Support NeoGAF

[CornBurrito]

that said, all that means is that scrafty's claim is potentially a real role as opposed to a fake claim, but I lean towards it not being a fake claim and in fact her actual role, just, she's neutral.

What's her win condition? Or you think she's a Commuter/Killer combo?

 

[squidyj]

What's her win condition? Or you think she's a Commuter/Killer combo?

I don't know what her win condition would be.

 

[CornBurrito]

Can we get an update on the current vote nin?

 

[Blargonaut]

request

oh wait someone else already did it for you

I see



well



Just good business

 

[nin1000]

oh wait someone else already did it for you

I see



well



Just good business

I think i will have to say something in here since no one adressed it

 

[cabot]

A heel or someone who kills those that visit them between rounds, brother. LA DIABLA feels it could be either.

Well it's unlikely to be a scum. Splinters pm doesn't say he dies if he gives a gift to a scum.

Why did you think a heel could kill the gift giver?

 

[Matt Attack]

I see Ultron as normal, that's why I don't go after him. He's not super active, but when he posts I find them worthwhile.

Matt Attack has lessened but yesterday he was a town lean read, because he seemed to formulate his own opinion on issues at hand, his opinions didn't feel like harmless ones that most other people had.

Specifically I refer to his feelings on testing batsnacks voting power, it was against the majority rule. He hasn't been good enough today though and needs to step up.

VOTE: Matt Attack

Hey, just wanna pop in and say that I'm here. I feel really bad saying this but I'm honestly pretty overwhelmed by the pace of the game thus far, which in combination with the fact that I'm both pretty sick and was really busy on Easter is why I've kind of been MIA this phase. I'm trying to get caught up now so I'll leave some preliminary thoughts here.

A) I strongly feel that Scrafty is town now. Call it a gut read if you want, but looking over her posts I really don't get the feeling that La Diabla is working against town. I also think that it's in scum's best interest to keep the focus directed towards her, because enough people seem to have remained cautious about her that it's a pretty safe move.

B) My initial thoughts on our lynch is that we should go after Salva or Ultron, neither of whom I feel very good about. Personally I lean towards Ultron being the slightly more likely scum from these two. I think I've seen the word "safe" thrown around for his play this game, and I'm very much inclined to agree- I just looked through all of his posts and it seems like a whole lot of nothing to me (moreso than Terrabyte, who has come under fire as well for not having much on offer.) Plus, he seems to want to lynch Scrafty (who I believe is town) so that we can figure out what happened with the votes D1. If she does flip scum/neutral then this is probably a moot point, but I really don't think that's going to happen, which makes this sort of reasoning seem like a good way for scum to make a mislynch appear more palatable to town. My reservations with lynching Ultron lie with the fact that he hasn't posted much (apparently this is in line with his regular play?). There are enough unknowns in addition to other relatvely inactive posters that an Ultron lynch feels like it might be a bit of a gamble at this point. Salva's flip would probably give us much more material to work with, and I get bad enough vibes that I could easily justify voting for him.

VOTE: SalvaPot

C) I'd like to reexamine Kawl, both because of nukedeggs' reasoning, squidy's insistence, and a general off feeling I'm getting from his D2 posts so far. Felt mostly okay about him on D1 but there have been some good points against him today. I feel like I might be missing something though, because squidy seems really damn sure he's scum and I don't think I'll be able to be that convinced. I also have totally null reads on Bronx and Stanley. Gonna have to look at them more, although due to his situation it might be tough to make a case against Bronx at this point (although his D2 posts are pretty confrontational?).

C) Having considered my feelings on the matter for a while, I definitely think that the focus on the non-WWE flavor being a part of WWE Mafia is weird, like RNH pointed out. I can sort of understand the concerns, but I don't feel like this sort of reliance on flavor would fly in the other games I've been a part of. Cabot has been the most vocal on this subject, and while I do feel pretty good about him being town (Magnum was concerned about this too and he was town, so it definitely doesn't have to be a scum tell), it feels kind of weird to me that he brought it up again today even after Ouro came in and said that it wouldn't be impossible for non-WWE roles to show up.

Let me know if anybody has any issues with anything I've said because you probably will. Been staring at this thread for like 2 hours now trying to make up for my absence and my eyes feel like they're gonna fall out.

 

[ScraftyDevil]

Well it's unlikely to be a scum. Splinters pm doesn't say he dies if he gives a gift to a scum.

Why did you think a heel could kill the gift giver?

There are some superstars so VOLATILE that they KILL ALL WHO APPROACH THEM. Is it not impossible that one such superstar could be a HEEL?

 

[nin1000]

oh wait someone else already did it for you

I see



well



Just good business

i am dissaspointed that you didn't do the banners in time

 

[cabot]

There are some superstars so VOLATILE that they KILL ALL WHO APPROACH THEM. Is it not impossible that one such superstar could be a HEEL?

I don't know we've not seen anything of a veteran yet, so I've yet to be sure.

 

[CornBurrito]

So nin didn't provide vote counts, but it seems were largely split today between Kawl, Scrafty, Salva.

Salva is personally who I think is the scum among those three.

I do think we get the most valuable info out of a Scrafty flip, especially if she is scum, but I don't know if we can afford to do that with 4 deaths. If one of those 4 was caused by a neutral we have at least 2 again on our plate tomorrow.

Squidy has been pushing Kawl hard and Kawl kind of seems defeated. But squidy being most likely town doesn't make him right. Multiple people have picked up "lynch Kawl" motto and I think that means Kawl really is town. He's too easy a lynch it feels like.

 

[squidyj]

So nin didn't provide vote counts, but it seems were largely split today between Kawl, Scrafty, Salva.

Salva is personally who I think is the scum among those three.

I do think we get the most valuable info out of a Scrafty flip, especially if she is scum, but I don't know if we can afford to do that with 4 deaths. If one of those 4 was caused by a neutral we have at least 2 again on our plate tomorrow.

Squidy has been pushing Kawl hard and Kawl kind of seems defeated. But squidy being most likely town doesn't make him right. Multiple people have picked up "lynch Kawl" motto and I think that means Kawl really is town. He's too easy a lynch it feels like.

no. I find his defeat and collapse to be disingenuous, doesn't read as legitimate at all to me.

 

[Palmer_v1]

I want a Kawl lynch at this point, but if we hadn't lost 4 people, I'd consider the Scrafty Lynch just to get more info. How many people are lynching her for being scum, and how many are lynching her just because they want info, or both?

On one hand, we could learn something definitive about the fluff, but I don't really CARE about that. What I really want to see is how her flip related to Kalor, and the people who have been after her.

There's also the inactives that aggravate me. I think Stanley and TB are still the most egregious right now, though they did show up to post a bit.

 

[CornBurrito]

no. I find his defeat and collapse to be disingenuous, doesn't read as legitimate at all to me.

It is possible.

 

[StanleyPalmtree]

reading through Kawl's posts, the imperceptible collection of sarcasm and fluff makes me feel like im looking at a Jackson Pollok painting. Its a bunch of colors strewn with no perceptible rhyme or reason, maybe he has some meaning behind it all, but hell if i cant figure it out. All in all its getting far more attention than its worth.

so Kawl, if you could give us a simple list on who you think is suspect, no sarcasm, no bullshit, just short and simple suspicions, i think it would help me and likely several others here to figure out just where we stand with you, not to mention how it may help us finally move past this very convoluted and distracting topic.

 

[nin1000]

CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Kawl_USC (7)
squidyj .1470
Blargonaut .1718
Nukedeggs. 1611
Palmer_v1 .1641
Bronx-Man . 1745
Batsnacks . 1750
Batsnacks . 1750

Bronx-Man (1)
cabot .1448. 1758
CornBurrito .1520

ScraftyDevil (4)
Burbeting .1416
SalvaPot .1453
Ultron87. 1612
StanleyPalmtree .1652

SalvaPot (2)
nukedeggs .1399
Matt Attack . 1807

StanleyPalmtree (0)
Palmer_v1 .1510

nukedeggs (0)
cabot .1411 .1448

CornBurrito (1)
ScraftyDevil. 1617

Terrabyte20xx (0)
Cabot . 1758


mattattack(1)
Cabot . 1777


No active vote for Day 2:
Kawl_USC
RobotNinjaHornets
Terrabyte20xx



Day 2 ends:

9 votes for majority

Done on mobile

 

[Burbeting]

Sorry, I haven't been able to read or post in the thread today due to having bit of a hectic day. I'll do my best to return tomorrow full-force!

