And having them come out no worse for wear, wearing what looks like freshly pressed and steamed uniforms
And having them charge at a group of machine gun wielding thugs while pointing their own guns in the air
what a stupid fucking movie
Dark Knight Rises v Man of Steel (Which one sucked more?)
- Thread starter Nintendoga
- Start date
- Status
And having them come out no worse for wear, wearing what looks like freshly pressed and steamed uniforms
And having them charge at a group of machine gun wielding thugs while pointing their own guns in the air
what a stupid fucking movie
TheKaeptain
Banned
MoS is the most talked about superhero movie of all time.
TheKaeptain
Banned
Yep
vatstep
This poster pulses with an appeal so broad the typical restraints of our societies fall by the wayside.
Personally, I didn't hate it, but I thought the first was much better. Top three Marvel movie for me.
it was fine.
it wasn't great, but there wasn't anything overtly insulting about it like with the other two movies.
Intheflorsh
Banned
MoS and TDKR at least had an element of spectacle. Thor 2 is just a cheaply made, cynical cashgrab.
SquiddyCracker
Banned
There's something wrong with your Poll, OP.
I can't vote.
I can't vote.
Jawmuncher
Member
TDKR was still worse than Thor 2.
LabouredSubterfuge
Member
Imagine thinking MoS is better than Thor 2.
Imagine not being able to dress yourself in the morning.
Imagine not being able to dress yourself in the morning.
cartoon_soldier
Member
The awesomeness of Loki is wasted in the Thor movies.
Even the first Thor is a complete piece of garbage.
it was Loki: the movie and that's basically what
dunno. I think there's way worse Marvel movies and the thor 2 stuff seems to be some kind of meme
TheKaeptain
Banned
but MoS is a better film than Thor 2.
god no
D.Lo
Member
This is a pretty fair fight, both are steaming turds.
I'd have to say DKR is the less-bad of the two. It has some fun scenes. It's just bonkers. Some weird and wacky stuff happens. Watch it as an Adam West Batman and it's perfect!
MoS is just - pure shit, every bit of it with the lone exception of Dianne Lane and to some extent Rusty.
The casting is otherwise garbage. Lois is plain as hell and looks far too old. Cavill got huge but is balding and has an elongated head and cannot act. Costner was shit, but didn't have a lot to work with.
Clark was a useless dickhead who had to ask everyone what to do constantly. What a piece of shit.
Every line of dialogue was expository SHIT. Oh god it was so bad.
I tried to watch it again but it made me too angry.
Also Thor 2 was stupid as hell but there was lots of Loki so it was more fun than either Nolan shiftiest.
I'd have to say DKR is the less-bad of the two. It has some fun scenes. It's just bonkers. Some weird and wacky stuff happens. Watch it as an Adam West Batman and it's perfect!
MoS is just - pure shit, every bit of it with the lone exception of Dianne Lane and to some extent Rusty.
The casting is otherwise garbage. Lois is plain as hell and looks far too old. Cavill got huge but is balding and has an elongated head and cannot act. Costner was shit, but didn't have a lot to work with.
Clark was a useless dickhead who had to ask everyone what to do constantly. What a piece of shit.
Every line of dialogue was expository SHIT. Oh god it was so bad.
I tried to watch it again but it made me too angry.
Great summary.
Also Thor 2 was stupid as hell but there was lots of Loki so it was more fun than either Nolan shiftiest.
Man of Steel is better than every Marvel movie starring Thor
MoS and Thor 2 were fairly average movies, but MoS was probably the worst for me. Lifeless, wooden characters and acting, with terrible fight scenes that basically consisted of zero consequence, mind numbingly repetitive, ping pong Dragon Ball Z esque back and forth's, that made combat seem almost entirely pointless.
I usually stay out of the TDKR-related threads because I fucking love that movie. It's not perfect but it hits the right notes and delivers on the action and drama. An awesome conclusion to The Dark Knight Trilogy.
Man of Steel is a flawed movie with strong performances and action but poor plotting, pacing, and dialogue. It's easily the weaker film but has its merits.
Voted Thor 2.
Man of Steel is a flawed movie with strong performances and action but poor plotting, pacing, and dialogue. It's easily the weaker film but has its merits.
Voted Thor 2.
brandonh83
Banned
Thor 2 is the winner. That movie is balls. TDKR and Man of Steel are amazing by comparison.
LabouredSubterfuge
Member
ThoseDeafMutes
Member
Wow I was expecting to have to rig this one but it looks like we got the correct order.
TDKR > MoS > Thor 2
TDKR > MoS > Thor 2
TheKaeptain
Banned
I can just see the MCU-marks voting MoS just because it doesn't have bright colors.
A Link to the Past
Banned
Y'know, I was fairly bored by Thor 2, but it was definitely the least boring of the three for me. Are people just being contrarian, or is Thor 2 just not a great movie for a lot of people?
shinobi602
Member
I thought they were both fantastic movies.
Confirmed by public poll people. This is the final answer. Nothing left to see here.
MisterHero
Super Member
I know it's a big week for MCU fans, but you know what? The Incredible Hulk, Thor 2, Iron Man 2&3, and
were all worse than either TDKRises or Man of Steel.
The poll puts the discussion back into perspective.
If you really want to trash a DC movie, trash Green Lantern. No need to crap on other movies.
Avengers 1
The poll puts the discussion back into perspective.
If you really want to trash a DC movie, trash Green Lantern. No need to crap on other movies.
talisayNon
Member
lol at TDKR "sucking"
GAF gonna GAF
GAF gonna GAF
Secks4Food
Member
Man of Steel was abysmally paced and over all really boring except for the absurd ending action, which was admittedly pretty cool but hardly redeemed the two hours that came before.
The Dark Knight Rises was kinda uneven and definitely the worst of the trilogy, but still better than Man of Steel in almost every regard.
I fell asleep for roughly 80% of Thor 2 in a loud theater, so there's that.
The Dark Knight Rises was kinda uneven and definitely the worst of the trilogy, but still better than Man of Steel in almost every regard.
I fell asleep for roughly 80% of Thor 2 in a loud theater, so there's that.
Doctor Decimate
Member
I mean, if we talk redeeming moments in all these movies then Thor 2 for me is pretty much just that ending fight.
brandonh83
Banned
like... how, man
Youre being a little kind
The only Marvel movies that are better than Man of Steel are Winter Soldier and Iron Man 1
the Thor 2 advantage is low. I will say this.
I've rewatched TDKR a couple times and I havent watched Thor 2 more than the theatre time
but I remember being more disappointed coming out of TDKR than the latter
there is absolutely no defending MoS tho
Godzilla's Left Toe
Member
Write in Vote Spiderman 3
- Status