-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Your frozen pizza of choice?
- Thread starter GeekyDad
- Start date
StreetsofBeige
Gold Member
Never tried Red Baron. But every once in a while when you read people talking pizza Red Baron comes up.This shit is the kryptonite of my diet
I know Walmart Canada had these way back for dirt cheap and I avoided them thinking they were shit. I think even their Great Value pizzas cost more. They also had one called Donnatella's or Donatello's which were also rock bottom priced. Never tried that either. They gutted these bargain brands and just expanded their selection of GV brand and Dr Oetker.
Last edited:
DarkestHour
Banned
Jack’s Pepperoni is the best for the price. Newman’s is the next best. Thin crust is the best because it is nice and crunchy.
West Texas CEO
GAF's Nicest Lunch Thief and Nosiest Dildo Archeologist
PrimetimeKnight
Member
Screamin' Sicilian is the best frozen pizza I've ever had, their sauce is on par and their crust is a healthy balance between thick and thin
I also appreciate their box design and names:
I always thought these looked good in the grocery store, but no way in hell am I paying 7-8 bucks for a frozen pizza.
S
SLoWMoTIoN
Unconfirmed Member
RokkanStoned
Member
Personally... I loved this one, but sadly it went outta production.
Also loved this one (, but it also went outta production.
This one was also kinda good, albeit it also went out of production:
Of those available here in Norway, I've been lately buying these, which are pretty good:
Sometimes I just make my own pizza as well, but frozen pizzas are great for gaming sessions. I'll also order now and then as well, but I feel like good frozen pizzas are kinda different from good restaurant made pizza, so I don't feel like they always compete.
My wife's favorite is:
Also loved this one (, but it also went outta production.
This one was also kinda good, albeit it also went out of production:
Of those available here in Norway, I've been lately buying these, which are pretty good:
Sometimes I just make my own pizza as well, but frozen pizzas are great for gaming sessions. I'll also order now and then as well, but I feel like good frozen pizzas are kinda different from good restaurant made pizza, so I don't feel like they always compete.
My wife's favorite is:
highrider
Banned
I’ve been eating those Stouffers French bread pizzas since I was a kid, I think it’s like a a nostalgia thing. My and my sister used to have them on Saturday nights when my parents were out, we would watch the Love Boat/Fantasy Island. Good times lol. I do think frozen pizza is better when it has kind of something different going for it than just a frozen pie. Definitely Stouffers and even Totinos, which to me is terrible pizza, but not bad for whatever it is lol.
Last edited:
Synless
Member
I came to say this and saw someone else say it, I feel good now.
Pesto does not belong on Pizza!
lachesis
Member
I just ordered flash-frozen pizza from Naples, Italy to NJ... will see how it turns out.
Supposedly it's all baked and all, you just need to heat it up.
Costs quite a bit - $117.28 USD ($109.99 for pizza, free shipping, $7.29 tax) to be exact... for their 8 pizzas (4 margheritas and 4 provolinas) - so each pizza is roughly about $14.66 - relatively comparable to the ones I can buy locally (NY/NJ) - hoping they are at least 12 inches, not personal pan pizza size.
Well, I guess I will be eating a lot of pizza over the holidays.
Supposedly it's all baked and all, you just need to heat it up.
Costs quite a bit - $117.28 USD ($109.99 for pizza, free shipping, $7.29 tax) to be exact... for their 8 pizzas (4 margheritas and 4 provolinas) - so each pizza is roughly about $14.66 - relatively comparable to the ones I can buy locally (NY/NJ) - hoping they are at least 12 inches, not personal pan pizza size.
Well, I guess I will be eating a lot of pizza over the holidays.
Billbofet
Member
I actually worked at the company that makes Screamin' Sicilian (Palermo's) a few years back as an analyst and I agree it is a great frozen pizza.
Not sure if this is a Milwaukee/Midwest only brand, but if you can find King Cheese - also made by Palermo's - grab it. You won't shit for a week due to how heaped it is with cheese, but it will be worth it. Trust.
I worked near the R&D kitchen and gained 8 lbs. in my short run there.
Not sure if this is a Milwaukee/Midwest only brand, but if you can find King Cheese - also made by Palermo's - grab it. You won't shit for a week due to how heaped it is with cheese, but it will be worth it. Trust.
I worked near the R&D kitchen and gained 8 lbs. in my short run there.
BigBooper
Member
Good luck. Living the dream
showernota
Member
Ngl the Walmart Sam’s Choice stuffed crust is pretty good. They have a chicken bacon ranch, and a buffalo chicken I’ve tried, pretty good. I like the digiornos deep dish and croissant crust in a pinch.
Ozzy Onya A2Z
Member
DragoonKain
Neighbours from Hell
Every frozen pizza I've ever eaten has given me extreme heartburn. I haven't eaten it in probably over 10 years now.
DetectiveBananas
Member
Well it sure as hell isn’t a DiGiorno. Bull shit it’s like delivery!
Frito_Pendejo
Member
I like the poverty Ellio’s joints.
highrider
Banned
I like the poverty Ellio’s joints.
Only the 5 cheese are good and they seem to be disappearing
Frito_Pendejo
Member
Cheap? Sure, If you go pick it up. You order a $9 pizza and if you get that shit delivered it somehow ends up being $32 lol
Chiggs
Gold Member
BigBooper
Member
I used to get Dominos on the regular, but since they switched to drive thru only, I'm guaranteed to wait in line at least 15mins and the pizza will be barely lukewarm.
Dthomp
Member
lol, fair enough. I used to always do carry out for that reason. I always end up living close enough to one of them that paying 3.50 Delivery charge plus expected tip, plus always getting the driver wanting to take two orders at a time so mine always shows up luke warm has made me avoid delivery.
D
Deleted member 801069
Unconfirmed Member
I haven't been to a Walmart in like 5 years
Grand Theft Scratchy
Banned
Croissant crust pizza is kind of gross. I like their stuffed crust bacon cheeseburger pizza though.
Ozzy Onya A2Z
Member
I like the poverty Ellio’s joints.
I lost it at "good source of calcium". I found the sixth cheese...cheesy marketing.
rorepmE
Member
School Pizza Pepperoni
Notice: This item is on national backorder. Subscribe to our email alerts for when item is available Cheese Pepperoni Pizza 24 count Topped with tomato sauce, blended mozzarella and diced pepperoni, Pizza Whole Grain Cheese Pepperoni Pizza is just delicious. Its crispy, thin crust is made...
Fuel for dodgeball in PE where I would crush weaker kids with devastating headshots.
Susurrus
Member
School Pizza Pepperoni
Notice: This item is on national backorder. Subscribe to our email alerts for when item is available Cheese Pepperoni Pizza 24 count Topped with tomato sauce, blended mozzarella and diced pepperoni, Pizza Whole Grain Cheese Pepperoni Pizza is just delicious. Its crispy, thin crust is made...www.guintherscustomcuts.com
Fuel for dodgeball in PE where I would crush weaker kids with devastating headshots.
Holy crap you even provided a purchase link. Didn't even know that was possible.
Codes 208
Member
One of the only frozen pizzas that rivals the freshly made pizza joints in terms of cheesiness imo
SS is a good one too, their mambo Italiano and meat lovers are amazing.Screamin' Sicilian is the best frozen pizza I've ever had, their sauce is on par and their crust is a healthy balance between thick and thin
I also appreciate their box design and names:
Last edited:
StreetsofBeige
Gold Member
Kirkland pizzas are good at Costco. But one time I tried one called Stromboli's. It was shit.
Here's a pic I found on the net. Avoid.
Here's a pic I found on the net. Avoid.
Kenpachii
Member
dr Oetker, tuna and curry powder flavour.
It was the definitive snack of the winter i spent in a huge apartment by a private lake in Grunewald, Berlin around the turn it the century..
I like those. So good.
BattleMonkey
Member
It's really good, to me closest to ordering a pizza, but yea for frozen it's expensive. But basically worth it whenever they go on sale. Local supermarkets often mark em down with deals and for the price it's one of the best frozen pies
Through many years of tribulation, I found these (especially the pepperoni) to be the best. I normally prefer a thin crust with a lot of topping, but the Rustica hits a kind of golden balance, even with a fairly thick crust, as the crust is just perfect. Pimp it a little bit with a fresh cheese of your choice (never cover the pepperoni with the cheese), and this might just be the best frozen pizza ever created.
