Support NeoGAF

[Spinosaurus]

All it's gonna take is a character reveal to know whether this is real or not. A 3DS stage reveal works too.

I think it's fake, but I totally dig Doc. I really want him in lol.

 

[j.rob]

I love the smell of leaks in the morning

 

[BY2K]

I love the smell of leaks in the morning

Eeeeewwww.

 

[BGBW]

So what's the bottom left corner stage meant to be?

 

[MAtgS]

I love the smell of leaks in the morning

R U A Farfetched?

 

[IntelliHeath]

All it's gonna take is a character reveal to know whether this is real or not. A 3DS stage reveal works too.

I think it's fake, but I totally dig Doc. I really want him in lol.

Yeah, it's more likely to be fake. Strange enough is that someone said that he leaked the roster, duck hunt dog and dlc but not stage. I swore that it came from same person. Maybe someone pointed out the flaws and they quickly dropped the screen.

I really like all characters so far but again it's good fake.

 

[Red Arremer]

If the leak is real than that means there's 9 Mario characters. =O That's not fair on the other series.

9?

Mario (1), Luigi (2), Peach (3), Bowser (4), Dr. Mario (5), Rosalina (6), Bowser Jr. (7)

Who else did you see here? Yoshi, Donkey, Diddy and Wario, by definition of Smash Bros. itself - and that has been the case since 64, and especially since Brawl due to series getting their own sections in the trophy gallery - represent their own games.

And again, if those 5 remaining spots are filled, that would be 7 out of 53 characters. That's about 1/8. Given the immensity of the Mario series, I don't see how it's "not fair".

 

[Storm Kyleis]

9?

Mario (1), Luigi (2), Peach (3), Bowser (4), Dr. Mario (5), Rosalina (6), Bowser Jr. (7)

Who else did you see here? Yoshi, Donkey, Diddy and Wario, by definition of Smash Bros. itself - and that has been the case since 64, and especially since Brawl due to series getting their own sections in the trophy gallery - represent their own games.

Well, according to the "leak" Yoshi is considered in the same franchise as Mario now.

 

[Makai]

IF this is actually from an ESRB employee that would explain why there's no space between the top and bottom screen, actually. Maybe whoever took the pic did it from a regular video player that includes both.

That makes sense. Maybe a projector? That would explain why it's at an angle.

 

[CHusson91]

It's looking more and more legitimate to me. Not so sure how I feel about Bowser JR. On the otherhand, Dick Hunt Dog's design is awesome.

 

[Neoxon]

Is the DLC thing from the same initial source? If so & it ends up true, they'll have me by the balls.

 

[BGBW]

Well, according to the "leak" Yoshi is considered in the same franchise as Mario now.

Which is disproved by the official site.

 

[-Horizon-]

I love the smell of leaks in the morning

>.>

 

[SuperSah]

What features make this scream legit?

 

[Red Arremer]

Well, according to the "leak" Yoshi is considered in the same franchise as Mario now.

No he's not, this is from the Smash 4 site:

He still has the egg as his icon, not the mushroom. That makes Yoshi its own series still.

Edit: Ninja'd

 

[Jaeger]

We still talking about those 4chan fakeshots?

 

[Makai]

Well, according to the "leak" Yoshi is considered in the same franchise as Mario now.

In the other games, some of the characters are out of order until all characters are unlocked.

EDIT: Doc Mario isn't from Fire Emblem, either.

 

[Baron von Loathsome]

Good morning. I just got caught up, and there have been some really interesting revelations. However, I'm still on #TeamWTF.

Anyway, about my source, yeah, they provided no evidence that they were actually involved in making that picture. However, I figured that it was worth bringing up at the time, on the basis that it was a possible lead.

 

[BGBW]

What features make this scream legit?

Line width

 

[MrSaturn99]

So what's the bottom left corner stage meant to be?

Gaur Plains

 

[IntelliHeath]

Line width

Well. People can research right?

 

[munchie64]

Gaur Plains

I do find it strange they'd include that on 3DS with little new levels for old series.

 

[Jawmuncher]

Chapter 8 of the FanFic

Toxi confirmed for way too evil tier

 

[Chunky]

That Duck Hunt render confirms it, right? How can you be on Team Fake when the leaker would have had to create an excellent 3D model that perfectly matches the smash 4 style?
Any other attempts to debunk this leak seem nitpicky at best.

 

[SuperSah]

That Duck Hunt render confirms it, right? How can you be on Team Fake when the leaker would have had to create an excellent 3D model that perfectly matches the smash 4 style?
Any other attempts to debunk this leak seem nitpicky at best.

Well someone faked the Palutena leak which matched the artstyle 100%.

 

[BGBW]

That Duck Hunt render confirms it, right? How can you be on Team Fake when the leaker would have had to create an excellent 3D model that perfectly matches the smash 4 style?
Any other attempts to debunk this leak seem nitpicky at best.

Because, surprise surprise, making character art isn't unique to the Smash Bros team:

You don't even need a 3D model. If they had a 3D model maybe we'd see some in game screenshots.

 

[Neoxon]

 

[DaBoss]

Super Smash Bros. Thread 13: MC's 24/7 Daycare Service

 

[NotLiquid]

Dun dun dunnnn

 

[BGBW]

http://s17.postimg.org/c59vkwwqn/IMG_76027202793370.jpg

That's probably the weakest attempt to debunk it.

 

[Baron von Loathsome]

Well someone faked the Palutena leak which matched the artstyle 100%.

Don't even go there, that actually can't be proven real or fake. This can.

 

[Storm Kyleis]

No he's not, this is from the Smash 4 site:


He still has the egg as his icon, not the mushroom. That makes Yoshi its own series still.

Edit: Ninja'd

Yeah, I don't believe the leak. I was pointing out that it got Yoshi's franchise wrong.

 

[Diprosalic]

If the leak is real than that means there's 9 Mario characters. =O That's not fair on the other series.

They can get 9 characters when they get as important to Nintendo as the Mario series is.

 

[Berordn]

They can get 9 characters when they get as important to Nintendo as the Mario series is.

Pokemon 20 characters when?

 

[Aβydoς]

If this is true, I'm disappointed for losing Ice Climbers and Snake, but damn the other newcomers are great. Shulk is my most wanted so that's awesome, Duck Hunt Dog is a perfect choice, and I didn't believe in Bowser Jr. anymore which was the best Mario newcomer remaining after Paper Mario.
It's weird to see Dr. Mario returning but not Mewtwo, but the full roster pic made me think that maybe there's still more to unlock. There's space, and seeing the clone characters like the Dr., Lucina and Dark Pit pushed aside is a clear sign. Also, Shulk as the only character with third parties doesn't make any sense.
I want to believe this is real and a few veterans have yet to be unlocked. We haven't seen the "You unlocked every character!" screen, right? And also why should the guy know about DLC? I would be OK to see all the cut characters or almost all return as DLC, but why should he know?

Oh, and I'm totally OK with 9 Mario characters. Should round out to 10 with Paper Mario.

 

[CrazedProfessional]

If real it kinda looks like midway through development Nintendo kidnapped Sakurai and was like
"Listen here Samurai, these are what will sell Amiibo. Make edgey pit and brat bowser characters on the double."

 

[Boss Doggie]

Yeah, the leak would've convinced me more if we see gameplay shots.

 

[The_Intruder]

Aaaand we're done now.

 

[Vampirolol]

Rendering isn't impossible at all, look at this

I'm in teamfake but that Little Mac VS Shulk is dumb. They just don't match, you could overlap Tom Wiseau on Shulk and the result would be the same.

 

[Mit-]

Too much new high quality artwork for me to consider this fake. Also doesn't seem like a final roster.

 

[-Horizon-]

Chapter 8 of the FanFic

Toxi confirmed for way too evil tier

"Heeeaaaathhh…" he whispered. SmashGaf went in closer to hear what his dying word was. "You suck."

lol

And the whole "leak thing" lol

 

[Ricky 7]

9?

Mario (1), Luigi (2), Peach (3), Bowser (4), Dr. Mario (5), Rosalina (6), Bowser Jr. (7)

Who else did you see here? Yoshi, Donkey, Diddy and Wario, by definition of Smash Bros. itself - and that has been the case since 64, and especially since Brawl due to series getting their own sections in the trophy gallery - represent their own games.

And again, if those 5 remaining spots are filled, that would be 7 out of 53 characters. That's about 1/8. Given the immensity of the Mario series, I don't see how it's "not fair".

Well if you're not going to count Yoshi and Wario as Mario characters then it doesn't seem quite as large. I still want more Pokemon characters though. =P

 

[Aβydoς]

Yeah, the leak would've convinced me more if we see gameplay shots.

There is and it's the most fake looking of them all:

I dunno. The renders are great.

 

[NotLiquid]

I'm in teamfake but that Little Mac VS Shulk is dumb. They just don't match, you could overlap Tom Wiseau on Shulk and the result would be the same.

I can see the splash card now

"Johnny enters the room"

 

[Boss Doggie]

There is and it's the most fake looking of them all:

I dunno. The renders are great.

It's been confirmed that that's not part of the source's leak. He only leaked the roster and DLC, the rest are just other people "riding on" the leak.

Rendering isn't impossible at all, look at this

I'm in teamfake but that Little Mac VS Shulk is dumb. They just don't match, you could overlap Tom Wiseau on Shulk and the result would be the same.

I can see the splash card now

"Johnny enters the room"

Oh god

"I did not hit her. I did not. Oh hi Riki"

 

[Diprosalic]

Pokemon 20 characters when?

are you saying pokemanz are more than twice as important as the Mario franchise is?

 

[Neoxon]

So, if this leak is legit, who's getting the DLC?

 

[Teriaaaaa!]

Wow Smash talk moves fast. I'm on #team fake btw but I'm more on the fence then others here.

 

[Diprosalic]

Oh, and I'm totally OK with 9 Mario characters. Should round out to 10 with Paper Mario.

*Koopa Troopa

why does he get no love?

So, if this leak is legit, who's getting the DLC?

I'm getting all the D Nintendo puts out.

 

[-Horizon-]

So, if this leak is legit, who's getting the DLC?

*raises hand*