• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Contraband cancelled- Schreiet

Microsoft hasn't done anything here besides fund a studio for 5 years and all we've seen is a logo.

No gameplay, no screenshots, nothing.

If you were paying people to build a house and 5 years in you still had a vacant lot you would tell them to fuck off as well. Studios need to be held responsible at some point, the same way Sony & Microsoft let several of these studios have to much leeway sinking 100s of millions with nothing to show for it.

How games are showcased are up to the pr department at ms not the studio. There are plans for these things. That you haven't seen anything doesn't mean there isn't anything there.
 
It's the other way around, after buying Activision they came at the same conclusion that Bobby Kotick did years ago : why waste time and money on risky projects when you can print billions by making the same thing forever and ever
same with valve and steam.
 
It's a good news for two reasons

1) Another shit GaaS bites the dust. Studios should understand that going the GaaS route could mean the death knell for them
2) Xbox fucks another developer yet again. Every studio should know that working with MS should be avoided at all cost as they are currently the worst publisher in gaming and cannot be trusted

I'm sad about Avalanche however. Hope they manage to land on their feet.
Did it say anywhere that was GAAS? For what I watched from the CGI trailer right now, it's a co-op game, being that doesn't make it GAAS, does it?
 
Last edited:
iu
 
They released 8 full-scale games in 10 years (1.25 games/year avg) only to spend SIX years on Contraband with nothing to show for it. GaaS and its repercussions have been a disaster for the human race.

2006: Just Cause
2009: The Hunter
2010: Just Cause 2
2011: Renegade Ops
2015: The Hunter: Primal, Mad Max, Just Cause 3
2018: Just Cause 4
2019: Rage 2
wtf rage 2 was that late??????????????????
 
off t but why do we hate destin?????
I've only seen a handful of his videos. The ones I saw where it's a group discussion he acts all weird. I didnt know anything about him going into it, but I honestly thought he had mental issues or had autism or something. Weird guy. But then I saw some of his solo videos and he seemed like a good guy speaking clearly.
 
If I'm a publisher, any game that isn't playable start to finish after 3 years, gets canceled. Last year can only be polish and refinement. Only exceptions to this would be the absolute heaviest of hitters. I'd still milestone them harshly, just find a different marker. Only exceptions would be the GTAs, Elder Scrolls of the world. I still do not believe the dev times need to be as long as they are. Everyone else is convinced because a man with an unkept beard and graphic t shirt told them so. Sure you probably could spend 8 years making Avowed or DA: Vag Guard, but I don't think it's necessary. Half Life Alyx - 4 years. Metro Exodus 4 years. Resident Evil Village 3.5 years. Control 3.5 years.

Unless Contraband was in the polishing stages, I would have canned it to. And I love that developer.
 
Last edited:
Exactly Microsoft funded the studio and should of been a lot more hands on in those 5 years, you can't just blame the devs and leave out MS, that's ridiculous, they own the studio, their money, they didn't bother checking in on them, story end of.

Microsoft don't own the studio? They agreed to fund the game that's it, the studio itself is privately owned company that creates games.
 
Microsoft hasn't done anything here besides fund a studio for 5 years and all we've seen is a logo.

No gameplay, no screenshots, nothing.

If you were paying people to build a house and 5 years in you still had a vacant lot you would tell them to fuck off as well. Studios need to be held responsible at some point, the same way Sony & Microsoft let several of these studios have to much leeway sinking 100s of millions with nothing to show for it.

Microsoft don't own the studio? They agreed to fund the game that's it, the studio itself is privately owned company that creates games.
So explain to us why ms funded this studio for 5 years and not get any gameplay or screenshots? Such incompetence from the person doing the funding.
 
So explain to us why ms funded this studio for 5 years and not get any gameplay or screenshots? Such incompetence from the person doing the funding.

Did you read my actual comment that you're quoting saying Sony & Microsoft fumbled giving these studios too much leeway while seeing nothing promising in return?

I'm sure they where shown something, there's been a breakdown but and they need better oversight and people in positions monitoring these companies and milestones being hit before more funds are released.
 
They paid blur studios half a million for a CG trailer and spent 4 years making a live service game that was deemed unsalvageable.
I think MS needs to be way more involved in its studios development and making sure it's going in the right direction but this was a hard miss from the avalanche leadership to start with.
 
I've only seen a handful of his videos. The ones I saw where it's a group discussion he acts all weird. I didnt know anything about him going into it, but I honestly thought he had mental issues or had autism or something. Weird guy. But then I saw some of his solo videos and he seemed like a good guy speaking clearly.
Destin just like me for real
 
So explain to us why ms funded this studio for 5 years and not get any gameplay or screenshots? Such incompetence from the person doing the funding.

You're making it sound like the cancelation was fully justified, not having anything to show after 5 years on the devs behalf 🤔
 
The power of gamepass.

People 10 years from now will realize how terrible a subscription service like GamePass was on the gaming industry.

The reason I think OD is next is, why would they fund another studio to make a game when they're not even funding like half the people at their own studios?

Kojima would pitch it to other Publishers, before he allows MS to cancel it.
 
why what did i do??

It's generally considered a breach of forum etiquette to make more than one post in a row, and you made five in a row. Not a big deal - we obviously aren't Miss Manners around here - but it kind of sticks out.

Adam said "use edit," but really what you need to do is multiquote, so you don't have to make separate posts to respond one by one. See that "+Quote" button in the lower right? Click on it, and it will add all the posts you want to reply to into a "clipboard" sort of holding file. When you click Reply and a new post opens, you'll see an option to "add quotes." You can add all the quotes you want and reply to them individually, but all within the space of a single post (i.e., not needing to take 5 different posts to do it). Cheers.

(edit: Ah, I see you did it yourself in post 186. That's what I'm talking about.)
 
Last edited:
Microsoft hasn't done anything here besides fund a studio for 5 years and all we've seen is a logo.

No gameplay, no screenshots, nothing.

If you were paying people to build a house and 5 years in you still had a vacant lot you would tell them to fuck off as well. Studios need to be held responsible at some point, the same way Sony & Microsoft let several of these studios have to much leeway sinking 100s of millions with nothing to show for it.
Game devs have an advantage over other people in other industries.

They can grift it for years of salary before a company finally pulls the plug on their shitty game. In other kinds of jobs, youre usually thrown in and expect to perform right away. You'll get your 3 months or maybe even 6 months of easy going management. But pretty soon you got to get the ball rolling. If some marketing manger fucks up a brand and the sales and share sink after a year, or an account manager struggles and his account tanks sales, they'll be on the firing line pretty soon. Maybe already gone. In finance, youre pretty much expected to know numbers and spreadsheets right away and contribute asap.

Nobody in these departments gets 3, 4 or 5 years of time before someone finally makes a decision to go or no go.

It would never happen (except in extreme cases like embezzlement or stealing secrets kind of thing), but IMO any people doing such a shit job should be sued and pay back the company something for a waste of time.

It's really no different than if you borrow your neighbours lawn mower and fuck up and break it. You pay the guy back for messing up. Or if some people get into a car accident, the guy at fault covers it through insurance. or if you hire someone to fix something. If they fuck up, they owe you. In none of these examples does the guy get off free saying..... "oh sorry bud, thats your problem. But thanks for your money. Also, if you want me to go away, you also got to pay me again"

But somehow, people fucking up doing a bad job owes nothing. If anything they get rewarded. Not only do they get paid, but they always get paid severance to go away. So net result of doing a bad job.... you can get paid twice. How does that make sense?
 
Last edited:
It's generally considered a breach of forum etiquette to make more than one post in a row, and you made five in a row. Not a big deal - we obviously aren't Miss Manners around here - but it kind of sticks out.

Adam said "use edit," but really what you need to do is multiquote, so you don't have to make separate posts to respond one by one. See that "+Quote" button in the lower right? Click on it, and it will add all the posts you want to reply to into a "clipboard" sort of holding file. When you click Reply and a new post opens, you'll see an option to "add quotes." You can add all the quotes you want and reply to them individually, but all within the space of a single post (i.e., not needing to take 5 different posts to do it). Cheers.

(edit: Ah, I see you did it yourself in post 186. That's what I'm talking about.)
oh i did not know gaf does have a cool down timer.
oh ok thanks i will read the entire thread next time and make multi quotes if the same question pops up and no one's answered it thanks.
 
oh i did not know gaf does have a cool down timer.
oh ok thanks i will read the entire thread next time and make multi quotes if the same question pops up and no one's answered it thanks.
It's considered spam when you triple post. GAF mods hasn't given warnings about it in a long time.
 
It's a good news for two reasons

1) Another shit GaaS bites the dust. Studios should understand that going the GaaS route could mean the death knell for them
2) Xbox fucks another developer yet again. Every studio should know that working with MS should be avoided at all cost as they are currently the worst publisher in gaming and cannot be trusted

I'm sad about Avalanche however. Hope they manage to land on their feet.


Another reason:

Sweet Baby Inc

Z2joxglsGSeX8qt5.jpg
 
What the hell is Contraband? I don't remember this game every being announced and now it's canceled?
 
What the hell is Contraband? I don't remember this game every being announced and now it's canceled?
I barely remembered it myself until this thread. I even thought it was a fist party game. Turns it out it was made by the Just Cause dev.

It had one trailer in 2021. Thats it.

They musta had such trash in development, they hadnt said one thing about the game or even a tiny snippet since that trailer. It was so long ago, PS5 and SX just launched half a year earlier.
 
Last edited:
blade is next imo.
Apparently Blade entered full production after several years (!) of pitching ideas and making a prototype. I'd say it's safe, but not what happens to og Arkane once they finish it.

Besides the new Blade movie is in production hell so it's not like there's major rush to release it not long after and capitalize on its popularity.
 
Top Bottom