the series or the characters or even the impact of his death on the characters for me, but it was a bit much.
GUNDAM SECOND SEASON CURSE
GUNDAM SECOND SEASON CURSE
The way events unfolded in that scene were a little hard to believe imo, like how do you people move so quickly?I did find Sukeroku's death a little too melodramatic, but that's just me. It didn't kill the series or the characters or even the impact of his death on the characters for me, but it was a bit much.
GUNDAM SECOND SEASON CURSE
GUNDAM SECOND SEASON CURSE
I'm fucking triggered. Two weeks in a row of this shit.
Did they introduce some magic of some kind? Please tell me they did that because I've been calling that ever since this show started airing a year and a half ago.
Youjo Senki 1
I have no idea why I expected anything actually good here.
I did find Sukeroku's death a little too melodramatic, but that's just me. It didn't kill the series or the characters or even the impact of his death on the characters for me, but it was a bit much.
I think there's a good argument to be had about it being a little too theatrical but it's something I'm willing to accept in a show obsessed with performers.
The way events unfolded in that scene were a little hard to believe imo, like how do you people move so quickly?