A polite discourse amongst friends on the importance of MP-elements in No Man's Sky

Status
Not open for further replies.
He did not say you'd never meet up with someone, just that the likelyhood is very very small. Well, TWO players met up together. So, they are the 0.00001%. Gratz.

Again, Sean did not lie. How many OTHER people are meeting up together at the same spot today? Or is it just THESE two streamers who won the astronomical lottery?

Until other people start meeting up and streaming together, I can only see those two guys from yesterday as EXTREMELY LUCKY.

That "non-issue" is over as far as I'm concerned.

So, the ONLY issue here is why they can't see each other face to face. And I think we owe HG and Sean some time to figure that out and let us know. It's DAY 2. Give them some time to figure it out.

They aren't hundreds of engineers like Blizzard. They are all of 15? 20? employees in a small office? Give them so time to investigate and respond.

Hell, the PC version hasn't even released yet.
 
labx said:
What is my take on all of this. The guy is trying to be ambiguos for the sake of bit and want to create some kind of thrill and surprise in his game. Maybe the guy is dodging the subject because he want to be a surprise tho. I don't think the man is a liar.
Click to expand...
He is a liar because he said several times before the game's launch that you could play with other people, and now we've found out at launch that you can't.

He's being ambiguous because he was thinking this entire time that maybe it would be a week at the very least before any players actually found each other and by then he'd be able to come up with an excuse.

Netherscourge said:
He did not say you'd never meet up with someone, just that the likelyhood is very very small. Well, TWO players met up together. So, they are the 0.00001%. Gratz.

Again, Sean did not lie. How many OTHER people are meeting up together at the same spot today? Or is it just THESE two streamers who won the astronomical lottery?

Until other people start meeting up and streaming together, I can only see those two guys from yesterday as EXTREMELY LUCKY.

That "non-issue" is over as far as I'm concerned.

So, the ONLY issue here is why they can't see each other face to face. And I think we owe HG and Sean some time to figure that out and let us know. It's DAY 2. Give them some time to figure it out.

They aren't hundred of engineers like Blizzard. They are all of 15 employees in a small office? Give them so time to investigate and respond.

Hell, the PC version hasn't even released yet.
Click to expand...
Obligatory CrowbCat video
 
Unless I at least get a confirmation along the lines of "You can never see anyone else", "You can see other people but there were server issues" or at the very least "You can see other people but it doesn't necessarily work how you would think" then my purchase on PC will go from definitely Friday to a wait and see. The feature isn't a game changer but I'm not about to get burned again with a game that seems more than it is and all this just seems shady right now.

I mean how hard is it to give customers direct information. Use my third option if you want to keep the mystery
 
Netherscourge said:
He did not say you'd never meet up with someone, just that the likelyhood is very very small. Well, TWO players met up together. So, they are the 0.00001%. Gratz.

Again, Sean did not lie. How many OTHER people are meeting up together at the same spot today? Or is it just THESE two streamers who won the astronomical lottery?

Until other people start meeting up and streaming together, I can only see those two guys from yesterday as EXTREMELY LUCKY.

That "non-issue" is over as far as I'm concerned.

So, the ONLY issue here is why they can't see each other face to face. And I think we owe HG and Sean some time to figure that out and let us know. It's DAY 2. Give them some time to figure it out.

They aren't hundreds of engineers like Blizzard. They are all of 15? 20? employees in a small office? Give them so time to investigate and respond.

Hell, the PC version hasn't even released yet.
Click to expand...

We don't owe them anything, they owe us a working game with features they advertised for the money they got for it. It's absurd that people actually think they owe devs anything beyond the money for their game.
 
Klyka said:
.
Click to expand...

ZlgW7nb.gif
 
Netherscourge said:
He did not say you'd never meet up with someone, just that the likelyhood is very very small. Well, TWO players met up together. So, they are the 0.00001%. Gratz.

Again, Sean did not lie. How many OTHER people are meeting up together at the same spot today? Or is it just THESE two streamers who won the astronomical lottery?

Until other people start meeting up and streaming together, I can only see those two guys from yesterday as EXTREMELY LUCKY.

That "non-issue" is over as far as I'm concerned.

So, the ONLY issue here is why they can't see each other face to face. And I think we owe HG and Sean some time to figure that out and let us know. It's DAY 2. Give them some time to figure it out.

They aren't hundred of engineers like Blizzard. They are all of 15 employees in a small office? Give them so time to investigate and respond.

Hell, the PC version hasn't even released yet.
Click to expand...

What needs to be investigated? All people are asking is whether its actually a feature or not. Nothings wrong with saying "Yes meeting people has been implemented but the servers are having issues, we're working on a fix". That would literally end all of this discussion. And yet all we get is more cryptic bullshit. "Wow two people already got to the same location! Wow so many species!"
 
Camp Freddie said:
Is the chance of players meeting a 'birthday problem' issue?
(You have a 50% chance of sharing a birthday with another player in a lobby of 23 people)

My calculator can't handle the awesome power of quintillion factorials, so I don't know what the chances are of 1 million guys finding a match in a quintillion planets.

In any case, it's straight up lying if this isn't possible in the game. You don't get to claim it's a feature and then not bother to include it. At least Molyneux owned up to his lies/wishful thinking before the game was released. Tweating about it as if two players literally met is utterly gross.

No Mans Sky is a game of self-directed goals, since there isn't really a plot except maybe find the centre of the universe and maybe meet/kill Atlas or something.
As such, a hell of a lot of players are going to have a No Mans Sky bucket list that includes, "find another player".

And lets not forget that this is a clear goal, since Sean has said that the only way to find out what you look like is through another player's eyes. In a game about exploration, "What am I?" is going to be a question that players want to answer.

Personally, I was going to find the planet closest to the centre of the Euclid galaxy and see if other people were around. Or possibly to build/rename a base there and call it, "The Restaurant at the End of the Universe".

I hope that this is just a bug, but I have almost 0% hope for that. If it were, then you'd thing Sean and Co. would reach out to those players and try to make it work, rather than expose themselves to the negative PR of promising something that was never going to be possible.

It sounds more like Sean thought it was statistically impossible for players to meet, so he thought he could get away with lying about it.
I always thought that multiplayer netcode was hard, so why would a small team try and code it in when it was extremely unlikely to ever be used?
Click to expand...

Alarm bells should have been going off when he was making rounds on late night talk shows and on Colbert, they were going around a planet tagging animals and they all had witty Colbert-isms, a sound effect, and a Colbert icon. They made a Colbert build of the game and used it to push the "unique" experience every player will have with the game.

Any programmer would have immediately sat up straight and understood what was occurring. Even the "zoom out" cinematic they play to represent all of the (potential) different nodes is shady as fuck.
 
Netherscourge said:
He did not say you'd never meet up with someone, just that the likelyhood is very very small. Well, TWO players met up together. So, they are the 0.00001%. Gratz.

Again, Sean did not lie. How many OTHER people are meeting up together at the same spot today? Or is it just THESE two streamers who won the astronomical lottery?

Until other people start meeting up and streaming together, I can only see those two guys from yesterday as EXTREMELY LUCKY.

That "non-issue" is over as far as I'm concerned.

So, the ONLY issue here is why they can't see each other face to face. And I think we owe HG and Sean some time to figure that out and let us know. It's DAY 2. Give them some time to figure it out.

They aren't hundreds of engineers like Blizzard. They are all of 15? 20? employees in a small office? Give them so time to investigate and respond.

Hell, the PC version hasn't even released yet.
Click to expand...
In the meantime, buy the game guys!

I'm sure in two or three weeks they will have figured out that they didn't put the feature in the game and then they will tell us. No lies detected!
 
GreySquirrel said:
Unless I at least get a confirmation along the lines of "You can never see anyone else", "You can see other people but there were server issues" or at the very least "You can see other people but it doesn't necessarily work how you would think" then my purchase on PC will go from definitely Friday to a wait and see. The feature isn't a game changer but I'm not about to get burned again with a game that seems more than it is and all this just seems shady right now.

I mean how hard is it to give customers direct information. Use my third option if you want to keep the mystery
Click to expand...
Well here you go, cancel that pre-order.
 
Boke1879 said:
Hold up did two people actually meet each other? Or is this just based on Sean's tweet.
Click to expand...

Two people actually met in the exact same spot and could not see each other.

The meeting was surrounded by network problems, No Man's Sky server problems and other things.
 
Najaf said:
Well, you know, other than saying "Yes, you are [supposed to be] able to see other players in the game."
Click to expand...

but he said two people have already met up in the game. He said that features were added to make it easier to spot players and it has been confirmed that said features do exist in the game. He probably doesnt even know about this thread. I see no reason why people are even questioning him tbh.

And if Im not mistaken didnt a gaffer somewhere in this thread confirm that they met up with someone as well?(although no screenshot was provided)

From the outside looking in, this just seems like a mindless witch hunt, especially when you consider how rare it is to even see someone in the game, which would help explain why many people havent met anyone.
 
Netherscourge said:
He did not say you'd never meet up with someone, just that the likelyhood is very very small. Well, TWO players met up together. So, they are the 0.00001%. Gratz.

Again, Sean did not lie. How many OTHER people are meeting up together at the same spot today? Or is it just THESE two streamers who won the astronomical lottery?

Until other people start meeting up and streaming together, I can only see those two guys from yesterday as EXTREMELY LUCKY.

That "non-issue" is over as far as I'm concerned.

So, the ONLY issue here is why they can't see each other face to face. And I think we owe HG and Sean some time to figure that out and let us know. It's DAY 2. Give them some time to figure it out.

They aren't hundreds of engineers like Blizzard. They are all of 15? 20? employees in a small office? Give them so time to investigate and respond.

Hell, the PC version hasn't even released yet.
Click to expand...

If you can't see people in game then you will never know if you were even close to anyone.

The thought of having a fleeting moment of seeing another player in a universe this vast is truly amazing, if it's not possible then come out and say so and I'll adjust my expectations for the game accordingly.

Communicating via reddit and a stream is not meeting up together, it's been made possible by the internet not by the game, they both played the game and were in the same place but they met up in a stream chat or on reddit, they didn't have any interaction in game at all, not even a fleeting glimpse.
 
If the center of the universe is in the same location in everyone's game, and everyone's getting closer to it, how would it not end up that tons of people would be in the same locations in game eventually? They're all in the process of reducing the distance between themselves and other players. With that in mind, I'd guess this game is not built to handle that kind of multiplayer traffic and you just can't see anyone else in-game.
 
darklin0 said:
If the end goal for everyone to try an reach the center, wouldn't the, '0.000001%' of meeting someone eventually turn into impossible to not meet someone?

So calling people idiots for thinking it would have multiplayer, (even when the devs said so), is just plain wrong. :/
Click to expand...

The answer to this revolves around major spoilers for what happens when you get to the center (which is answered in the spoiler thread).

I'll try to avoid major spoilers and just answer this specific question, as much as I can:

You could probably wait around near the center in an effort to meet other players, as long as you don't actually go there and complete the story.
 
JeTmAn81 said:
If the center of the universe is in the same location in everyone's game, and everyone's getting closer to it, how would it not end up that tons of people would be in the same locations in game eventually? They're all in the process of reducing the distance between themselves and other players. With that in mind, I'd guess this game is not built to handle that kind of multiplayer traffic and you just can't see anyone else in-game.
Click to expand...
Sean figured he had the amount of time it would take for more than 1 player to reach the center of the universe to get out of town.

Najaf said:
I posted that interview earlier. It is so frustrating how he refuses to directly answer the question multiple times, even when the interviewer rephrases the question.
Click to expand...
I thought the immediate "no" he gives was good enough.

Though yes, the question wouldn't have needed to be asked multiple times if he'd just said "no" before. Or if he'd just say "no" now.

Maybe he now sees this as an opportunity to sell copies of the game based on people thinking it possibly has a feature that it doesn't actually have, whereas blatantly saying "no" would lose potential sales.
 
Mifec said:
We don't owe them anything, they owe us a working game with features they advertised for the money they got for it. It's absurd that people actually think they owe devs anything beyond the money for their game.
Click to expand...

Bu-but small indie team and Sean Murray is normal nice guy and only 15-20 people in small office and forgive us of our trespasses and those who trespass against Murray and bullshit and party!
 
Najaf said:
I posted that interview earlier. It is so frustrating how he refuses to directly answer the question multiple times, even when the interviewer rephrases the question.
Click to expand...
Well he does directly tell Colbert that the only way you'd know how you looked was if someone else sees you. So that's pretty cut and dry to me.

edit: whoops, that was not the video I thought it was.
 
This is embarrassing. To me the response is the most telling. I hope Sony never works with these lying assholes again
 
What a fantastic rollercoaster of a thread. I don't really care much about multiplayer in NMS but I can't figure out why Sean won't confirm/deny stuff instead of skirting the issue.
 
Bedlam said:
Nitpicking? Worlds collide? Crazy expectations? Players idea?

Wut?

Again: Sean Murray himself described the rudimentary MP functionality of players meeting and seeing each other in various interviews. Just yesterday he tweeted "Holy shit two players found each other".

This is not something that players projected into the game. It was announced and marketed by the developers themselves. It doesn't matter how important or unimportant this feature is to each individual player. The issue is their deceitful communication.
Click to expand...

Lets do this.

Nitpicking: the players are having selective abstraction about a handful of thing of a bast game. Things that would be or not, confirmed later on, not 72 hours of the game release. People wanted a everlasting game and now people want to do everything that the game has to offer in one sit.

Crazy expectations: some people imagine or believe that seen another player would be like a tag team in a FPS maybe that is not the case.

Worlds collide/player idea (imaginary): The developers have an idea, the executed like they thought initially. They clumsy enough talk about this idea and then people start to making assumptions about this idea creating a concept far away from the concept of the developers.

I think that he is not ill intended. I think rather that deceitful (i.e. Blizzard's lot box system) he is clumsy expressing his vision. Again, this is an opinion from a human being, so I can be wrong and the man is a master class con artist.




Onemic said:
Is there a scan for other players feature in the galactic map?
Click to expand...

Pop said:
Yup
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ORFgfhj_hM&feature=youtu.be&t=234

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AE0nuW-mQ8A


DOWN said:
This:


Who the fuck are these people saying "they met but didn't see each other"??

If they hadn't been streaming on twitch to each other, they wouldn't have known they were exploring the same place at all. Neither player got anything but their usual single player experience. Y'all have a fundamental misunderstanding of the word "meet"
Click to expand...
 
Kadin said:
Well he does directly tell Colbert that the only way you'd know how you looked was if someone else sees you. So that's pretty cut and dry to me.

edit: whoops, that was not the video I thought it was.
Click to expand...
You're right, the Colbert interview is from 2015. The one I posted was from this year.
 
Bedlam said:
The found each other the same way you can find other players in The Witcher 3. Mind blowing!
Click to expand...

This is accurate and depressing.

I don't want full on multiplayer functionality but if another player is in the same place as me it's been said you could see them, the chance of it is minuscule due to the size of the universe alone.

Saying that they found each other because they were in the same location but for all purposes both offline playing single player games is just shady, they didn't find anything but disappointment.
 
Conkerkid11 said:
The earliest that the Steam page ever said whether it would be single-player, co-op, and/or multi-player was March 3rd of this year. Before that, the whole section that described all that was left blank.

And this is what it looked like. Single-player, Steam Achievements, and Partial Controller Support. The only difference is that it now says Full Controller Support.

...

Via waybackmachine
Click to expand...

Can also use the SteamDB site to check for any updates done to the product:
SteamDB Entry for categories

Also, where the HECK is the one screencap a gaffer posted from a gaming magazine that talked about "No Man's Sky ONLINE" coming a while after release. I remember it vaguely mentioning that they plan on making it easy to join your friends WORLDS to play with them. I tried googling but I only get the usual suspect articles "does NMS have MP" and old interviews?

I CAN'T be the only one who remembers the screencap? Well might be cause I vaguely remember it being written in german. If someone has it we can translate it for the rest?
 
I love all the people claiming they won't buy it now because you MIGHT not be able to see one another. The game has over 18 quintillion planets.

Do any of you even realize how big that is? 18 quintillion is:

18,000,000,000,000,000,000

divide that by a million players all online at the same time and your odds of running into someone are:

1 in 18,000,000,000 Billion

Now, yes, two people seem to have found each other somehow, that doesn't change the fact that up until now it should have been seen as such a REMOTE possibility that buying the game in the hopes it would happen just seems incredibly foolish.

On the other hand, seeing that it is now possible, I can see people getting upset that you can't see one another (apparently), but nothing leading up to this should have given you the impression that you would be playing this game for a few months and probably find someone.
 
Wow this thread got fucking wild overnight.

If I wasn't sure whether the miscommunications were Sean's fault or the fans' fault yesterday, post 1799 onwards of this thread really, really cleared that up.

What the fuck is this guy doing? He must know how this looks to everyone, right?

Raven77 said:
I love all the people claiming they won't buy it now because you MIGHT not be able to see one another. The game has over 18 quintillion planets.

Do any of you even realize how big that is? 18 quintillion is:

18,000,000,000,000,000,000

divide that by a million players all online at the same time and your odds of running into someone are:

1 in 18,000,000,000 Billion

Now, yes, two people seem to have found each other somehow, that doesn't change the fact that up until now it should have been seen as such a REMOTE possibility that buying the game in the hopes it would happen just seems incredibly foolish.

On the other hand, seeing that it is now possible, I can see people getting upset that you can't see one another (apparently), but nothing leading up to this should have given you the impression that you would be playing this game for a few months and probably find someone.
Click to expand...

It's like Sean Murray felt like he could promise whatever regarding multiplayer because the odds he'd be found out were so infinitesimally small, only to end up winning the reverse lottery on the first day.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

No Man's Sky: Relics (New update)
35
2K
Trogdor1123 replied
No Mans Sky Nintendo Switch 2 Edition Trailer (Free Upgrade)
27
135
Soodanim replied
No Man's Sky Aquarius Update
38
3K
cyberheater replied
No politics in gaming on Neogaf
Live  2 3 4 5
249
2K
Pallas replied
[Verge] No Man’s Sky is getting a Switch 2 update in time for launch; New Expansion for all Platforms
18
80
yet_another_alt replied
Top Bottom