It really is a truly wonderful experience. I think all the superlatives for the game have been exhausted, so I won't bother. I'll have to sit on the game a bit before I decide where to place it, but I'm almost certain it's in my Top 10, possibly even Top 5.
I feel the same. I've been unable to post for the last few weeks and all the while I was just bursting with things to say about the game, but was unable to (no biggy, just couldn't log in anymore). Now that I'm able to post again, everything good (and bad) about the game has been said, so I don;t really feel the need to anymore.
Simply said: it's not my favorite Zelda, I'd still place OoT, MM, LA and LttP over it, but it's a Top-Tier Zelda for sure. I prefer traditional dungeons and items over the Sheikah slate and Shrines, but I completely understand why they went for this style and it works. I would have loved to have seen more variety in the shrines, there's too many copy/paste combat shrines and blessing shrines. I'd say remove those completely and make the overall world 15 or 20% smaller to compensate and we'd have a close to perfect game.
Another thing I don't really see mentioned is a lack of inside locations. I would have loved to see some properly designed caves or other structures, but there's hardly any of them. I loved Hyrule Castle, and I feel the game needed a few more of those type of locations. Also there's so many ruins, but never really anything of note to see or do, why not have a trapdoor every now and again that leads to an abandonend basement or something? I know they're really focused on the "open-air" adventure, but I really missed inside locations.
Also no graveyard? What the hell? I always love graveyards in Zelda games and I was so sure this was gonna have a great one simply becasue of the vastness of the game. How cold they not have even one tiny little graveyard? I was seriously lookig forward to a huge field of graves and pushing gravestones aside, hunting ghosts, finding catacombs and such, but nothing like that was anywhere to be found. Maybe it's a "don't put all your eggs in one basket" type situation and the next one is gonna have the mother of all graveyards.
Still though, even if the game isn't perfect, compared to most other games, this feels like next-level stuff. It's just better than 90% of games imo so what few criticisms I have are actually pretty light in the overall picture. I've played for close to 110 hours now and I still can't put it down. I've been playing Nier Automata in the meantime which is fun enough, but my mind's always in Hyrule.
I sincerely hope Nintendo's using BotW as a base for the next one. I hope the next one is gonna be what LA or MM were to its predecessors. At any rate, the future is looking good for Zelda as far as I'm concerned.