Most this conversation has nothing to do with the OP.
True. If this deal gets you an XSX without having to pay a scalper then yeah, you've saved money. I don't think the deal is necessarily bad. I just don't think it is revolutionary in any way like the OP.
You've barely even addressed the OP, you have been so occupied with trying to prove that All-Access is a scam that in your mind the thread the OP changed to something entirely different. This thread isn't about whether or not you should pay 2 year or buy upfront (which most Americans do the former) or whether Gamepass can be gotten cheaper. You have created an imaginary thread argument and got a few goof balls along for the ride.
The only time you even sort of address anything is here
People want to point to marketing as why this hasn't taken off. I think most people just know better.
Which still connects to your off-topic "trying to prove it's a scam" argument.
Issue is you are wrong and it's not even an argument you can make, it's a fact that the marketing was poor before and the program was limited. It only started to be taking more seriously with the Xbox One X although you could use it to get a One S as well, and there was much talk online about the "upgrade" process to the Xbox Series consoles so there's clearly a substantial amount of people using the program and Microsoft has put a lot more effort in pushing it.
They went international a couple years ago, increased and are still increasing their retail footprint, the advertising is becoming more common, and they just got the US's NUMBER ONE Wireless Carrier, NUMBER TWO Internet provider, and NUMBER 2 TV provider, Verizon, to sign on to the All Access program. As stock increases Verizon will have more exclusive stock to use, you'll see Xbox All Access signs right next to your Samsung Galaxy Signs, iPhone signs, and LG memorial signs, over 250 million users more than half being unique.
That's a pretty big deal, and unlike the phones, you don't even have to pay tax upfront for your $0 down, you just walk out the store. Most Americans, and even many customers in other countries are part of the debt economy, it's one of the reasons why all these Affirm clones are so popular, people want to manage their budgets and enjoy products they like without having to wait or to subtract too much from their expendable income.
It's not about whether they can "afford" the console or not upfront, that's only an issue half the time, the other half of buyers CAN afford the console but they would rather just may only $35 a month, or $25 a month for the S, which barely scratches their wallet, and not think about it knowing that for such small payments the console will eventually be either eligible to upgrade or paid off in two years, than spending $500 in cash they could use for other things or even savings. Also i they don't mind digital and gamepass they also save monthly on games which in many cases can cost up to $70.
The additional benefit that the Xbox Series X in particular is the most powerful consoles out, and will still likely be the most powerful consoles in two years sweetens the pot, and if there is a another "pro" situation this gen then they'll be able to upgrade and transfer all their stuff over to the new Xbox Series pro consoles for free, $0 down.
The point of the OP is that if this takes off, and it's showing evidence it is, eventually it will become a way to lock millions of people to a companies eco system, and if this plan becomes even half as popular for consoles as it is for phones, than it opens up many of the opportunities I presented in the OP.
btw
And it's not just the Xbox, providers can add their own exclusive deals on top of what All Access provides, Verizon is offering network discounts and a 50% off discount on an Elite controller, one of the other retailers provided a free headset, and will provide other deals across the 2 year installment. Most consumers only see cheap monthly payments and incentives and having All Access reach more stores, more cities, more sites, and more countries is a major step forward toward million of subscribers signing up. Cleary Microsoft is investing more and more into All Access because they are seeing numbers they like there's no other reason why they keep tripling their investment every year.