Man, you seem to be everywhere when MGS4 gets brought up. I get that you love it, but you seem to get a bit too into defending the game. I agree, a lot of people get a bit hyperbolic about MGS4, going so far as to call it a garbage game (which it clearly isn't). However, I don't think anyone can deny that it does have some glaring problems, with certain elements of the game absolutely being terrible. If you like that, great, but trying to shut up detractors with completely valid complaints by resorting to "but look at the reviews!" isn't fair. A sizable portion of the fan base considers the game bad (in relation to the rest of the series at least), and whether or not that group is a minority (which I don't really think it is), the position seems pretty valid.