-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Meet The Switch Controller That Promises 'No Drifting, Ever' (Child of xbox and switch controller)
JetBlackPanda
Member
pro controllers don't drift anyways, right?
D
Deleted member 1159
Unconfirmed Member
Mine doesn’t, had it almost since launch
kingfey
Banned
Mine doesnt. But maybe because I spend less time playing.
Captain Toad
Banned
ALL controllers with analog sticks have units that get drift - Xbox, PlayStation, etc. This new controller will too.
But, yes, the Pro controller seems to have a more typical failure rate and nothing like the JoyCon drift.
NeoIkaruGAF
Gold Member
butane bob
Member
Yeah it's awful but to be fair, all of the current big 3 controllers have atrocious d-pads.
EverydayBeast
ChatGPT 0.001
The DualShock got better over time I like to think the ps6 controller will be better.
01011001
Banned
at least the XBox dpad is precise... but it's way too clicky and loud for sure.
the Razer Wolverine has a surprisingly good d-pad (the mechanism feels like a fight stick), but I have severe trust issues with 3rd party controllers, even the "good" ones often have deadzone or sensitivity curve issues -_-
also everything from Razer I ever used broke within like a year or so...
Last edited:
Knightime_X
Member
Oooh that controller looks nice!
Probably $150+
Edit: $70?
Hmm, might have to check it out.
Probably $150+
Edit: $70?
Hmm, might have to check it out.
Last edited:
SlimeGooGoo
Banned
.
Last edited:
FeldMonster
Member
Isn't the whole point of this controller that they are a using a Hall Effect sensor (i.e. non-contact) instead of the mechanisn that wears in other modern controllers.
justiceiro
Marlboro: Other M
Do they make those for wiiu too? My Wii u gamepad started drifting recently...
Krappadizzle
Member
Just replace the stick. I'd bet it's at best like a $2.00 fix and super easy to do.
MrTroubleMaker
Member
it will
StateofMajora
Banned
You got one with drift bro? My two pro controllers are going strong, all my joycons are fucked though, but at least I didn't pay for them lol.
The d pad thing I thought was an early issue that they fixed?
01011001
Banned
so their revolutionary tech here is using Hall Sensors?
like... the Dreamcast controller... that can totally drift too...
stick drift has exactly 2 causes:
1: The part that measures the stick position has a defect like metal flaking off
2: the feathers holding the stick up straight when you let it go loosen up
as far as I understand their controller only fixes that first issue... but not the second... right?
like... the Dreamcast controller... that can totally drift too...
stick drift has exactly 2 causes:
1: The part that measures the stick position has a defect like metal flaking off
2: the feathers holding the stick up straight when you let it go loosen up
as far as I understand their controller only fixes that first issue... but not the second... right?
Last edited:
Craig of War
Banned
I always wonder why Nintendo use the same form factor as the Xbox controller for their pro controller
guess it is really the best form factor for a controller
guess it is really the best form factor for a controller
01011001
Banned
because they were pushed to that because people are stubborn with their layout and don't want to learn a new one even tho it is superior...
this layout is better for many reasons, but the most important one is that both of your thumbs are relatively straight,
making precise movements in the 4 cardinal directions way easier.
but people simply couldn't get arsed to get used to it
nkarafo
Member
It is. There is a bigger gap between each thumb which means you can have wider movement before bumping on each other, especially if you have big hands.
You also have a different level of control on each hand, that's why you get right handed and left handed people. Making the design less symmetrical reflects on that.
Personally, even though my first dual analog controller was Sony's (because of the PS2) and played with it for many years before i got my first XBOX console, i still ended up loving the hold and feel of the XBOX pad much more.
I could never get used to the face buttons being lower than the analog stick.because they were pushed to that because people are stubborn with their layout and don't want to learn a new one even tho it is superior...
this layout is better for many reasons, but the most important one is that both of your thumbs are relatively straight,
making precise movements in the 4 cardinal directions way easier.
but people simply couldn't get arsed to get used to it
Last edited:
MightySquirrel
Banned
Looks somehow familiar. 
bitbydeath
Member
01011001
Banned
I got used to it really quickly. I played CoD Ghost on Wii U back in the day, and after an hour it was absolutely no issue anymore.
meanwhile having both sticks on the top felt amazing for shooters
Makoto-Yuki
Gold Member
this is funny cause it suggests Xbox/PS controllers don't get drift. Of all the controllers I've owned the only ones that haven't drifted were my Switch ones both joycons and pro model. My Xbox and PS4 controllers have drift. I went through a few Xbox replacements and I had to buy a new DS4 recently. I still have joycons from my launch Switch in 2017 and they play fine,
both joycons and pro model. My Xbox and PS4 controllers have drift. I went through a few Xbox replacements and I had to buy a new DS4 recently. I still have joycons from my launch Switch in 2017 and they play fine,
Craig of War
Banned
I prefer offset sticks way more it just feels so much better cause my thumbs line up like thatbecause they were pushed to that because people are stubborn with their layout and don't want to learn a new one even tho it is superior...
this layout is better for many reasons, but the most important one is that both of your thumbs are relatively straight,
making precise movements in the 4 cardinal directions way easier.
but people simply couldn't get arsed to get used to it
for me the best Nintendo controller is still the OG Gamecube controller layout with the offset sticks
NeoIkaruGAF
Gold Member
I had to fix the stick not once, but twice. Xenoblade 2 edition.
The D-Pad issue was never solved, that was just the internet being the internet and spreading lies because a new version (precisely, the Xenoblade one) had become available. I tried fixing the D-pad as well, but with limited results. Good luck playing Tetris with that controller’s D- pad.
About D-pads… this one’s was a pain. I used it to do the challenges in NSMBU and it simply destroyed my left thumb. It’s ridiculous how hard it seems for most controllers to nail the D-pad’s positioning and size, especially Nintendo since they invented the thing and used to do it perfectly all the way to the DS.because they were pushed to that because people are stubborn with their layout and don't want to learn a new one even tho it is superior...
this layout is better for many reasons, but the most important one is that both of your thumbs are relatively straight,
making precise movements in the 4 cardinal directions way easier.
but people simply couldn't get arsed to get used to it
justiceiro
Marlboro: Other M
Really? Isn't like a really custom part?
Icymanipulator
Member
My switch has been fine, but my $70 PS5 controller is drifting, not even 3 months old.
March Climber
Member
It makes no sense why they do.
Then again, the perfect mouse was also created years ago but Apple continues to stubbornly make their own worse yet overpriced one.
Krappadizzle
Member
I replaced the Wii U gamepad screen, which is considerably more work than the joystick for like $15 if I remember correctly. Bought it off Amazon and it even came with the small screwdrivers to open up the pad.
If I remember correctly, the joysticks are on for the first things you'll see when disassembling a gamepad.
FeldMonster
Member
I am an Xbox fan, and hate modern Nintendo, but I agree that this layout is superior for games that heavily use both sticks. Wish I could get an official Xbox controller in this layout for Halo/Destiny/TitanFall.because they were pushed to that because people are stubborn with their layout and don't want to learn a new one even tho it is superior...
this layout is better for many reasons, but the most important one is that both of your thumbs are relatively straight,
making precise movements in the 4 cardinal directions way easier.
but people simply couldn't get arsed to get used to it
Wheeljack539
Member
It makes no sense why they do.
Then again, the perfect mouse was also created years ago but Apple continues to stubbornly make their own worse yet overpriced one.
I can't be the only one that while I liked the idea of 6 in front I hated the placement. Especially when playing Street Fighter Alpha 2 Gold on Saturn and trying to hit all three buttons for a Level 3 super and having to angle my thumb downwards. Nintendo did the same thing with the updated top loading NES controller button layout.
daveonezero
Banned
Did anyone get this thing? My pro controller seems to be drifting it’s screwing up my Hades play and always aiming me to the lower right.
Not sure if I should replace the sticks or buy this or and 8bitdo.
On second thought replacing seems to require soldering something I’m not ready to get into yet.
So ya is this thing or the Switch Pro. In my mind I like HD rumble but not sure if I even notice it on the Switch Pro controller.
Not sure if I should replace the sticks or buy this or and 8bitdo.
On second thought replacing seems to require soldering something I’m not ready to get into yet.
So ya is this thing or the Switch Pro. In my mind I like HD rumble but not sure if I even notice it on the Switch Pro controller.
Last edited:
64gigabyteram
Reverse groomer.
Drifting is so widespread these days. Nintendo controllers have it, Sony controllers have it as well, and even XBOX controllers are having it
These new analog sticks they use for controllers are fucking awful. last gen we didn't hear about this drifting issue. I beat the shit out of my Wii u gamepad and the sticks on those are still working as well as the day i first got them
These new analog sticks they use for controllers are fucking awful. last gen we didn't hear about this drifting issue. I beat the shit out of my Wii u gamepad and the sticks on those are still working as well as the day i first got them
Any analog stick with mechanical parts will drift eventually. The sensors become dirty or worn from use. Joycon and vita drift is more apparent due to the type of analog stick used by the consoles. I have 3 PS5 controllers and two Xbox controllers in my queue waiting for new analog sticks due to drift. PS5 controllers are my most commonly repaired accessory lately. Second is still joycons with broken LR buttons.
ReBurn
Gold Member
Oh but we did. Youtube is full of videos of people fixing drifting PS4 and XOne analog sticks. There are also plenty of teardowns showing that this gen's controllers use pretty much exactly the same analog sticks as last gen.
Last edited:
