The Witcher 3 | Review Thread

This is going to review really well because it is a long game with a big map. I'll wait for a month as I don't want to fall into the same trap as dragon Age Inquisition. Where the game was everyone's game of the year and it was decidedly average.

In your opinion, you mean. It goes without saying that any particular individual may like a game less or more than the metascore indicates, but you make it sound like your opinion is a fact and everybody else is wrong.
 
Ewww.



This is actually the first time where I think it's looks pretty rough. That ground isn't looking too hot.

Yeah, that ground isn't good looking.. but that happens in every single open-world game.. I just like those wyverns flying around, those many trees, that one big tree on that mountain, etc. just pure great atmosphere
 
In your opinion, you mean. It goes without saying that any particular individual may like a game less or more than the metascore indicates, but you make it sound like your opinion is a fact and everybody else is wrong.

We should have a quick IMO tag in the options when writing messages. Some posts do come off like that when it's totally opinion based. I ditched Dragon Age Inquisition 1 hour in - maybe less.
 
Svvb.jpg

OMG cant't wait to see the sweet magic of HairWorks, his chest is going to look great... somebody help me.
 
In your opinion, you mean. It goes without saying that any particular individual may like a game less or more than the metascore indicates, but you make it sound like your opinion is a fact and everybody else is wrong.

Of course it's his opinion. He shouldn't have to write a giant "IMO" before every statement he makes.
 
She's not his biological daughter and her hair is supposed to be natural grey (as opposed to Geralt's pure white). It's a rare elven hair color, a trace of her remote ancestry.

Personally, since The Witcher takes place in a fairy tale world, I'd also bet on destiny having something to do with her being born like this, to make it easier to get it through Geralt's thick skull that he won't escape the destiny he requested for himself.

Yep. Ciri's hair is ashen according to the books, whereas Geralt's hair is supposed to be white (lacking pigment) and yeah, there is a strong string of fate between them, not only because the child of surprise thing, but for what they've both chosen through their lives and what they both mean to each other.

Still, Sapkowski continues to play with the ambivalence of an destiny and the ability to choose.

PD: I'll wait to play it by myself, but i still think that making a game with Ciri as MC would be a lot different than what we've been accostumed in the series. That chick is too OP!! (or should be according to the books).
 
How is the combat? Really killed both 1 and 2 for me....everything about them seemed great, but I found the combat horrible. Is this more immediate akin to Bloodborne or other straight action games?
 
Hey, those PS4 shots look really nice. I especially like the colors and lighting. There's a soft, natural feel to it that is very inviting.

This is actually the first time where I think it's looks pretty rough. That ground isn't looking too hot.
It's one screenshot of him walking downhill where the ground is up close to the camera. That's probably the case for most games, no?
 
White hair comes from genetic mutation, I believe. Geralt's hair isn't naturally white either, it just became so after he underwent Witcher training as a child. I didn't read the books, so I'm not the expert on this.
Ciri's ashen hair is inherited, Geralt's white hair is due to his witcher mutations (like an albino)
Their scars are a result of unrelated unfortunate circumstances

From the "The Price of Neutrality" short story:

When a witcher saves a man's life and the man says, "In gratitude, I will give whatever you desire," the witcher then answers, "You will grant me whatever unexpected thing you encounter when you return home." In rare instances, the surprise proves to be an infant, born during its father's absence. Based on the Law of Surprise, the child belongs to the witcher, becoming the Unexpected Child to whom the witcher is bound by Destiny. Many Unexpected Children were brought to Kaer Morhen, where they were then raised and trained to be witchers.
 
How is the combat? Really killed both 1 and 2 for me....everything about them seemed great, but I found the combat horrible. Is this more immediate akin to Bloodborne or other straight action games?

Nothing like Bloodborne. It's more of a refined TW2 combat system.
 
I played The Witcher 2 on 360 and I guess I won't be able to transfer my save file to PS4 in any way but is there an option to see what actions I did in The Witcher 2 so I can choose them in The Witcher 3?
 
So, book readers, I say this is almost certainly Torque, the sylvan of Dol Blathanna. I mean, we already know that Dudu is in the game, so why not Torque, too?

Dudu is in it? Holy shit, I didn't know that. And yeah, that could be Torque now you mention it. Bit tall and fat though.


That one reminds me of the beginning of TW2.
 
To give y'all an idea of CDPR's post-launch support, from wikipedia for TW2:

Patch 1.1 removed DRM, giving 5-30% performance/load time boost (depending on the versino of the game), as well as activation and registration issues
Patch 1.2 "fixed a large number of issues, addressed broken quest lines, eliminated gameplay balance problems between the main character and his enemies, and improved features like the save game import system that allowed files from The Witcher 1 to be imported."
Patch 1.3 "included a plethora of fan-requested improvements, including difficulty adjustments for the game's Prologue, support for a variety of different aspect ratios, and a host of other gameplay tweaks and fixes. Next to the long list of changes, this update also included free downloadable content — a quest called "A Sackful of Fluff"."
Patch 2.0 "added three major features to The Witcher 2: the new Arena gameplay mode, in which players can fight waves of enemies; a new Tutorial system that introduces the player to the game's complex control systems; and a special Dark difficulty mode, which offers greater challenge to players, as well as unique rewards in the form of Dark items. The patch also brought a variety of bug fixes and improvements, including an overhauled targeting system and enhanced parrying."
Patch 3.2 "was released for the Enhanced Edition of The Witcher 2. The user interface was significantly modified by David Block, who originally created this UI modification and now works at CD Projekt RED. The patch also added some optional enhancements."

I believe The Witcher 1 had pretty good post-launch support, as well.
 
To give y'all an idea of CDPR's post-launch support, from wikipedia for TW2:

Patch 1.1 removed DRM, giving 5-30% performance/load time boost (depending on the versino of the game), as well as activation and registration issues
Patch 1.2 "fixed a large number of issues, addressed broken quest lines, eliminated gameplay balance problems between the main character and his enemies, and improved features like the save game import system that allowed files from The Witcher 1 to be imported."
Patch 1.3 "included a plethora of fan-requested improvements, including difficulty adjustments for the game's Prologue, support for a variety of different aspect ratios, and a host of other gameplay tweaks and fixes. Next to the long list of changes, this update also included free downloadable content — a quest called "A Sackful of Fluff"."
Patch 2.0 "added three major features to The Witcher 2: the new Arena gameplay mode, in which players can fight waves of enemies; a new Tutorial system that introduces the player to the game's complex control systems; and a special Dark difficulty mode, which offers greater challenge to players, as well as unique rewards in the form of Dark items. The patch also brought a variety of bug fixes and improvements, including an overhauled targeting system and enhanced parrying."
Patch 3.2 "was released for the Enhanced Edition of The Witcher 2. The user interface was significantly modified by David Block, who originally created this UI modification and now works at CD Projekt RED. The patch also added some optional enhancements."

I believe The Witcher 1 had pretty good post-launch support, as well.

I hope there's no need for an Enhanced Edition this time around.
 

This is good news. I urge people not to get their hopes up too much expecting ALL framerate issues to be solved, but if they can fix parts here and there that would be fantastic.

I'm not trying to be that guy, but I always take a wait and see approach with this type of stuff. It's not inspiring that these issues weren't already addressed before review copies were sent out.

It's not but at the same time they had an insane time crunch just to even get close to shipping this giant game, even after the delays. Considering the performance tweaks usually come near the tail end of development this makes sense.

There's one thing I know for sure here. CD Projekt Red supports their games more than anyone else out there. Whether that be extra content or fixing bugs/issues.
 
For fuck sake so many screenshots, not sure if I should keep checking this thread, don't want to get everything spoiled.
 
Haven't seen it mentioned yet in any of the reviews I've glanced at, but has anyone posted impressions on how the game deals with setting up past choices for first time players?
 
Watched the retrospectives on game trailers. Jeez, this story is a big confusing, no?

Kind of. The main arc's are pretty easy to follow but the multiple characters all with different goals make it complicated.

He never woke up after the canon W2 ending.

(I hope I'm remembering that right.)

Depending on your path, it's possible Triss helped him.

Haven't seen it mentioned yet in any of the reviews I've glanced at, but has anyone posted impressions on how the game deals with setting up past choices for first time players?

There's a conversation at the beginning where you can choose what happened previously.
 
Just finished my third play through of The Witcher 2, so ready! Gah this wait is going to feel endless. I'm just messing around in Arena here on out.
 
Different reviewers scores carry different weights, the bigger sites carry more weight so their score affects the metascore more than a small site.

Exactly. It's the big sites giving the game high review scores, reason why I expected a 94-96 going by OP.
 
Top Bottom