[SPOILERS] Star Wars: The Force Awakens - It's True. All of it.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Luke never knew the rules of the Jedi Order and he's pretty much the exact opposite of what an Old Republic era Jedi was (Luke's ability to love and care about his friends/family is exactly what helped him fight off the dark side and turn Vader). There's no reason why he'd stick to the old ways of the Jedi.

Exactly. He's forming a new Jedi Order and can make his own rules.
 
Also, Luke is totally going to die. I hope you are all ready. Probably Leia too. Chewie may survive since he is a familiar face for continuity. (Or he'll die trying to protect Leia).

aHGZLys.jpg

.
 
Just a random absurd thought --- I hope some smartass on the oscar nominee committee has the gall to nominate Mark Hamill for Best Supporting Actor.

That 4 second silent oscar performance. The internet salt alone would be worth it.
 
Just got back from the movie. I really did enjoy it, but boy howdy is it ever a retread of IV.

- Rebellion Resistance gets valuable information
- Empire First Order attacks just as Rebellion Resistance gets the information
- Information is put onto a droid and sent onto a desert planet
- Main character finds the droid
- Main character escapes desert planet and the Empire First Order on the Millennium Falcon
- Significant portion of the movie is trying to get the information to the Rebellion Resistance
- Evil force wielding villain has a significant history with one of the main characters, an old man
- Said villain kills the old man
- Empire First Order has a giant weapon that can destroy planets
- Last fight of the movie involves trying to destroy said weapon

Again, I did enjoy the movie a lot. I loved the final confrontation between Rey and Kylo at the end.

When it was unique, I thought it was brilliant. Even when it wasn't it was still good. But I think JJ might have played this one a bit too safe. I'm really looking forward to what's coming next though.

Trench run
 
Luke wouldn't have had a daughter since he was a jedi. Unless he wanted to break the rules of the Jedi Order. He started an academy and searched for the first temple so it's pretty clear he wouldn't have taken a spouse if so that would rewrite the PT.

True but wasn't Luke the last living jedi? Would the code/rules still apply in that case? I always figured it was something set in place while the jedi council was active. Like something they enforced and taught. Without that and without other jedi, maybe his view would change over time. I doubt it though.
 
When it was unique, I thought it was brilliant. Even when it wasn't it was still good. But I think JJ might have played this one a bit too safe. I'm really looking forward to what's coming next though.

The first act of the movie, roughly -- up until it got too far into the han solo stuff -- was brilliant. I had some structural issues with it after that, but overall liked it largely because it has good characters.
 
What about Kylo is whiny?

He throws tantrums. Lines like "i'm so torn apart i feel the light pulling me," etc. Came off to me as really self-pitying. Okay Vader redeemed himself in ROTJ and showed a little conflict be he did it without a single word or facial expression (dat helmet). He was just a cool stoic villain.
 
Don't know how you guys can like Kylo over OT Vader. What made Vader cool is he was all-in with being evil and almost zombie-like in his obedience. He wasn't a whiny kid. Same gripes with Kylo that I have with PT Anakin. I found his conflicted moments pretty cringey/melodramatic.

Why is a character automatically bad if they're conflicted, or as you put it, "whiny"?

PT Anakin was poorly written and performed.

Kylo had legitimately believable reactions and Adam Driver totally sold the character with his physical performance and delivery. Vader was also an old dude. Kylo looks to be around the same age Anakin was during RotS and he's already done many despicable things.
 
Trench run

Heh, yup.

I definitely noticed all the other parallels, and I wasn't particularly happy about them kicking things off with Death Star III, but this was the one reference where I actually said "seriously?" out loud during the film.

He throws tantrums. Lines like "i'm so torn apart i feel the light pulling me," etc. Came off to me as really self-pitying. Okay Vader redeemed himself in ROTJ and showed a little conflict be he did it without a single word or facial expression (dat helmet). He was just a cool stoic villain.

Vader was pure Tarkin/Emperor lapdog for the entire series, he threw tantrums in both IV (barking orders at his commander on the Tantive IV) and V (killing anyone who disappointed him), and in VI any hint of an intimidating air was more or less neutered once the Emperor showed up (hell, his main threat in the intro scene was that his boss was gonna show up).

The degree to which he ceased to be a threatening villain came through especially painfully in any word he spoke to Luke about whether he'd turn back to the good side in VI. You can tell he's just a broken man who's beginning to rethink his life but feels powerless to change at that point.
 
His tantrums for example, his daddy issues which is such an overused movie trope.

Kylo basically did the same thing as Vader did, but in different ways. It suggests to me that Kylo is actually a more reasonable person than Vader - when Kylo got bad news, he destroyed things. When Vader got bad news, he destroyed people.
 
2. BB8 was everywhere in this film and they did a pretty damn good job with it. The design is great and works really well, I never had to question "but how will it do/go/jump there?".

By the way, I liked how they introduced the BB-8's ability to shoot whips. It might prevent situations like the one with R2-D2's rocket engine in Episode 3.
 
So now that I'm posting in the right thread, can we all agree that the final shot is horrendous and possibly, most likely, the worst final shot of all 7 Star Wars films simply in terms of cinematography? A spinning helicopter shot? In 2015? In a Star Wars film? It was ridiculously bad to me.

h2QEwz6.gif


It's actually the best final shot of all the Star Wars films. Sooooo good.
 
Where in the flashback were Obi-wan and Yoda??? I didn't see them.

You don't see them, but you do hear them say a few lines.

*Vader breathing*
*Scream* (Sounds a little bit like Leia)
Yoda: "An energy field (with echo)... It surrounds us and binds us."
*Luke screaming "no" from Empire is blended in with Yoda's last line*
Ben: "Remember (with echo)... The force will be with you, always."
*Scream* (Inuman - sounds like a Tusken Raider)
*Scream* (Female, unknown)
Young Rey: "Come back!"
Unkar Plutt: (Restraining Rey) "Quiet, girl."
*Scream* (Female, unkown)
Unknown male: "Rey?" (Does sound like Alec Guinness)
Unknown male: (Whispering) "These are your first steps."
 
I was pretty bummed by how underused Captain Phasma was in the movie. Such a badass character and amazing actress just wasted. Hopefully she gets more screen time in the sequel.

Man I was worried when Snoke first showed up and appeared to be a giant. It just struck me as goofy and luckily it was just a hologram. Man, they've really perfected that technology over that 30 year gap.
 
So the Hosnian system was destroyed by Starkiller, correct? And that was the current seat of power for the Republic, since they had moved to planets hosting the centre of power, rather than it always being Coruscant? And according the novel, the blast took out a major portion (most?) of the Republic fleet? And is Chancellor Mothma, and the Galactic Senate, dead?
 
I'm starting to think that the movie really could have used another 15-20 minutes. It has such a fast pace that slowing down a bit wouldn't hurt, plus I think a lot of the relationships could have used the extra time. I think they work as-is but mostly on strength of character and performance--not so much in the writing.

They so easily could have had that moment early on where Finn takes his helmet off have Phasma come into shot and shock the shit out of him with the baton stick for it. Then later on, at the Maz bombing she comes out and sees him. Boom, vendetta.

Yeah, I also agree that it would have made more sense for her to be the one fighting Finn, although FN-B4D4SS was great.
 
The force. He's obviously got a few skills we haven't seen before. Same with the delving into people's minds to get information.

Well yeah but my memory might be faulty but nobody outside of the extended universe, which doesn't exist did that. I know the old time people could block a light saber with the force but a blaster shot, that was a first for me.
 
I do think that R2 turning on was because at this point Luke wants to be found. I think that Hans death and kylo and Rey with the saber is saying she is searching him out like he did Vader.

Yeah that's possible, he would have felt Han's death. But I think they could have illustrated that in some way, we KNOW Luke is alive, and we see him in Rey's vision. I think they could have managed to add in Luke at that point, just a glimpse.

Felt wrong for Han to die without any sort of acknowledgement from Luke. I really thought Luke would be present if that ever happened.
 
Speaking of ending shots, static or not, they just need to be memorable.

Han, Luke, Leia at the victory celebration. Luke and Leia, R2 and C3PO on the cruiser looking out into space. The whole cast sitting together.

But the prequels... I had to go look them up, I couldn't remember them. And I actually don't hate those movies! But the final scenes didn't evoke any kind of emotion or trigger any memories.

But this shot, with Rey's outstretched hand holding a lightsaber to Luke, I will remember forever. It was INSTANTLY memorable, even if it was an aerial shot. It evoked the same feelings. I'm almost waiting for an artist to group all the ending shots together.


That last shot was one of the shots that worked well in 3D

I would say that ending was damn near perfection. But One thing I would have changed slightly was Luke flipping his hood down. There was no need. And Hammil hammed it up slightly.
 
So, what if Luke,instead of using his non-orthodox Jedi mentality to train new Jedi, found information about the oldw ays and taught people like that and it totally backfired?
 
Well yeah but my memory might be faulty but nobody outside of the extended universe, which doesn't exist did that. I know the old time people could block a light saber with the force but a blaster shot, that was a first for me.