 

[SalvaPot]

Blarg pretty much killed the discussion yesterday and to be honest the day start was highly demoralizing. We are 5 towns down in a single Day/night cycle and we are not any closer to hitting a scum target tonight. The only players I have strong feelings for are squid (I said why) and scrafty (I also said why). If I am lynched because of how scummy I am playing then so be it, my flip will be quite telling, for now I want to see who can resist to hammer..

Vote: Kawl_USC

One more vote to let it down, who wants to do it?

 

[Kawl_USC]

Vote: Kawl_USC

 

[Burbeting]

Fuck, the game is this close to turbo?

I'll read the thread through then again now, though it's 2am here.

 

[Burbeting]

Hey, wait.

Thanks for giving me the time guys.

 

[Ourobolus]

THE DAY HAS ENDED

 

[Kawl_USC]

for now I want to see who can resist to hammer..



One more vote to let it down, who wants to do it?

I've always wanted to hammer.

 

[StanleyPalmtree]

I've always wanted to hammer.

no sarcasm, no bullshit, straight to the point, thanks man. exactly what i was after.

 

[Gorlak]

LOOOOOL

 

[Ourobolus]

SHUT UP

 

[Bronx-Man]

Interesting how there's suddenly multiple posts claiming that Scrafty is town. Almost as if scum is trying to protect scum.

 

[CornBurrito]

Igame talk

Day ended.

 

[Ourobolus]

Bronx, the day is over. Hush while I type up the end of day.

 

[SalvaPot]

I've always wanted to hammer.

I am not even mad.

 

[squidyj]

well shit.

 

[Ourobolus]

DAY 2 HAS ENDED

Kawl_USC stood in the center of the ring, surrounded by the personification of steroid abuse, and he screamed towards the ring announcer, "I DEMAND A TRIAL!"

Jim Ross smiled, then deftly grabbed his microphone and brought it to his lips. "Well then! We have something more suitable to a man of you talents! Away with you!"

Kawl clapped his hands as the audience and the ring gave way, only to be quickly replaced by another arena. Kawl gazed around, and noted that it was somewhat...familiar...

A large, muscular man stood on top of a platform high above Kawl, his hands gripping what appeared to be a large cannon of some sort. Behind him was a giant bullseye, for some weird reason. The man laughed heartily, calling out to Kawl, "KAWWWWWWWWWLLLLL! IT IS I, NITRO, WHO WILL BE YOUR JUDGE, JURY, AND...EXECUTIONER TODAY!"

Kawl's eyes went wide with horror. "Oh, no. You have got to be kidding me."

"WHAT, WERE YOU EXPECTING FUCKING MALIBU? THAT JACKASS ONLY LASTED ONE SEASON!"

Jim Ross suddenly appeared and clapped his hands once more. Kawl's WWE attire magically changed into a bright orange leotard, the fabric and elastic barely containing his body. "Kawl, before you you will find several nerf guns. They are totally accurate. Trust me on this. If you can hit the target behind Nitro in the next sixty seconds, you'll be free to go. If Nitro manages to hit you with his cannon, then you're done for.

"What? Can't we just joust or something?"

"We could. But we'll save that for later. GO!" Jim Ross rang the bell.

Kawl tumbled forward behind the first barricade and grabbed the Nerf gun, and took careful aim at the target behind Nitro. He pulled the trigger, and his eyes shined brightly as the missile flew true, only to suddenly be knocked out of the way by Nitro's heavy breathing.

"My turn!" Nitro yelled. He pulled the trigger as Kawl ducked down behind the styrofoam barricade, waiting for the tennis ball to hit.

Jim Ross turned to Kawl, "Oh. Forgot to mention. Couldn't find any tennis balls, so we went with M1A1 120mm rounds."

"Wha-" Kawl gasped as he suddenly exploded in a shower of limbs and testosterone.

"...probably should have mentioned that earlier," Jim lamented.

Kawl_USC has been eliminated!

Congratulations, you are Goldberg!

You are one hell of a man but years of heavy steroid usage have taken its toll.

