Firestone77
Neo Member
I just wanted to say as someone who entertained a "maybe" vote for Trump, this latest immigration talk is where he jumped the shark for me.
If he wants to get rid of the "anchor baby" situation by challenging the 14th Amendment in a court of law, that's one thing. If he said "going forward, this isn't going to happen anymore," I'd probably even say "okay." But his end game is that he wants to retroactively take away citizenship from some Latinos who have lived here as citizens for years? That's absurd. Those are people who had no reason to even try to become a citizen since they already are one. Under this, they would now get kicked out without even having the opportunity of going through that long, arduous process of obtaining citizenship in the first place? What would Trump or America even gain from that?
Plus, I guarantee some of these people affected are current voters. Hell, just think about the Latino community. Probably many Latino voters will have at least a friend who would be put into this situation or at a bare minimum, empathy for them regarding this absurdity. If he'd ruined his chances at the Latino vote before, he just scorched the earth with it now.
It's just really really stupid to punish someone for abiding the laws, even if he feels they got it through a loophole. A contract is a contract, Trump, and it must be respected. You even said that about the Iran deal if it were signed.
Also, this talk about shipping everyone out and letting the "good ones" back in just reeks of wasted time and resources. What is the point of forcing a "good one" out with the intention of letting him in at a later date, "expedited process" or not? It's just him screwing with people for no positive gain. Identify the bad ones, okay, I follow him there, and force them out. They're probably the ones in prisons right now and I'm fine with that. Or if they're undocumented and later commit a violent crime, they're gone too. I'm cool with that.
Don't bother anyone else. There's just no point. It's mean and economically destructive. Give them a shot at citizenship though this "expedited process" without forcing them to leave in the first place. Make it a one-shot deal for everyone who's undocumented and in the country currently when this would go into effect. Protect the country's interest going forward instead of punishing those who have committed no crime.
Sorry for the rant. I know plenty of people here disagree with doing *anything* about illegal immigration in the first place. Which I found weird because even Obama has acknowledged many of the issues (https://www.whitehouse.gov/share/in...aking-steps-fix-our-broken-immigration-system).
All great points. I don't believe trump is stupid and realizes the impracticality of all of these things too. What he's really trying to do is counter the underlined, which has been the status quo for going on 40 years now. In real terms. He's doing it by asking for $1000, when that is really wanted and needed is $500. It's an amazingly brilliant strategy for getting things done that really need to be done. If he has to offend the people with delicate sensibilities, who cares? They're going to look to be offended for the lamest of reasons anyways. See anchor baby video for extreme proof. Disgusting.