'Switch 2' Doesn't Really Need Backwards Compatibility - Nintendolife

Does Switch 2 Really Need Backwards Compatibility?

  • Yes

    Votes: 336 91.1%

  • No

    Votes: 33 8.9%
  • Total voters
    369
Walter Matthau

Walter Matthau

Member
Original Article:
www.nintendolife.com

Soapbox: 'Switch 2' Doesn't Really Need Backwards Compatibility

Much as we all want it
www.nintendolife.com www.nintendolife.com

Summary (via ChatGPT)
I'd love the next Nintendo console, 'Switch 2', to be backward compatible, allowing us to play older games on the new system. It's a convenient feature that offers peace of mind and eases the transition to a new console.

Lifelong gamers value compatibility for the assurance of accessing their existing library easily. Still, Switch owners are more likely to keep their old consoles handy, making it less of an issue compared to bulkier home consoles.

From Nintendo's perspective, emphasizing backward compatibility may not outweigh the potential drawbacks, such as hacking risks and piracy. Maintaining a clean break from the previous platform is crucial to establish the new system's identity.

Additionally, Nintendo might prefer not to re-release last-gen games. Unlike previous instances, where Wii U ports were essential due to its commercial failure, Switch has thrived, and beloved titles like Breath of the Wild don't need reissues.

For those concerned about retro games, NSO could offer a solution. While specifics may vary, maintaining this service is crucial for continuity.
Click to expand...

Nintendo historically has done a reasonably good job in having backwards compatibility so it's hard to imagine them forgoing it this time around unless the new system's architecture or control scheme is drastically different than the current Switch (like the Switch was to the Wii U and 3DS). I believe it will be a priority for them to transition their base over as quickly as possible and backwards compatibility would be a pretty critical selling point in the first year or two of sales.

Betting time: Do you think the Switch 2 can still be a success if it doesn't have backwards compatibility?
 
Yes it will still be a big success if it does not have BC but...I mean, it's 100% sure that it will be. That article is dumb dumb.
 
Nintendo, I'm sure, would love it to not be BC so that they could sell you the same games for yet another generation. I grew up on Ninty, I love their properties, but some of their decisions just baffle me so it wouldn't surprise me if they did something stupid like this.
 
Yes. Why would I invest in an online library (what all our publishers actually want) if I'm not guaranteed to take my library with me?
 
If they want to keep their customers locked into their ecosystem, it better have BC. Otherwise you risk to lose your customers to a competing platform since a platform-move to the next Switch would be like a soft reset. This service-based, account-based, ecosystem-based business model requires that you can assure the customer that the shit he buys stays with him, so that he buys more shit and is more and more unlikely to change to another ecosystem.
 
Imagine being a Switch digital only gamer and hearing publications making excuses on how the next Switch doesn't really need BC; I'd be fuming.
In any case, if Nintendo is stupid enough to not add BC then at least I can sell all my games and for a pretty penny too since the entirety of my Switch library is physical.
 
Last edited:
Not buying one without it.

I skipped on Switch and only way I will get 2 is if it's BC.

Else I will just get Switch and play those games there.
 
If it has BC, I'm a day one purchase. If not, I'll wait and see if it gets any games that pique my interest. BC needs to be a consistent thing.
 
Of course it doesn't. Nintendo will very happily sell you the same games again.

(I can understand not having full BC, but still bitter about what happened to my Wii digital library, which should have been easily available on Switch)
 
If it is a "Switch 2" - yes or course it does. It is not 1995 anymore. This is expected with new devices. If it is a different device, a new paradigm, that is a different story.
 
Filben said:
Yes. Why would I invest in an online library (what all our publishers actually want) if I'm not guaranteed to take my library with me?
Click to expand...
This exactly. One of my personal determining factors when buying a digital game is "will I be able to play this in the future?". Nintendo has, so far, proven that they can't be trusted to carry a digital library forward - which is why I predominantly only buy Switch games on physical cartridges (and then rip them to my PC).

If a game is released for Switch, PlayStation, Xbox, and PC (and is digital only) I'm more likely at this point to buy it on anything other than the Switch, especially digitally.

If the Switch 2 is announced to be backwards compatible, not only will I buy one Day One but I'll also pick up a handful of digital titles that I've been holding off on because their future is currently uncertain.
 
I mean.... Everyone buying a Switch 2 (or at least 90% of the people who do) already own a Switch 1. If no BC, just keep playing and finishing the games on your current one.
 
diffusionx said:
If it is a "Switch 2" - yes or course it does. It is not 1995 anymore. This is expected with new devices. If it is a different device, a new paradigm, that is a different story.
Click to expand...
I think so as well. Unless its has very unique parts inside.
 
Suck Up Yes Man GIF by Noise Nest Network
 
Stupid clickbait article designed to do exactly what it's doing right now, getting people annoyed and talking about it. Nah.
 
The title prompted a no vote out of me by mistake. Could some consistency between title and poll be implemented in the future? It better be backwards compatible.
 
clarky said:
Maybe im missing something here? When has a Nintendo system actually had BC?
Click to expand...
The WiiU could play Wii games
The Wii could play Gamecube games
The 3DS could play DS games
The DS could play Gameboy Advance games
The Gameboy Advance could play Gameboy Color and Gameboy games
The Gameboy Color could play Gameboy games

And that's not counting stuff like the SNES being able to play Gameboy games (with an adapter) or the Gamecube being able to play Gameboy Advance games (with an adapter). Or the mid-gen refreshes like the New 3DS or DSi also working with their existing library.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Switch 2 Backwards Compatibility Page Launches on JP Website, Lists Compatible and Games w/ Issues
2
56
4K
Heimdall_Xtreme replied
  • Locked
Backwards Compatibility Confirmed for Switch Successor
Hardware 
1
413
Robb replied
Doesn't look like Switch 2 will be scarce at launch?
2
69
3K
Same ol G replied
What if… Switch 2 has a dock with a disc drive for backwards compatibility?
Hardware  2
85
4K
diffusionx replied
Moving from Switch to Switch 2, what you need to know.
47
2K
LakeOf9 replied
Top Bottom