Your brain shrunk down to the size of a pea but at least you know how to vote!

Every Day phase, you are able to Vote in order to throw someone out of the ring.

You are aligned with Town

You win when all Mafia-aligned players have been eliminated.

If there are any questions left feel free to ask

The game thread can be found here

You can Subscribe to the thread here.

Please confirm that you received this message by replying to this message as well as posting in the game thread with “my body is ready.”

Good luck and have fun!

Day 3 begins in:
*countdown pending*

 

[nin1000]

 

[nin1000]

What happened?! The crowd was confused and looked at the screen, but nothing of interest was glimmering there. What??... I don't... Why??.. As the audience tried to get a grasp of what happened the match started

cabot has been eliminated from the game

Role pm

Spoiler

Day 3 begins

Players Alive

1. [-] Seath
2. [m] Cabot
3. [m] Bowlie
4. [f] ScraftyDevil
5. [m] Burbeting
6. [m] RetroMG
7. [m] Palmer_v1
8. [m] StanleyPalmtree
9. [m] Kawl_USC
10. [m] Batsnacks
11. [m] Squidyj
12. [m] *Splinter
13. [m] Terrabyte20xx
14. [m] Matt Attack
15. [m] CornBurrito
16. [m] SalvaPot
17. [m] RobotNinjaHornets
18. [m] MagnumBoy20xx
19. [m] Kalor
20. [m] Blargonaut
21. [f] Nukedeggs
22. [m] Ultron87

8 votes needed for a majority

 

[CornBurrito]

Wait... no role PM?

What?

 

[ultron87]

Stupid Time Cube.

 

[Palmer_v1]

WTF

 

[Bronx-Man]

How can someone not get a role PM?

 

[CornBurrito]

Maybe scum has a role that prevents their targets PM from being released? Though this didn't happen yesterday so maybe it is X shot? Or even night only?

Though actually that seems more like an ability a neutral killer would have.

 

[squidyj]

Vote: CornBurrito

 

[Burbeting]

We're now 5 vs 10, if we assume cabot wasn't scum (and why would town have role pm cleaning powers?).

WTF was yesterday, you guys went fo turbo in just bit more than 24 hours.

 

[RobotNinjaHornets]

...wat

 

[ScraftyDevil]

LA DIABLA never got a say in yesterday's proceedings because you jabronis decided to END IT IMMEDIATELY instead of getting as much info as you could first.

VOTE: CornBurrito

LA DIABLA is ridin' this train all the way to the end of the line, OOOOOOOH YEAH

 

[SalvaPot]

Vote: CornBurrito

 

[CornBurrito]

Squidy was so correct about Kawl, I'm glad that Scrafty and Salva just jumped on to his early bandwagon with no explanation.

 

[CornBurrito]

Assuming 5 scum:

If Scrafty and Salva are scum

I have three votes on me, 1 from town and 2 from scum.

5 more votes for majority. 3 more scum potentially. All that needs to happen are two quick town votes and scum could potentially hammer me like Salva did with Kawl yesterday.

I urge people to not allow another turbo to happen.

 

[ultron87]

I'm going to be very pissed if they can already blatantly turbo Corn because the double voter is scum.

 

[SalvaPot]

Assuming 5 scum:

If Scrafty and Salva are scum

I have three votes on me, 1 from town and 2 from scum.

5 more votes for majority. 3 more scum potentially. All that needs to happen are two quick town votes and scum could potentially hammer me like Salva did with Kawl yesterday.

I urge people to not allow another turbo to happen.

I am totally scum, lynch me.

 

[CornBurrito]

I'm going to be very pissed if they can already blatantly turbo Corn because the double voter is scum.

I completely forgot about that possibility.

If batsnacks is scum they only need 1 town voter to hammer me.

Am I off the mark here? Scrafty is complaining about people hammering, but it was pretty much Salva that did the hammer yesterday (or at least turned it into hammerable situation). For someone so annoyed by the hammer Scrafty you don't seem to want to actually confront the person responsible.

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

OK, time out.

First we have no role , which I will assume has to do with that guy Squidy brought up yesterday.

Second, can those who are voting Corn tell me WHY they are, because all I see are votes that are almost halfway to majority.