I don't understand the concern about The Order.
It seems to be a "linear, cinematic third person shooter that heavily combines set pieces and interactive cutscenes with stand cover based shooting"
That is also an exact description of Uncharted, yet no one is worried about Uncharted 4.
I think because they went all in on cinematic....its kind of a huge gamble, so far the only games to get cinematic gaming right have been Uncharted, God of War, Journey and Call of Duty... so many games labeled as "cinematic" end up suffering in the gameplay department because of it so it has people nervous. Two poor demo showings didnt help either as both demos showed of fairly standard TPS shooting in a fairly drab area (graphically) of the game with QTE sequences.
I have no doubt though that RAD is going to knock it out of the park with this one though. I think they showed it a bit to early and the stand out scenes werent ready.