• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Video: Bronies (grown men) invade little girls' section of Toys R Us

Status
Not open for further replies.
To be fair, I think Dora the Explorer is for like 2-6 year olds and My Little Pony is meant for girls 6-12 or something.

I watched an episode of My Little Pony once just out of sheer curiosity (I kept seeing it mentioned here) and the writing certainly wasn't "Can you spot the apple?" stuff like you see on Dora. The writing wasn't bad and the characters were charming. Did you ever watch Dexter's Lab? You know that character Dee Dee, the sister who was a free spirit and caused all sorts of trouble for Dexter? Well, there's a pony like that in this show.

Anyway, I personally don't have a problem with anyone (even grown men) being a fan of something as harmless as My Little Pony just as long as they don't take it too far. The problem is that too many have... and some even go all Rule 34 on it.

I just now watched the first episode of MLP on Youtube out of curiosity/ I can definitely say that it's not aimed at 6 year olds, it seems to skew a little higher than that. Not saying I get why there's a rash of grown men who seem to be into it though...

Is there any info out there about exactly how widespread the Brony phenomenon is? Are there really a ton of dudes out there who are into this, or is it one of those 'vocal minority' things that make a lot of noise? I haven't read this whole thread- have any Bronies spoke up and explained why they love the show so much?
 
I just now watched the first episode of MLP on Youtube out of curiosity/ I can definitely say that it's not aimed at 6 year olds, it seems to skew a little higher than that. Not saying I get why there's a rash of grown men who seem to be into it though...

Is there any info out there about exactly how widespread the Brony phenomenon is? Are there really a ton of dudes out there who are into this, or is it one of those 'vocal minority' things that make a lot of noise? I haven't read this whole thread- have any Bronies spoke up and explained why they love the show so much?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WV9DZehYs4

I mean just cross out the autistic bit in the title and some of the reasons might explain why guys like MLP
 
It never ceases to amaze me the people's capacity to see a terrible force of evil in liking a show aimed at little girls. Mummei was onto something regarding the whole "sexism also harming men".

Anyway, since so many people seems to be curious about the fandom (if not outright hating them), this is one of the best analysis of the matter that I have ever seen. It is a very unique phenomenom, really.

enabling people to be perpetual children is one reason

Correlation! = causation!
 
To be fair, I think Dora the Explorer is for like 2-6 year olds and My Little Pony is meant for girls 6-12 or something.

I watched an episode of My Little Pony once just out of sheer curiosity (I kept seeing it mentioned here) and the writing certainly wasn't "Can you spot the apple?" stuff like you see on Dora. The writing wasn't bad and the characters were charming. Did you ever watch Dexter's Lab? You know that character Dee Dee, the sister who was a free spirit and caused all sorts of trouble for Dexter? Well, there's a pony like that in this show.

Anyway, I personally don't have a problem with anyone (even grown men) being a fan of something as harmless as My Little Pony just as long as they don't take it too far. The problem is that too many have... and some even go all Rule 34 on it.
Some fans can take it too far, but in what cases do that become considered a hit against the whole fanbase and not just the deviant group? Consider the adult Pokemon fanbase, for example. There continues to be a ton of drawn porn among the fanart that are produced, a big chunk of it being furry porn. Does it then become creepy for adult men and women to be fans of the franchise because of the actions of that subgroup?

(This is, of course, besides the fact that pretty much all anime/cartoon series has drawn porn in abundance anyway.)
 
If a little girl likes wrestling (and it does happen), is it disgusting and she deserves hate?

Or an adult female fan likes animation clearly targeted at the 8-14 male demographic. Disgusting, right?

I'm staying out of the debate in this thread, but I'd just like to comment that if little girls like wrestling, it isn't disgusting but it's not mainstream, therefor weird.

@Jintor, the funny thing with cartoons is that there are hardly cartoons targeted at a male demographic per se. However, cartoons that are targetted at girls are easily distinguishable by the use of colors, the characters and the stereotypes (rainbows and flowers and stuff).
 
He-Man, Transformers, Thundercats, GI Joe, Ninja Turtles... that's all pretty young male-demographic (old-school, anyway). In more modern times, it's difficult to say if superhero shows target a gendered demographic so much as they target a superhero-fan demographic, though.
 
There's liking, then there's being overly obsessed, and then there's rule 34.

The same exact thing can be attributed to Star Wars and Star Trek fanbases. And yet there seems to be a lot less hate there. I'm not going to defend every aspect of the fanbase, they can forget that this thing is meant for the kids first and foremost and they should at times probably stand aside for them, but its sad that it has lead to hatred of the entire fanbase.

I just now watched the first episode of MLP on Youtube out of curiosity/ I can definitely say that it's not aimed at 6 year olds, it seems to skew a little higher than that. Not saying I get why there's a rash of grown men who seem to be into it though...

For the people that don't understand the fad, then maybe the best way to explain it is as something that's not for you. The biggest reason this has gotten so popular is the cutesy artstyle and charming characters. Some people like cute things, other people love gorey things, some people like both. There's no reason either side should hate the other for being interested in different things.

The way they play with some established tropes can be interesting and some of the jokes are legitimately funny, but really no one would care if it was the same script with a bad artstyle. Its why some of the most popular characters amongst the fanbase are ones that only had like 2 lines in the show.

If that's not enough for you, and you still can't get past the whole fact that its written for kids, then think really hard about how intellectual most television shows are. How involved is the plot for most sitcoms? How mature are those reality style talent shows? I'd even ask how complex is an episode of most cop shows?
 
I wonder what the reaction would have been if the men were there for Barbies rather than ponies.

fIFOy.jpg


???
 
Ikael said:
Anyway, since so many people seems to be curious about the fandom (if not outright hating them), this is one of the best analysis of the matter that I have ever seen. It is a very unique phenomenom, really.

Is there a link to a copy of this that is actually readable? I'm genuinely interested in reading it but that 'infographic' is just horrible in nearly every way possible.

I don't get people who hate bronies, but I seriously struggle to understand the whole thing myself and I'd actually be ashamed if anyone I knew started getting into it.
 
I don't get people who hate bronies, but I seriously struggle to understand the whole thing myself and I'd actually be ashamed if anyone I knew started getting into it.

Ouch. That's almost worse. Why would you feel like that?
 
The people who get upset about people liking MLP are like the people who get upset at gay marriage.

WHAT THE FUCK are e you even talking about. God damn it billy You know I like you but taking it that far is fucking crazy man. You cant fucking compare that to fucking gay marriage I mean come the fuck on. SERIOUSLY.
 
Ikael said:
Anyway, since so many people seems to be curious about the fandom (if not outright hating them), this is one of the best analysis of the matter that I have ever seen. It is a very unique phenomenom, really..

From that very link

CLOPFICS
While it may seem that clopfics are simply perverted fantasies of equally perverted individuals, there is truly another side of the story.
Yes, there is the group of individuals who are genuinely turned on by stories of ponies making fillies.
However, one must realize that ultimately it is not the ponies loving each other that is sought after, it is the characters. In the exact same way that connections develop between an individual and the personalities of the show, their characterization leads one to naturally develop affinities and preferences towards individual characters.
We care about them, and it is not their physical form we are attracted to, it is their personalities. Thus, sexual fantasies involving the characters develop and are translated into clopfics.
While RULE 34 MLP images seem to disprove this analysis, the fact still remains that the source of the attraction is not the physical forms themselves, but rather the character they represent. Of course, it is vital to note that this very emotional attachment to the characters can have the reverse effect, as the clopfics and artwork can destroy the innocence which holds the emotional connection together.

So, other than the contradictory statements that doesn't prove anything other than the knowledge that something may be wrong, I have a question for any bronies willing to answer.

If what this individual says is true, and some bronies develop a deep emotional bond with MLP characters, what is making those characters so different from others in shows right on-air or from the past?

What's so ground-breaking and unique about this characters that, I suppose, where never represented before in TV or on any media?

Are the Ponies from MLP far, far, far away from TV tropes? Why MLP and, I don't know, a deep emotional bond with Glee characters?
And I'm not talking about Rule 34, but this attraction to their personalities and not their physical forms.
 
I've seen that infographic before and don't really like it either. Seems a little too self-important. Here's a article from Huffington Post, if you would prefer that.

Actually, looking at that infographic, there is one thing that stands out, that might help explain my perception of (a healthy segment) of the fandom as "different" from other fandoms:
sDsqJ.png


VoLG5.png


Maybe I'm either naieve or ignorant, but I can't really think of other pop-culture fandoms that describe their obsession in this kind of language. It sounds as if the show is more "important" to these Bronies in personal ways than I've encountered with other groups.
 
From that very link

So, other than the contradictory statements that doesn't prove anything other than the knowledge that something may be wrong, I have a question for any bronies willing to answer.

If what this individual says is true, and some bronies develop a deep emotional bond with MLP characters, what is making those characters so different from others in shows right on-air or from the past?

What's so ground-breaking and unique about this characters that, I suppose, where never represented before in TV or on any media?

Are the Ponies from MLP far, far, far away from TV tropes? Why MLP and, I don't know, a deep emotional bond with Glee characters?
And I'm not talking about Rule 34, but this attraction to their personalities and not their physical forms.

The ponies are based on fairly typical character tropes (farmer girl, bookworm, shy, fashionista, tomboy, silly party girl). However, they play these parts well, bringing some additional depth/motivation to the table. Their personalities interact well, leading to friendships onscreen that feel honest.

I've never seen Glee, so I can't speak for that specifically, but something about how the ponies interact combined with how their designs and body language compliment their personality really sells them.
 
WHAT THE FUCK. ARe you even talking about. GOD damn it billy You know I like you but taking it THAT far is fucking crazy man. You cant fucking compare that to fucking gay marriage I mean Come the fuck on . SERIOUSLY.

lol
 
Me? I personally have no opinion either way, people can do what they want.

I was asking for your opinion of the Bronies were Powerpuffers and acting the same way.

Well I don't think grown men should be running around getting kids toys unless it's something that could be a collectible. Even then though...
 
All gay pride events should be converted into combined gay-brony pride events, since they're pretty much the same thing and both groups face the same struggles
 
tumblr_mbre6xXGls1rzjjrdo1_400.gif


People who like My Little Pony are not being disowned by their parents or getting fired from their jobs for liking My Little Pony. That's a terrible connection.

some people have. some parents think their son is gay so they disown them. or some parents think their son is a pedophile and disown them.

ive heard it happen a few times.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom