Edit: and I reiterate my question as to O Lucky Man! A three-hour musical satire starring Malcolm McDowell sounds fucking awesome, but it also sounds like it could be terrible.
It's been a while since I've seen O Lucky Man!, so I'm a bit fuzzy on the details. I do remember enjoying the hell out of it. Malcolm McDowell reprises his Mick Travis character, this time as a young man setting out to make his fortune in the world. This takes the form of our hero getting into and out of trouble, with periodic moments where things get pretty goddamned strange, set to occasional bursts of musical comentary. It's blackly humorous and more than a tad surreal; I was reminded of Bunuel at times, which is fine with me since I'm a huge fan of Bunuel. So, yeah, totally recommended, though you may want to watch If... (1968) first.
AlternativeUlster said:
As much as I love A-ko and think it shouldn't merit anything less than two stars if only for it's impressive level of wacky hijinx, I can see someone reacting badly to C-ko and marking it down accordingly.
I went to go see Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy last night, along with half of the NPR listening audience in Durham. I'm a great fan of both the novel and the original miniseries and was uncertain as to how they were going to cram the story into a two hour film adaptation. The answer is rather well, with a lot of judicious trimming to keep the key story in place, a bit of timeline juggling, and some new scenes to bridge some of the gaps. I think the flick could use an extra half hour or so to help clarify the plot and to focus more on Smiley's relationship with Ann, but otherwise, not too shabby. That said, based on the comments of some of the folks around me, they were moderately bewildered, so your mileage may vary.
Concerns about the plot and shoehorns aside, Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy is a damn fine spy thriller in the gloomy realism vein set during the heart of the Cold War, and one of the best things about the movie is how well it captures the era; the set design, costuming, and so forth is just incredible. Then there's the non-stop parade of top-notch acting talent they've got in the flick. Everyone does a terrific job, and if Gary Oldman's Smiley can't help but fall short of the Alec Guinness interpretation for me personally, it's not because he didn't deliver a damn fine performance.
The best thing about the movie is that, in a bit of character merging, Stephen Graham makes an appearance as Jerry Westerby, giving me hope that Tomas Alfredson will film the entire Karla trilogy and we'll finally get a screen adaptation of The Honourable Schoolboy.
It looks like this is already being discussed, so fingers are crossed.
Fnord Smiley