Yep, it's new. I thought Kylo having some powers we haven't seen before was great, instead of relying on just the powers we saw in the PT and OT. I wasn't really expecting it.
 
Do you have to reach a certain level of force power to interact with force ghosts? And is it possible we will see force ghosts in 8? Imagine rey being trained by Luke, Yoda, Obi and Anakin?
 
I mean Phasma was supposed to be a dude and was a late change to female after complaints of too many guys in the movie.

If this true (which I doubt)... too many guys? The main character is a woman, as well as two other very important ones, and there are female Resistance pilots too.
 
Kylo basically did the same thing as Vader did, but in different ways. It suggests to me that Kylo is actually a more reasonable person than Vader - when Kylo got bad news, he destroyed things. When Vader got bad news, he destroyed people.

But he did it with gravitas and no emotion and that is what made him impressive. If you throw a tantrum before you punish somebody it just feels strange. The Stormtroopers reacted at one scene like out of a sitcom while Kylo was again raging.

Kylo is way more like Darth Helmet.
 
Well yeah but my memory might be faulty but nobody outside of the extended universe, which doesn't exist did that. I know the old time people could block a light saber with the force but a blaster shot, that was a first for me.

That's what made that moment so cool. I'm glad JJ and company aren't feeling restricted to the force powers George Lucas made up. I'm glad no one force jumped in this film.

h2QEwz6.gif


It's actually the best final shot of all the Star Wars films. Sooooo good.

Are you being serious? I get the dramatic intention of that entire final sequence but that shot, it was just so bad. What made it good to you?
 
So, what if Luke,instead of using his non-orthodox Jedi mentality to train new Jedi, found information about the oldw ays and taught people like that and it totally backfired?

Luke destroyed the Holocron that prohibited Jedi's from getting some, he told all of his new pupils that back in the day Jedis could have as many wives as they wanted.
 
So now that I'm posting in the right thread, can we all agree that the final shot is horrendous and possibly, most likely, the worst final shot of all 7 Star Wars films simply in terms of cinematography? A spinning helicopter shot? In 2015? In a Star Wars film? It was ridiculously bad to me.

Yeah, I wasn't crazy about that.

Actually, overall, the cinematography was a little up and down (mostly up). It looked good, and some shots were fantastic (ex: the bridge scene looked like concept art), but othertimes it felt very...I don't know. A little too slick? Seeing it again tomorrow in IMAX, maybe I'll have actual thoughts by that time.

I would have rather it ended with something a little more refined and less Bad Boys 2.
 
Also, Abrams seems to make the Galaxy a very small place, which is disappointing. The Republic, First Order, and Resistance all seem to have like, one planet each. I know that's not accurate butt it seems ridiculous when the Resistance throws everything they have into a last ditch assault on Starkiller Base and it's like, 1 squadron of x-wings. The Original Trilogy always made it seem like the Galaxy was huge and full or mystery and surprises, this movie made it seem like everyone and everything important were within five feet of each other.

Well, think of this conflict not as a galaxy-spanning war, but a regional civil war.
 
To me Vader was always more of a pop culture icon than a deep character.

In terms of characterization, Kylo Ren already has more going for him in this film alone.

That is exactly why I love more Kylo Ren, sure Vader is a great character and I really love him in the OT but he's some kind of zombie, tired, old, fallen Jedi, he was pretty average in Ep 4 but became an amazing character in 5 and 6.

Kylo is more like a beast, he's angry, affraid, jaelous, twisted etc ... I really like him in this movie, has the potential to be even better if Disney doesn't "Naruto" him
 
Why is a character automatically bad if they're conflicted, or as you put it, "whiny"?

PT Anakin was poorly written and performed.

Kylo had legitimately believable reactions and Adam Driver totally sold the character with his physical performance and delivery.

sorry double post.
 
I'm starting to think that the movie really could have used another 15-20 minutes. It has such a fast pace that slowing down a bit wouldn't hurt, plus I think a lot of the relationships could have used the extra time. I think they work as-is but mostly on strength of character and performance--not so much in the writing.



Yeah, I also agree that it would have made more sense for her to be the one fighting Finn, although FN-B4D4SS was great.
I think the length and pacing are perfect as is, but they maybe could've replaced the freighter action sequence with something else.
 
So now that I'm posting in the right thread, can we all agree that the final shot is horrendous and possibly, most likely, the worst final shot of all 7 Star Wars films simply in terms of cinematography? A spinning helicopter shot? In 2015? In a Star Wars film? It was ridiculously bad to me.
Nah, I thought it was great. One of my favorite shots in the movie.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom