stop talking for a sec so I can spam yall
The Rock tearing down the house at Madison Square Garden on interviews, or even having a good match in his first time back as a participant in seven-and-a-half years should have been expected.
But watching a guy at 39 be even quicker than he was at 29, well, that first impression for his first in-ring sequence since 2004 was not expected, with a few lightning fast armdrags and a quick house cleaning of foils R-Truth and The Miz.
The 2011 Survivor Series on 11/20 was a very different show. For one night, wrestling was cool, and while Rock brought the people in, in many ways it was the fans who were the stars of the show. They came to see The Rock, to boo John Cena and to make Zack Ryder. Cody Rhodes came across for the first time in his career like a superstar who had arrived. C.M. Punk came across like the kind of guy who can lead the company. Ryder, who didn’t even wrestle, was, aside from Rock, the biggest star of the night to the degree that Rock even put him over as fans chanted “We Want Ryder” during his promo after the show went off the air.
Were they there to see wrestling matches? Not really. It was more to be not just at an event, but to be the event. It’s one thing when it was the ECW Arena in the 90s when you had 1,000 people doing funny chants in unison, and something else when you get 17,000 people doing it, and obviously it doesn’t take more than a few to start chants and a few hundred can make tons of noise and it feels like it’s the whole crowd, but it comes across so much more big time.
Rock got the reaction one would expect, and Cena did as well, but perhaps even more vehemently than usual. It was easily 90% negative to Cena, and vociferously so. This is a prelude to WrestleMania and says loud and clear that the audience that Rock brings to the table is an audience that hates Cena. The question then becomes what do you do with Cena for the next few months. The people have already turned him heel. But there’s the risk, in the sense that when it comes to big shows, yeah, you get that Male 18-34 who wants to see a big event. But when it comes to house shows, that audience is not coming in great numbers and it’s a kids and parents audience, plus so much of the merchandise income is based on catering to kids. The big kids favorites have been Cena, Rey Mysterio, who is gone with knee surgery, and Sin Cara had become a favorite with that group, and he’s also now needing knee surgery.
There are a lot of issues with turning Cena, including fear of alienating that fan base, his merchandise and all of his charity work. They’ve learned the lesson of the failed 2001 Steve Austin turn where business went down hard and fast and never recovered, with the idea that because Austin had brought so many people to the table, that his being a heel made them check out. Even though Cena is no Austin, he also has brought a lot of people to the table. In the past, while Cena being turned has at times been open for discussion, the talks usually end based on his merchandise sales. C.M. Punk may have passed him (Punk claims he has and I’m sure he did in August which was the big month but then September was down from the prior year), but it was noted that Cena is a proven long term merchandise seller while Punk had one big month and fell greatly. In addition, reportedly just this last week Vince noted that when you look at the people who move ratings, that Cena is far and away the biggest (except for Rock who is part-time) and the only person on the roster you can count on to move numbers. There is no guarantee with a heel turn that will still be the case. There have been babyfaces who were big ratings draws that were turned heel and their ratings drawing power went way down.
I wouldn’t use this night at MSG which drew a very specialized pro-Rock audience as a barometer for the world, but Rock or Punk or Mick Foley or the announcers or the other faces can’t endorse Cena and make this audience like him. And they’ve certainly tried every trick in the book, including Cena’s role as being the good guy who praises the fans when they boo him because he likes it when they express their unfiltered viewpoint. It’s almost comical to watch every trick they try and have an audience that is usually fairly easy to control and manipulate dig in their heels and resist all the tricks to get people to cheer Cena, even to the extent of booing other faces who praise him. Even though most figure Cena vs. Rock is going to do monster business, and it is, there are people not happy and noted that this was the exact fear of what would happen in booking a Cena vs. Rock program.
They can’t script him making saves for other faces, endorsing the Ryder like cult favorites that the people are behind or all the methods of subliminally tricking the audience to have the kneejerk reaction of being behind him. This is the same dynamic that Hulk Hogan faced in 1996, and if anything, it’s a lot stronger. The difference is that Cena is still moving merchandise and Hogan really wasn’t as a face by that point, and Hogan did have a hot angle that everyone knew was already a hot angle to jump into. Cena may not have a hot group, but he does have what could possibly be the biggest money single event in the history of the industry. But the good thing from a WWE standpoint is that whether they turn him or not, Cena is not just a heel in this program but a super strong heel to the audience that will be in Miami, and the cities leading up to Mania, and the majority of those watching on television.
If this exact crowd reaction took place in Montreal or Toronto or Mexico City, Vince McMahon would have ordered the announcers to insult their own audience. Instead, it’s New York, and in their minds, when it happens in Toronto, it’s people trying to ruin the show. If it’s in New York, it’s a barometer of where things are going, even if the day after the place was filled with people with Ryder merchandise and chanting his name loudly before, during and after the show. This in many ways was reminiscent of the night Giant Baba called the audible before the show based on his feel of the crowd and had Mitsuharu Misawa pin Jumbo Tsuruta, and I’m not trying to say Ryder could have become Misawa if he had won the U.S. title on this show, but for a company that changes plans dozens of times weekly, to have the guy on this night in his home city win what is essentially a meaningless mid-card title just to throw the audience a bone wouldn’t have been that hard to do. I expect based on the build that they have plans for Ryder to eventually win and it will get over. As far as plans for him to graduate to being a top guy, the way he’s booked now seems like they don’t take it seriously and see him at that level. Long-term, nobody knows, but to me, when somebody who doesn’t fit the mold of your perception of a top guy catches fire, you go with him and see how far he goes, instead of book him like a prelim guy for whatever mentality you have to show that you are in charge and you decide when stars are made. The thing is, they are pushing his petition and they did give Ryder a cameo tease where he looked good at this show. My gut is they put John Morrison against Ziggler instead of Ryder as a strategy to get the people wanting Ziggler vs. Ryder more, but I can’t believe anyone could have anticipated this level of groundswell. And clearly by his booking losing to Del Rio via armbar in just 2:24 at Raw, even now they don’t see him as above the Kofi Kingston level.
As for Rock, he did two promos, one early in the show and one after the show was over. The first was awesome and I wish it was done on the Raw go-home show because it would have made Survivor Series from MSG seen like a much bigger deal. They also did a great video package on his life and career (and with Cena as well), and again, why this wasn’t on Raw last week makes no sense. I get the fear that a video package may cause minute-by-minute ratings to drop, but in the big picture, that doesn’t even mean one-tenth of a rating point when the show is over and when the ability is there to make a PPV show seem special and out of the ordinary, those things should be taken advantage of. We’ve already seen with boxing and UFC what kind of dynamics today draw larger than usual numbers, and you can’t do that with 13 or 14 shows a year, but you can with three to five, and clearly you could have here.
Rock not only talked about his debut in Madison Square Garden 15 years ago at the 1996 Survivor Series, but went back farther than that, all the way to being a five-year-old in 1977 when his grandfather, High Chief Peter Maivia, challenged Superstar Billy Graham for the WWWF title. He talked about 1984, at the age of 12, hanging out with Andre the Giant (which he said twice, the first time not getting that big a pop until he commanded the bigger pop), and watching his dad defend the WWF (which was sound edited) tag team title.
The second saw him say that November 20, 2011, was the greatest day of his wrestling career and he said this was just the beginning of his run. He thanked the audience, reacted to the audience including after the millionth Ryder chant of the night, put over Ryder (this impromptu reaction was the only part that made television). Fans were chanting “You still got it,” and “Welcome back,” at the same time and he joked that the fans would have to choose one or the other (they chose the former). At one point when he started to get emotional about being back wrestling in MSG (MSG itself was a big part of this because of what MSG represented in the territorial days regarding headlining that arena and the coincidences of Rock beginning, end and the night it really became clear he was going to be the next big thing all coming in MSG) and a fan said, “Don’t cry,” he responded back, “The Rock doesn’t cry” and made a reference to how you must have some good weed in these parts leading to a chant of “Weed, Weed.”
Johnson wanted to come back quicker and sharper in the ring than when he left and said he was in the best shape of his career. Cosmetically, dieted down, he looked more like a bodybuilder than the very fit football player look he had as a 260-270 pounder. But as everyone has seen for decades, looking like a bodybuilder gives no indication of being a great performer once the bell sounds. Now, doing some early practiced spots and a hot tag to a finish is very different from doing a 20:00 singles match, but his performance was exactly what it should have been. He came in, looked more impressive in his short stint than probably most expected. He showed enough to whet people’s appetite without showing so much that they think they’ve seen the real deal, which should be saved for WrestleMania.
Rock & Cena beat The Miz & R-Truth in the main event. Rock was in to shine at the beginning, with action so fast that he appeared to be the quickest big guy in the company even today. Most of the match was Cena selling, which didn’t get traditional heat. It was more amusing because the crowd wouldn’t get behind Cena no matter how much he sold. When Rock was in early there was a “Don’t tag Cena” chant. At the end, when he finally hot tagged in, he did several of his trademark spots, sold briefly, and eventually used the people’s elbow to pin Miz. Post-match, Rock and Cena took turns climbing to ropes to cheerlead the crowd, with the crowd cheering half of the team like crazy and booing the other half out the building. The final scene was Rock laying Cena out with a rock bottom.
From a wrestling standpoint, the show was really no better than most WWE PPV shows, and worse than many of the better ones. But almost everyone enjoyed it because they came to see one thing, and that one thing delivered, and the atmosphere made it come across as a special and historic night, the best since Money in the Bank. The crowd had its mind made up all night about what it wanted and what was going to standout and what it didn’t want. Even though John Morrison vs. Dolph Ziggler had a strong opener, the best wrestled match on the show, the crowd was mad because they wanted Ryder in that spot.
They didn’t want to see Mark Henry vs. Big Show, so they entertained themselves with chants for Undertaker (there were rumors that he would return at this show but I never put much stock in those), D-Lo Brown (Henry’s former partner), Sexual Chocolate (a one-time nickname and bad gimmick of Henry’s), Mae Young, Randy Savage (when Big Show did an elbow off the top rope). At one point, after Henry laid Show out with a tackle through the barricade, when a double count out was teased and Show just beat the count, the crowd booed. I’m not sure if it was because they wanted Henry to win, or more likely, they wanted the match to end. The match, aside from two memorable spots, the barricade spot and Show’s elbow off the top, wasn’t good. But the crowd made it worse with chants that had nothing to do with the action, booing both guys and “boring” chants. And the finish made it worse than that, as Henry was disqualified for a low blow to save the title, which saw the crowd turn on the match. They gave the people a post-match angle where Show put Henry’s ankle into a chair and leg dropped down on it. Henry was tended to by officials and said his leg was broken. But he’s still booked on all the shows, so they aren’t going to play the injury up that big.
They wanted to see Punk win the title, and got it with the Anaconda vise submission. For Punk it must have been something, winning the title in Madison Square Garden. These days the title doesn’t always mean that much, but winning it in Madison Square Garden still has an aura. Plus he got to use a finisher that a few years back the promotion took away from him, and even only using it a few times of late and never as a winning move, it was over enough that the place exploded when he locked it on. Punk on TV noted that the title, which has changed hands eight times in the last seven months (the same number as from the inception of the WWWF name in 1963 until 1979) would no longer be a hot potato.
Right now Vince McMahon has made the commitment to Punk as champion. They are back in the mindset of trying to strengthen the belt by not changing it every month (a strategy that often changes four weeks later when there is a PPV and Raw rating to jump). Punk is planned to be champion past Royal Rumble. As for Del Rio, McMahon has lost confidence in him according to multiple sources, and with the experiment of bringing in stars from Mexico, with the idea it hasn’t worked out as he had envisioned.
Henry vs. Show, likely in a chairs match, will be one of the big matches on the 12/18 PPV, the TLC show from Baltimore. The two matches advertised are Punk vs. Del Rio for the WWE title and HHH vs. Kevin Nash. Since Show used a chair to the ankle for an injury spot on Henry, one would think that would be a chairs match. HHH vs. Nash was scheduled for this show as a tables match a few weeks back. That leaves Punk vs. Del Rio as either a ladder match or a TLC match. Another top match appears to be Randy Orton vs. Wade Barrett. The final angle of the show seemed to lead to John Cena vs. The Miz vs. R-Truth with R-Truth going face, but instead the angle, where Miz turned R-Truth face and laid him out with a skull crushing finale on the ramp, was to write R-Truth out due to a 30 day suspension for a drug test failure.
This one has a lot of people talking. When Evan Bourne was suspended for the drug Spice (a marijuana substitute that is on the company’s banned list), it was not a secret among the wrestlers that another bigger star was doing the same thing he was with him, who was said to be not suspended, but instead fined $2,500 for a marijuana violation. It was a big enough issue that there were these explanations going around about how maybe the usage of the marijuana covered up the Spice, and thus it didn’t show up, but why would that be the case with one wrestler but not with Bourne. The company does have a policy where if a guy fails a test, they’ll allow him to work the next television. If this test failure came up over the last week, his working the PPV and doing the angle to write him off with the injury would be common practice. But this is one filled with skepticism.
In the case of Ron Killings, we have it confirmed his suspension was for a marijuana substitute, presumably Spice, and that the test result came in several weeks ago. According to someone with complete knowledge of the situation, Killings was informed around the same time Bourne was suspended that he had failed the test for a marijuana substitute. Because he was not suspended, he presumed he was not being suspended, based on the idea that they had the European tour and he was in the main event at Survivor Series. He was never told anything different and had no idea he was being suspended until 11/22. We were told the writers were also not informed of anything, and that this had nothing to do with the lack of heat put on he and Miz to build the show. Michael Hayes had told Miz and Truth that for this main event there was no need to get heat, which nobody understood but felt to mean Rock was going to sell the show whether they did an angle or not, so why bother. Vince McMahon ordered the R-Truth babyface turn because he felt Raw only has two babyfaces that were over, Cena and Punk, and if one gets hurt the depth was bad. Plus, McMahon felt there was great potential in Little Jimmy merchandise.
In pro wrestling, nobody on the inside is ever going to have confidence that the drug policy is enforced equally to prelim guys and top stars. This would seem to indicate the idea that you fail the test and they write you out on the next TV is more that if you’re on top, they’ll allow you to work out your program for several weeks, but that eventually you are going to serve your 30 days. Although R-Truth is on top, he’s really not the level of guy that would alleviate the skepticism. There have been incidents that came out where Vince McMahon talked Dr. David Black (who is in charge of handing out the suspensions) into changing some things. There is always the issue of Randy Orton not being suspended with everyone else after the Signature Pharmacy names came out. Even Harry Smith, who was a prelim guy, when he got popped in developmental, he was not suspended for more than a month after he was informed he had failed the test. Then he was brought up to the main roster,. They waited until the day the policy changed where they would announce people testing positive, and then right away, he was announced as suspended when the policy changed. Perhaps there is an explanation, but that was years ago and none was ever given. From time to time there are stories among the talent of one of the guys at the top failing a test and somehow not being suspended. Again, given the confidential nature of the testing and nature of locker room gossip, all of these incidents can be wrong, or there may be foundation to them.
The fact football, baseball and the Olympics have all had a lot of questionable things regarding drug testing, tipping stars off (in baseball in particular this came out), covering up positives at times, you can’t trust that favoritism won’t come into play in any endeavor, sport or otherwise, from the high school level to professional, where a star system exists.
The other major story coming out of the show was Sin Cara rupturing his right patella (kneecap) tendon, requiring surgery and is expected to be out of action six to nine months. Early in the ten-man elimination match, Sin Cara and Kofi Kingston did a double flip dive spot with Cara on Hunico and Kingston on Jack Swagger. It was not the landing, but Cara’s knee went out either on the step before or the step of the take-off. Because the knee went out, he didn’t get the height in his jump and in going over the top for his dive, didn’t quite clear the top rope, and his leg hooked the rope, changing his trajectory. It was clear immediately he was hurt and the match stopped and there was about a minute of confusion . They ended up announcing he was unable to continue, as opposed to him crawling into the ring and doing an impromptu finish. He was then helped him to the back.
The timing of this was really bad because they had a ton of new Sin Cara merchandise about to be released and he was expected to be a major seller to kids for the Christmas season. So now both he and Rey Mysterio are gone at the same time. Plus, with a guy with his style, the first knee injury is usually the beginning of a series of problems. In addition, he and Mysterio were hoped to be a significant part of Mania because of the idea of doing the gimmick at the show of having everyone put on masks and breaking the Guinness World Record for the largest gathering of masked people in any one place in history, The Anaheim Angels baseball team had a Lucha Libre mask night last season and got a decent amount of pub breaking the record which sparked the idea in WWE circles. Sin Cara is unlikely to make it back for Mania and Mysterio, who has had two recent knee operations, is touch-and-go.
The show drew a sellout of 16,749, with about 13,000 paid and a gate in the $1 million range. We’ve got no early indication of the PPV numbers. The show legitimately sold out right away, but a lot of the tickets went immediately to the secondary market. Those sales at the end must have been soft because we had several reports of people being able to get good seats late for half or even less than the ticket value. The whole ticket dynamic for events that people perceive as being “hot” today with stubhub and Craig’s List is that tickets to hot events are like a stock market short-term investment, and this show, like WrestleMania, benefitted from that.
Mark “Bison” Smith, who had been one of the top foreign stars for Pro Wresting NOAH since his debut there in 2005 passed away on 11/22 in San Juan from a massive heart attack. Smith was 38.
Smith had wrestled on 11/20 in Sapporo, Japan, for NOAH on the final day of the Global League tournament, and then flew from Japan to Puerto Rico where he was scheduled to work the weekend shows, finishing with an 11/27 headline match with Primo Colon at the WWC Crossfire Show.
Details are sketchy as to what happened but it appeared he suffered a massive heart attack and was unable to speak, and was rushed to Hospital Regional in Carolina, PR where he passed away.
Smith, a 6-2, 280-pound thick powerhouse was an offensive lineman at the University of Colorado who started wrestling in 1998 at the All Pro Wrestling school in Hayward, CA. He started his career with APW and moved to Pro Wrestling Iron when his trainers, Michael Modest and Donovan Morgan left APW to start their own company.
His first career break was in 2003 in Puerto Rico, as Buffalo Bison, where he won the IWA world heavyweight title from Shane Sewell. Through Modest & Morgan, he got hooked up with Pro Wrestling NOAH and due to his size and because he did not sign on with a major U.S. group, he was pushed as one of the company’s top foreign stars from his debut in 2005. He held the GHC tag team title twice, with partners Akitoshi Saito and Keith Walker, and also with Saito won the 2008 tag team tournament. Smith & Saito were defending the titles on June 13, 2009, in Sapporo against Mitsuharu Misawa & Go Shiozaki in the match where Misawa died after breaking his neck taking a back suplex from Saito.