• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Xboxera: Xbox is Dead. Long Live Xbox

IbizaPocholo

NeoGAFs Kent Brockman

Xbox is not "dead" but fundamentally transformed: it has shifted from a console-centric identity to a broad, service-driven ecosystem focused on accessibility, multiplatform publishing, and consistent content delivery, and 2025 marked the year this strategy clearly paid off.

Summary

  • The article challenges the recurring claim that "Xbox is dead," arguing that the phrase has become meaningless clickbait rather than a serious assessment of the brand's health.
  • Historically, Xbox has been repeatedly declared "dead" during past crises such as the Xbox 360 Red Ring of Death and the Xbox One reveal, yet the brand has persisted and evolved.
  • In 2025, Xbox as a business is financially strong: Microsoft is one of the largest publishers in the industry, and Game Pass has tens of millions of subscribers.
  • What has truly "died" is the traditional idea of Xbox as primarily a physical console ("the box") and the emotional loyalty tied to hardware exclusivity.
  • Xbox's modern philosophy is summarized by the mantra "Every screen is an Xbox," meaning players can access Xbox games across consoles, PCs, handhelds, phones, smart TVs, and cloud streaming.
  • Microsoft has deliberately stepped away from the console wars and the belief that exclusivity inherently creates value.
  • Xbox consoles still exist and will continue to exist, but they are no longer the central pillar of the brand.
  • The company's pivot reflects industry realities: rising development costs, thin margins on hardware, and diminishing returns from exclusivity.
  • Xbox positions itself differently from competitors:
    • Sony emphasizes prestige and a destination ecosystem.
    • Nintendo emphasizes creativity and "magic."
    • Xbox emphasizes accessibility and utility.
  • Multiplatform releases, including Xbox games on PlayStation, are framed not as surrender but as abandoning the illusion that withholding content benefits players.
  • A major criticism of Xbox in past years was poor execution and delayed promises; 2025 is presented as the year Xbox finally delivered consistently.
  • Throughout 2025, Xbox released a steady cadence of high-quality games rather than relying on one or two prestige launches.
  • Notable first-party and associated releases mentioned include:
    • Avowed
    • Ninja Gaiden 4
    • Doom: The Dark Ages
    • The Outer Worlds 2
    • Oblivion Remastered
    • South of Midnight
    • Keeper
    • Call of Duty (annual release)
    • Grounded 2 (early access)
  • Game Pass is highlighted as a major strength due to its breadth, curation, and consistent addition of quality titles across many genres.
  • The article argues that mainstream discourse often focuses on what Xbox is not (market leader, prestige brand, console war winner) rather than what it actually is.
  • Common criticisms—such as claims that Game Pass is unsustainable or that multiplatform publishing signals failure—are dismissed as coming from commentators who do not actively play on Xbox.
  • The author emphasizes that Xbox has a large, active player community that continues to receive frequent, diverse content.
  • The old Xbox model, defined by hardware launches and exclusive "system-seller" titles, is described as finished.
  • The modern Xbox model is defined by scale, consistency, variety, and accessibility across platforms.
  • Looking ahead, the article suggests that Xbox's 2026 lineup appears even stronger, reinforcing confidence in the brand's future.
  • Overall, the piece concludes that while Xbox has changed dramatically, it is thriving in its new form rather than dying.
 
Xbox is not "dead"

It's dead as fuck! Papa Phil failed us

RIP

(another cope article)
ruaOe5LlZU32tVNB.png




Improve Mad Men GIF
 
Last edited:
Xbox died for me the day I compared the Xbox 360 and Playstation 3 spec sheets. The first half of the 360 gen it seemed like maybe it was gonna work out, but yeah, been pretty much all downhill since that day. Damn shame since my appreciation of the OG Xbox grows by the day. It truly was the Omega Console.
 
Last edited:
It's obvious people mean the gaming console Xbox is dead. MS taking the other brand direction as your "gotcha" that it isn't dead is hilarious. Basically letting yourself get gaslit.

Beyond that most of what "Xbox" is consists of companies MS absorbed in the last 5 years. They bought their way into 3rd party publishing, and their biggest IP's weren't there until very recently.

Microsoft isn't done with gaming but what people knew as Xbox is very close to dead.
 
Last edited:
2025 marked the year this strategy clearly paid off.

WTF? Paid off how?

Multiplatform releases, including Xbox games on PlayStation, are framed not as surrender but as abandoning the illusion that withholding content benefits players

LOL. Yeah guys, they did this because they care about the players! It wasn't because, despite buying half the damn gaming industry, their first party games weren't good enough to sell Xboxes. They did it for us!
 
"And so, 'Xbox is dead' lives on. One of the most persistent and patently absurd refrains across this industry is driven by people who just never play there. "

Plenty of people USED to play there. That's exactly the point.

Joe Biden Politics GIF by The Democrats
 
The article doesn't really disprove "Xbox is dead" so much as redefine what "dead" means. Sure, the term "dead" is overused to death and weaponized by console warrior morons. But, this whole piece tries to wave away criticism instead of acknowledging the real concerns — like declining engagement, weak hardware momentum, and a blurry platform identity.

It reads less like a fair rebuttal and more like an attempt to reframe the problem out of existence.
 
There are still Sega fanboys who act out in current year so the "I'm not owned" mantra from these guys is going to be going well into 2075: A Cyberpunk Story.
 
Microsoft's flagship console was outsold by the Nintendo Switch by nearly 4:1. Not the Switch 2 - that did 10:1 - the Switch, Nintendo's last gen machine. Xbox is dead.

Microsoft transitioning into a third party publisher might be very successful if they actually just did it instead of continuing their absurdist take that they've magically turned iPhones into Xboxes. "My PlayStation is now an Xbox because I bought Grounded 2" doesn't make any fucking sense and only compounds their elongated failure. If they don't pull their head out of their ass soon, they really will be dead because no one will buy what they're selling on any platform.
 
This article claiming Xbox isn't dead but Xbox consoles are dead but that's exactly what 90% of people refer to. Xbox consoles are dead. Nobody cares if the Xbox brand dies. It's now in the same category as the EA or Ubisoft brand. Software.
 
^^^ That's right. Everyone saying xbox is dead is talking about a console. Because that's what an xbox is and always has been.

If xbox was turning into a competent hardware-agnostic platform like steam, I might feel a little differently. They'd be prepared to carry on that self-contained console like experience in a different way. But they have nothing going on but a shitty xbox app and now a half baked big picture mode.
 
"And so, 'Xbox is dead' lives on. One of the most persistent and patently absurd refrains across this industry is driven by people who just never play there. "

Plenty of people USED to play there. That's exactly the point.

Joe Biden Politics GIF by The Democrats

It's such an ignorant, tribalist mentality to think that people who view Xbox as dead, and especially dead to them, are just "haters from opposing fanbases". Some of my fondest gaming memories happened on Xbox and Xbox 360. The latter is one of my favorite gaming devices ever. Halo is still dear to me, despite all the fuck ups. I still cross my fingers that some day they'll do another Kameo, Killer Instinct, or Viva Pinata.

But, I'm not going to pretend that the house that was built by James Allard and Peter Moore didn't get taken over and burned down by soulless business suits. Ones that have not one lick of understanding for creativity in them. Why? So I don't hurt the fee-fees of pitiful drones who kept giving them a pass to be utter failures because they married their personality to a brand?
 
Xbox is not dead, it has successfully shifted to an ultra efficient subterranean mode of aliveness that consumes no energy, doesn't need oxygen and requires no brain activity.
 
The modern Xbox model is defined by scale, consistency, variety, and accessibility across platforms...

note the absence of 'profitability'. & also 'lack of sales data', something that's come to define the modern xbox model more than just about anything else...
 
| Xbox is not "dead" but fundamentally transformed: it has shifted from a console-centric identity to a broad, service-driven ecosystem focused on accessibility, multiplatform publishing, and consistent content delivery, and 2025 marked the year this strategy clearly paid off.

Same vibes as.

"My dog is not "dead" but fundamentally transformed. It is now living on a far away farm that I can't visit for some reason, but he is enjoying a lot, playing in the open field. My dog's is super happy, and the plan for his good life clearly paid off."
 
WTF? Paid off how?

LOL. Yeah guys, they did this because they care about the players! It wasn't because, despite buying half the damn gaming industry, their first party games weren't good enough to sell Xboxes. They did it for us!
Xboxera did the same song and dance a year ago saying how amazing xbox is for doing the "this is an xbox" campaign. Even went as far as calling the backlash the "xbox tax". The exact same talking points too. How it wasn't a surrender but all about being "pro-consumer". Xboxera benefits from "xbox" the brand not becoming irrelevant. They know the console is irrelevant today but are clinging on to the brand being attached to other things.


I said in 2023 they would attach the xbox brand to other things because the console is dying:
MS killed the Xbox brand for the gamepass strategy but now they kind of have to pretend that other things are still 'Xbox' to not make it that obvious their strategy has shrink xbox the console to the point where it's doing worse year after year, gen after gen. Wouldn't want people thinking it's been abandoned and killing all xbox sales quickly though so MS have got to tie other parts of the business like mobile and PC to the 'xbox' branding to try and create this positive buzz about it knowing full well their strategy means what was originally 'xbox' is kind of irrelevant now in the grand scheme of things.


This was before the "this is an xbox" campaign too. Xboxera are just a MS mouthpiece and what they're saying is predictable for selfpreservation because they're based on "xbox" themselves. If MS truly cared about the consumer it would stop timed exclusives entirely, but it won't. If xbox was relevant today and they weren't reliant on PS and PC for sales they would have been screwing them even harder.
 
Top Bottom