2012 NBA Mar |OT| Knicks fans now drinking JD in straight shots

Status
Not open for further replies.
it would also be silly to say he should play nash and hill 40mpg. They simply can't.

Where did I say anything remotely close to this? I just don't like his rotations. I think he can mix things up more. I would try and keep Hill in more with the 2nd Unit. Have him run the offense. I'd also play Dudley more minutes with the 2nd Unit and if you need to keep his number lower, put Brown in with the starters (don't actually start him).

I was only using +/- for the comparison with Telfair and Price because you obviously think Telfair is better and somehow you have watched them both play. I don't know how else to convince you then. Neither are starters but Price is a better player for us off the bench. Telfair should not be getting any minutes at all. Hopefully Brooks will come back for the rest of the season and this point will be moot.
 
Youre not "better" because you're not injured. If thats how we classify things, Oden is the worst player in NBA history.

Give Oden 5 years of development time with almost no injuries and then make your case. When he was healthy and lost a little weight, he was dominant.

Wait.....Sativa..it's gotta be.

Man you are lacking sense today.
 
CBS gives Chuck a proper script, and he sounds like Hubie Brown out here.

Just filter the man, TNT. His vocabulary is not great. Year after year of letting him run wild because of decent ratings in wrong :(
 
Those people were right.

My people said "knee injury and one leg is shorter than the other? Portland can't be that dumb right? Ohhhh Portland..."
One of the articles I read before the draft that year had a guy watching Oden just walk. The author noted that you can often tell how good a big man can be by just seeing how he moves in street clothes and Oden could barely put one foot in front of the other.

Such a bad move by Portland. I grew up one town over from the HS that Sam Bowie went to. It's amazing seeing the parallels. Bowie at least got 10 seasons out of his career though. Oden may not even get one complete one.
 
Wait.....Sativa..it's gotta be.

Man you are lacking sense today.

Oden is a bust because of the injuries, that's not debatable.

But he is good at basketball, its not fair to judge his skill when his body didnt allow him to compete. Even more unfair to compare him to a player that has developed through the years and then be like "har har I was right"
 
Youre not "better" because you're not injured. If thats how we classify things, Oden is the worst player in NBA history.

Give Oden 5 years of development time with almost no injuries and then make your case. When he was healthy and lost a little weight, he was dominant.

Oden is easily the biggest bust in NBA history. Doesn't matter how it happened. Sam Bowie was a good player too when he wasn't hurt, which is most of the time. Ammo blew out his knee and I don't see anyone saying he isn't a bust either.

One of the articles I read before the draft that year had a guy watching Oden just walk. The author noted that you can often tell how good a big man can be by just seeing how he moves in street clothes and Oden could barely put one foot in front of the other.

Such a bad move by Portland. I grew up one town over from the HS that Sam Bowie went to. It's amazing seeing the parallels. Bowie at least got 10 seasons out of his career though. Oden may not even get one complete one.
Bill Simmons:
And you know what? He walked like a 50-year-old man. His posture was screwed up. He had the Fred Sanford walk going. If you saw him from behind and just studied his walk, you would have thought it was a retired player, someone like Patrick Ewing or Robert Parish. I couldn't believe it. I didn't stop talking about it the rest of the night. Greg Oden walked like a guy who had bad knees. If I were Portland's GM and watched Oden walk across the room, that would have been it for me. The next day, I even called my buddy Sully (who works for the Celtics) just to have the obligatory, "Yo, we might have dodged a bullet May 22; Greg Oden walks like a 50-year-old man" conversation.

The Oden pick set the blazers back badly. Durant is a top 5 player on a contending team. Portland just blew it up and is rebuilding again. Oden is a huge bust.
 
Oden is a bust because of the injuries, that's not debatable.

But he is good at basketball, its not fair to judge his skill when his body didnt allow him to compete. Even more unfair to compare him to a player that has developed through the years and then be like "har har I was right"

You are judged on what you contribute. Period.
 
SSOL: Marion getting rebound, dish to Nash, find Joe or Qrich for back-breaking 3. Nash/Amare PnR PnP: Corner 3s.

Melo did not/does not want to be Marion.

Is what it is.

You mean Melo doesn't want to be a productive basketball player? Matrix numbers during that era were quite impressive..
 
You mean Melo doesn't want to be a productive basketball player? Matrix numbers during that era were quite impressive..

ESPN has always doomed MDA with their approach to his offense. Always have had to have the bullet point question of will this system win a championship. Why wont they play defense?

Never respected the change in the guard.

SF became the anchor, not the center. Lots of 3s, limited post presence. They've always played some D. They won .600 of their games. Just really cant stand producers at ESPN sometimes.

IMO, MDA will be coaching WAS next season.
 
And remember when minny fans wanted a lotto pick for flynn?

Revisionist history is not a hot look.

Cant exactly predict injuries, thats why Oden wasnt a bad pick. The people back then who were making those injury concerns were a minority, and not even a vocal one.

Flynn hate is valid because he had ONE good game
 
You ARE judged by what you contribute and So Oden is judged because of circumstances beyond his control.

No, he is a bust. It didnt pan out. Just because we feel for him doesnt make it any less true.

Based on draft position and team expectations, getting hurt every year was not the plan. I'd imagine.
 
Well, the odds are against him but i'm betting on it. I hope his contract is bought out by the rockets and he comes back to the lakers in some capacity as a staff member on the coaching team. That'd be cool.

I'm very late to this, but god damn.

The requirement in order to get your jersey retired by the Lakers, is to be in the Hall of Fame.

Fisher will not be in the Hall of Fame.

Thus you are wrong.

Just admit it ffs. If you honestly feel Fisher will make the Hall of Fame, you would have a point. But nobody, and I mean nobody should think he will make the Hall of Fame. No Hall of Fame = no retired jersey.

No Hall of Fame = no retired jersey.
 
ESPN has always doomed MDA with their approach to his offense. Always have had to have the bullet point question of will this system win a championship. Why wont they play defense?

Never respected the change in the guard.

SF became the anchor, not the center. Lots of 3s, limited post presence. They've always played some D. They won .600 of their games. Just really cant stand producers at ESPN sometimes.

IMO, MDA will be coaching WAS next season.

I've said this before, I'll say it again. MDA's offense is fun to watch but it's not something championship teams can be built on. With the floor spaced and the corners filled offensive rebounding and transition D suffers. Both crucial in tight playoff games. And if you're playing the type of small lineup needed for PnR and 3 shooters that MAD likes your defense and defensive rebounding suffers too. Doesn't matter how efficient your offense is, if you can't rebound or play D well because you're fielding a small lineup you're probably gonna lose at some point. Not to mention, MAD's offense doesn't give you many FT's either as it's perimeter oriented.

I know people will disagree, but that's been my opinion on that offense. SVG can kinda make it work with Dwight who single handily covers rebounding, defense, and getting the other team in foul trouble by himself. But MAD's system doesn't work well with post up players like Dwight
 
Is that why the heat have one of the top three effecient offenses in the league? Also lol at 10 coaches. Spo is playing to the teams strengths and getting the team to play superb defense. I don't see how its gets so much better than that all factors considered.

Portland was the most efficient offense for several years playing ISO-ball, and never won more than 2 games in the playoffs.

Oden was waived, Suns suck, Blazers fired everyone, Roy is out of the league. I think Reilo and I are done for a while.

Plus, you're too pussy-whipped these days to be trolling on forums.
 
Revisionist history is not a hot look.

Cant exactly predict injuries, thats why Oden wasnt a bad pick. The people back then who were making those injury concerns were a minority, and not even a vocal one.

Flynn hate is valid because he had ONE good game

I understand what you're saying, I just think its funny. Conley was my favorite player from that draft. I had him going 3rd.

I don't hate Oden, but I always liked Durant more than him. Because Conley's great play in college was always marginalized because of Oden. And I never liked that.
 
I don't think the guy that proclaimed Jerryd Bayless and Luke Babbitt as future all-stars has any right to pull any sort of revisionist history.
 
You guys are haters. D'Antoni was the only problem. Now that Melo is done sabotaging the Knicks to get his coach fired he can go back to playing hard and the wins will just start rolling in. Watch.
 
I agree, injuries or not, you gotta consider Oden a major bust.

Just like everyone else, I feel bad for him because he didn't get to live up to his potential... but it is what it is. It's over.

Doesn't help that he was picked ahead of a guy who's in the MVP race this season either.
 
I don't think the guy that proclaimed Jerryd Bayless and Luke Babbitt as future all-stars has any right to pull any sort of revisionist history.

Thats how Knicks fans deal with being Knicks fans, misdirection.

Its like they all watch "The Prestige" as group therapy
 
Oden couldn't even stay out of foul trouble in the NCAA tournament despite being known for his defense.

Sucks what happened to him, he didn't get a real chance in the NBA but I doubt he would have been anything special.
 
Oden couldn't even stay out of foul trouble in the NCAA tournament despite being known for his defense.

Sucks what happened to him, he didn't get a real chance in the NBA but I doubt he would have been anything special.

Erm what? Anyone that watched Oden play knew that he would be special if healthy.
 
Oden got dealt a shitty hand. He was surprisingly decent the times I watched him despite missing huge chunks of the season. If he could stay healthy and get it together he could have been around as developed as Bynum is now.

Roy-Batum-LMA-Oden would have rocked teams. Post scoring and defense in both bigs, mid range from everyone not Oden and decent long ball from Roy and Batum. One of the best starting lineups if not the best.
 
Oden got dealt a shitty hand. He was surprisingly decent the times I watched him despite missing huge chunks of the season. If he could stay healthy and get it together he could have been around as developed as Bynum is now.

Roy-Batum-LMA-Oden would have rocked teams. Post scoring and defense in both bigs, mid range from everyone not Oden and decent long ball from Roy and Batum. One of the best starting lineups if not the best.

Oden was already putting up Bynum numbers (16-11ish) before his kneecap split in half in less playing time. The other big difference? Oden was a much better defensive prospect.
 
Like Webber said, Melo is a ball stopper. Nobody who is running New York has a fucking clue. They are all idiots. Any top office guy who would bring in Melo with D'antoni as a coach knows nothing about basketball.

I don't think it's a coincidence that New York went on a 7 game winning streak without Melo, and started to lose when he got back.

Amare is an uptempo player
Carmelo is a ISO half court player
Lin is an uptempo PG
JR smith is an idiot who has no brain
Tyson Chandler is half court defensive beast
D'antoni is an uptempo no defense PG heavy coach.

Could you have built a more unbalanced team? It's honestly like the Knicks were treating this like a fantasy team, trying to get big names to appeal to the market. Not giving a shit how balanced anything was.

Now they have Woodson running things. Woodsons system is like a poor, starving Somalian child's version of what they do in LA. Except Carmelo isn't even a 35 year old Kobe, and Amare couldn't average 10 rebounds to stop world hunger.

+1000 damm
 
Oden was already putting up Bynum numbers (16-11ish) before his kneecap split in half in less playing time. The other big difference? Oden was a much better defensive prospect.

This. He was a monster. I could see why Portland held onto him for so long even though he saw no playing time.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom