Breaking Bad - Season 5, Part 2 - The Final Eight Episodes - Sundays on AMC

Status
Not open for further replies.
comments are awight as well

I truly cannot see what attracts people to this show . I think it must be like a sort of follow the leader type show ( just like sheep buy I-phones because everyone else bought them and it was in fashion ) . Of all the current and past shows ( and I watch a lot ) , this is the most boring one around
 
Just curious, did you start watching this show because you wanted to see Walt get it in the end? Did you cheer when he got Gus, when he did that meth crystal bomb thing-thing in the first season? When he killed those dealers?

Nope, didn't cheer any of that. But I appreciated that there was no major moral compassing surrounding the story lines. Just a bunch of interesting characters interacting and trying to survive.

But now, it seems different. Yes yes Walt is dark, Hank is light, Mr Chips to Scarface, he's a bad guy and a liar. But I guess that was the destination of the whole series, to show that transformation. I think I just prefer the journey more.
 
I'm beginning to think amirox is not on team walt.

I went back and did some catch-up reading, and he's been making this thread almost unreadable for pages and pages now.

Walt's done some bad things, that's for sure, but until Season 5, nothing that couldn't really be justified in context. And then he got out of the game and went back to living a family life. Sure, it's not all hunky-dory, but black is one of the component shades of gray, after all.
 
One thing I might have missed something on when I started rewatching was that early Gus scene where he shows up at the DEA office to promote that charity. When finds out that Walt's got a DEA agent in the family and has cancer, wouldn't that be the point that he stops doing business with him, since the whole intro to his character was about how cautious he was?
 
I went back and did some catch-up reading, and he's been making this thread almost unreadable for pages and pages now.

Walt's done some bad things, that's for sure, but until Season 5, nothing that couldn't really be justified in context. And then he got out of the game and went back to living a family life. Sure, it's not all hunky-dory, but black is one of the component shades of gray, after all.

Then justify the actions. I assert it is impossible to justify the actions, and thus there is no gray element of Walt any more and hasn't been for quite some time. Instead of complaining about posters, respond to points being made. You'll get further.
 
The show definitely felt more grey in early seasons. But after 4, and clearly now with 5, they're trying to paint Walt as a bad guy who'll get his just desserts in the end. Meh.
As the creator has described the show is basically "Mr chips turning into Scarface" not much room for shades of grey there - when it comes to walts characterization.
One thing I might have missed something on when I started rewatching was that early Gus scene where he shows up at the DEA office to promote that charity. When finds out that Walt's got a DEA agent in the family and has cancer, wouldn't that be the point that he stops doing business with him, since the whole intro to his character was about how cautious he was?
Gus was trying to kill Walt since S3. He knew he was a loose cannon.;p
 
This has been sticking with me.

tumblr_mrei22AfVE1qe4wtgo1_1280-550x203.jpg


The condition of the house and the ensuing shots of Walter in the mirror showcase what that Ozymandias poem was referring to.

This scene bothered since I have a hard time believing a suburban neighborhood would let a house fall into decay and reduce the property value of their homes.
 
no offense to you for posting it, but does anyone else DESPISE how overused this comparison has become?

Well, it doesn't help Gilligan says it in almost every freaking interview he does.

I can't help but wonder how much of the show's target audience even knows who Mr. Chips is .
 
Brilliant episode, much better than the opener of the first half of the season.

The Daily Mail have posted an article entitled: 'Is this the best TV show of all time? Breaking Bad is back and Jim Shelley picks 12 pivotal moments that make it a modern classic'

They go on to include in the article:




i dont even think this guy has watched it

Lmfao, oh man.
 
As the creator has described the show is basically "Mr chips turning into Scarface" not much room for shades of grey there - when it comes to walts characterization.

Yeah, in season 4 you could make a few arguments in Walt's favor but I don't think the writers are even bothering to add moral ambiguity to Walt's actions now. I honestly don't understand how anyone could still stand up for Walt now- maybe his powers of manipulation have affected the viewers as well.
 
This scene bothered since I have a hard time believing a suburban neighborhood would let a house fall into decay and reduce the property value of their homes.

That scene probably takes place between the time the house was being kept intact for police investigation and before it's due to be either renovated or demolished.

Neogaf ad.

6st7.jpg
 
Yeah, in season 4 you could make a few arguments in Walt's favor but I don't think the writers are even bothering to add moral ambiguity to Walt's actions now. I honestly don't understand how anyone could still stand up for Walt now- maybe his powers of manipulation have affected the viewers as well.

He's out of the game. He left willingly to escape from all the violence that surrounded him. That's a pretty big source of ambiguity, IMO.
 
no offense to you for posting it, but does anyone else DESPISE how overused this comparison has become?

Yeah it's their go to phrase for describing the show. I think Cranston uses it in every interview he's done.

As the creator has described the show is basically "Mr chips turning into Scarface" not much room for shades of grey there - when it comes to walts characterization.

I know it's expected, after they explained it over and over to us in PR and behind the scenes clips. It's just that now there's a clear agenda from the writers to pit light against dark. Which is fine, if that's the story they wanted to tell in the end.

That's why I like a show like Mad Men. It's basically just a window into the lives of people who may or may not be assholes or saints at any point in time but it never goes out of its way to tell the audience to take a moral stance. I hope BB doesn't ham fist it too much.
 
He's out of the game. He left willingly to escape from all the violence that surrounded him. That's a pretty big source of ambiguity, IMO.
If there was any ambiguity.. I'd think he'd have turned himself in by now as soon as he realized hank was on to him, or at least showed signs of remorse and guilt for his actions. But nope, judging from the opening of both ep9 and 1.. he's going fight hard to escape the consequences of his actions.:p
 
He's out of the game. He left willingly to escape from all the violence that surrounded him. That's a pretty big source of ambiguity, IMO.

Is there any shred of evidence he left the business because he was affected by the violence? Far more likely is that he left the business due his cancer returning. Also, it's not like Walt turned into a saint after he stopped cooking. He's still lying to Jesse and snubbing Lydia (which will probably condemn her to death).
 
If there was any ambiguity.. I'd think he'd have turned himself in by now as soon as he realized hank was on to him, or at least showed signs of remorse and guilt for his actions. But nope, judging from the opening of both ep9 and 1.. he's going fight hard to escape the consequences of his actions.:p

Morally gray doesn't mean morally light. There's nothing inconsistent about a morally gray character not wanting to face imprisonment, the seizure of his assets, the humiliation of his family, etc.

Also, let's be real. Every character Walt killed either personally or indirectly was crooked as hell, and aside from Gale, they were all career killers themselves.

Is there any shred of evidence he left the business because he was affected by the violence? Far more likely is that he left the business due his cancer returning. Also, it's not like Walt turned into a saint after he stopped cooking. He's still lying to Jesse and snubbing Lydia (which will probably condemn her to death).

Lying to Jesse is kind of like those parents who tell their kids that the family dog went to go live on a farm somewhere. Snubbing Lydia... by refusing to go cook again? How is that something to use against him?
 
The full context of situations of on the show. People have a tendency with Breaking Bad to rattle off events and judge them in a vacuum. You did this with the crash.

Walt put another's person's life in danger without their consent. Yes, by all accounts this is an immoral act. No shit. Saying this is as revelatory and poignant as saying the sky is blue; it literally accomplishes nothing. Why ignore Walt continually begging for Hank's life? Why ignore his repeated attempts at throwing Hank off the trail by non violently? Why ignore the ramifications of reaching the laundry which were markedly more severe than a low speed car crash? Etc.. etc..

You'll no doubt read this and argue against some "you're propping Walt up as a shining beacon of morality" straw man, but that couldn't be further from the case--in fact I've seen NO ONE make this argument.

Walter White has done horrible & immoral things for horrible & immoral reasons. He's done horrible & immoral things for noble reasons. And he's done horrible & immoral things because his only options were horrible & immoral. To argue merely for the former is disingenuous, and blatantly ignores much of the show.

Great post. Saved me a lot of trouble. Amir0x will gloss over this and get right back to trolling, but this is fantastic.


As someone in the foreclosure business this happens all the time.

How do you sleep at night when you work in a business that destroys so many lives?
 
This thread is fucking insane; so were Facebook/Twitter last night. It only took the average bonehead (i.e., my friends) 4-5 years to catch on to this shit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom