Romney got under Obama's skin, made him defensive. The conversational attack-mode of Romney's detailing America's woes and Lehrer trying to rein in the clock disrupted Obama's rhythms and forced him to speak with a much quicker cadence - his words were right for the most part, but the emphasis and space to hammer his points wasn't there. Moments where Obama begins by collecting his thoughts come across as flinching recoils from an attack or accusation.
The problem I have when examining these two is that Romney has laid down principles, but no details - no hard choices - no plan that has been examined that has been found to match his principles. This is huge, and Obama tried to point out this lack of details a few times, but couldn't truly nail the point.
Obama was the bearer of hard choices - each one of those an avenue for attack by Romney, which is perfectly fine - and Obama has a record to show for those choices and how they could lead to success over the long term, but the fact that he didn't turn a huge economic crisis in 2008 into an engine of growth and prosperity for all right now puts that record against Romney's 'trust me, I won't let you down', and Romney's passionate vagueness will sway more people.
Another disappointment was that I wanted to see Obama clearly riposte Romney's attacks - because I felt he did a great job when he did - but he left some attacks on the table: Obamacare raising premiums by $2500 instead of lowering them - the rationale for investment in green technology companies when looking at their track record - cuts to the military - tax credits for moving plants overseas. I think Obama could have tackled these and come out on top, but they didn't match the direction he seemed to want to speak about, so they were left in the air to linger.
Romney got blood tonight, even though we got ZERO details, yet again. But his attacks and ready-to-fight and readiness for quick statements will be eaten up by the pundits and his base.
Its too bad too, because Romney expects us to forget what we've already seen from him, whether it be the hidden camera footage, or blatant trolling during the Libya attack, or the lack of plans that meet any arithmetic sense. None of those have changed - but if you're angry, he's got skills at being your standard bearer.