The batmobile complaint is interesting, because it's so universally disliked among reviewers, that I wonder how the rest of the game holds up vs how bad those sections truly are. In that regard, the Gamespot review stands out not because the batmobile sections are poor but because the reviewer didn't think the rest of the game was fantastic enough to overcome those sections in warranting a higher score.
We just had Witcher 3 come out to pretty much universal acclaim and that title has plenty of gameplay issues or things that straight up suck (hello Roach and horse racing). And you could make a list of such issues across the gameplay systems within Witcher, but clearly the package clearly came together, worked and impressed reviewers to warrant high scores.
That's my takeaway from the Gamespot review anyways, not that the batmobile sections are poor but perhaps the rest of the game isn't impressive enough to carry those sections.