• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Skullgirls DLC Character vote | The Campaign united us, The Voting will destroy us

Yeah, I really don't get where this mindset is coming from. Like, I know he's a wrestler, but there's a surprising amount of non-grappling moves he could and probably will have. I dunno, I just don't see it with him. Could just be me. *shrugs*

Too busy smacking fools with chairs.
Everything seems to indicate him being a grappler, so copies of characters seems boring. At least, if we're going to make sense of him being a wrestler.

Unless he's this kind of wrestler: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hyEveyeXRaU
 
Push Annie.

I know your feel so much. I got my absolute number 1 and I'm happy but now Feng, Black Dahlia and Annie (who I'm coasting on as my absolute second pick) are looking at me all puppy eyed.
big_boss__s_salute___mgs3_by_rainedrebellion-d57boh0.gif


This isn't really how voter psychology works, especially in the short term. If the second vote were three months away, you might be right, but two votes back to back will simply solidify the voting blocs, not separate them.
Nah; the current top 8 have the most chance of winning the next vote. The only thing that will help characters right now is a dedicated fanbase rather than the casual vote since only your top vote counts. They made hate-voting impossible.
I hope you guys are right!

...still hoping that Black Dahlia goes far, though. In spite of myself.
 
Considering that most people would agree that Eliza is all around a pretty awesome character I wonder how close she was to making the initial roster.

Not likely. Don't forget that the four original DLC characters were going to be Squiggly, Umbrella , Black Dahlia and Marie. Alex actually wanted to keep Eliza for the sequel.

YES ELIZA!!!
MAI WAIFU!!!

I lied to you Team Annie. I actually voted for Eliza in round 4.

My brah!
 
edit: Beaten, but yeah. Alex is trying to tell a story here, and as much as I'd like for him to tell it, the allure of Eliza now was too great
 
I hope you guys are right!

...still hoping that Black Dahlia goes far, though. In spite of myself.
It's hard to say who's going to fill the next top 8, simply because it seems like those who weren't voting Eliza were fairly close together.

The most interesting thing Peter has said about the vote so far is how close some of the votes have been when it comes to second, which at least means that the second vote has the potential to be interesting.
 
The most interesting thing Peter has said about the vote so far is how close some of the votes have been when it comes to second, which at least means that the second vote has the potential to be interesting.

The top 10 will be Annie, Minette, the four dudes, Umbrella, Marie and Aeon. Don't expect any surprises.
 
Holy crap, Eliza won!? Tonight is a good night.

The day when we get finished gameplay footage for her can't come soon enough.
 
Not likely. Don't forget that the four original DLC characters were going to be Squiggly, Umbrella , Black Dahlia and Marie. Alex actually wanted to keep Eliza for the sequel.
I wonder if they'll set up Eliza's story as a bridge between SG1 & SG2. Sort of like an epilogue, taking place after the main events of the first game.
 
The top 10 will be Annie, Minette, the four dudes, Umbrella, Marie and Aeon. Don't expect any surprises.
Maybe. If the votes were indeed 50 or less votes apart between 2nd and 3rd, there could be some definite swing-voting going on, especially in a voting system which isn't based on plurality (giving that voting is now weighted).

I still have a hard time understanding what Skullgirls 2 could even possibly be, other than simply the first Skullgirls with more DLC. Mike himself said that it takes an average of three months to balance a character, and even then it needs constant tweaking. If Skullgirls 2 is just more characters, then I can understand that, but I don't see how anyone here can be clamoring for Skullgirls 2 without some time to see how the PC release of this game actually does.

It's easy to release poorly balanced games, Marvel and Street Fighter X Tekken are perfect examples of this. Far more difficult to make a game that is competitive and balanced.
 
It's funny how the two female characters I want were the planned DLC anyway (Umbrella and Black Dahlia).
Oh and if Squiggly was in the voting I would've probably voted for her too.

well considering even ravi said it wasnt true i guess it was just people really hating on minette and annie :/ i dont really understand the hate they get since i see a lot of fanart for the 2
I don't mind any of the 3 but the competition would be more interesting knowing the final results won't be similar.

That and the salt.

Looks like I got a team of Ms.Fortune/Squiggly/Eliza now :D
Team Undead?
 
What, my picks didn't win? Outrageous! I'm calling my credit card company right now and demanding a chargeba-


Nah, I'm just kidding. I mean, what kind of jerk would do that?
 
I'm already trying to figure out how my votes will go down. I need some sugar after all this salt.

Just put Annie in number one and your second favorite in number 2. That's pretty much all you need to do for the first round; only your number one character will actually get a vote, anyway.
 
Just put Annie in number one and your second favorite in number 2. That's pretty much all you need to do for the first round; only your number one character will actually get a vote, anyway.
This isn't true at all, weighted averages tend to turn out much better rather than strict pluralities, at least in terms of voting. The United States would likely have much more interesting voting and higher voter turnout if this was the case.
 
This isn't true at all, weighted averages tend to turn out much better rather than strict pluralities, at least in terms of voting. The United States would likely have much more interesting voting and higher voter turnout if this was the case.

How isn't it true at all? If all the current Annie supporters put Annie in their number one spot then she their number 2 and further characters won't be very relevant; only your top spot is getting the "vote".
 
How isn't it true at all? If all the current Annie supporters put Annie in their number one spot then she their number 2 and further characters won't be very relevant; only your top spot is getting the "vote".
This... isn't how these kinds of votes work.

Basically
1st character - 3 votes
2nd character - 2 votes
3rd character - 1 vote

Effectively this is how these kinds of votes work. They put more weight on characters you would like to see based on your level of interest in them. So to say that the 2nd character is not voting is silly. It doesn't have as much weight, but it's still significant.
 
If this wasn't a 6 button Marvel-like game I'd threaten to kick all of your asses with a keyboard.

But it is.
I'd probably prefer a more Guilty Gear style, but eh. My two favorite fighters will probably always be Guilty Gear Accent Core and Third Strike.

edit: also, dan, if you're using a 360 USB stick, as long as you're on Windows you should be fine.
 
This... isn't how these kinds of votes work.

Basically
1st character - 3 votes
2nd character - 2 votes
3rd character - 1 vote

Effectively this is how these kinds of votes work. They put more weight on characters you would like to see based on your level of interest in them. So to say that the 2nd character is not voting is silly. It doesn't have as much weight, but it's still significant.

Wait, what? It's instant-runoff, right?

300px-IRV_counting_flowchart.svg.png


Only first choices are counted.
 
Top Bottom