• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

‘Dark Tower’: Clashing Visions, Brutal Test Screenings Plagued Journey to Big Screen

Grizzlyjin

Supersonic, idiotic, disconnecting, not respecting, who would really ever wanna go and top that
It's for the same people studios always say it's for when something flops

"it's for the fans"

Even though that's basically never true because they're the ones that would be most critical of it. I get what you're saying though, I've wondered that as well. The whole thing is just sort of an odd decision on every level.

I have no idea what they were thinking saying this is a sequel to the books. I understand that makes sense if you've read the novels, but why say that? If it was just straight adapting, book fans are going to go. And hopefully new people too. But if you say it's a sequel you've scared away all the new people, who you need. And for what? To attract people who were going to go anyway?

It never made sense. Just sounded like damage control to justify all the messy changes they probably made.
 

FunkyMonk

Member
Ugh, absolutely gutted. I've been hoping the trailers were just being misleading as I love the books, they tail off towards the end but I still enjoy them, however in my heart I knew they wouldn't make a good film out of the books. Sony getting it should have been warning enough.

Sigh.

I hope this doesn't torpedo the tv series based on Wizard and Glass but it probably will. At least I still have the fantastic audio books.

I'll still probably go and see it though, on my own as my missus has no interest and neither do my mates. That's not too sad right? Right?!
 

Busty

Banned
Pls share

I posted it in the most recent box office thread the other day.

When test screening after test screening was coming back with awful scores it was decided that what the film needed was a positive ending.

They shot one and stuck it in the film, tested it and it came back with even worse scores. At this point an exasperated Sony just said 'Fuck it!' and just decided to put it out as is.

We shall see how this pans out.
 

BlueTsunami

there is joy in sucking dick
I posted it in the most recent box office thread the other day.

When test screening after test screening was coming back with awful scores it was decided that what the film needed was a positive ending.

They shot one and stuck it in the film, tested it and it came back with even worse scores. At this point an exasperated Sony just said 'Fuck it!' and just decided to put it out as is.

We shall see how this pans out.

Hahahaahahaha
 

Fury451

Banned
I posted it in the most recent box office thread the other day.

When test screening after test screening was coming back with awful scores it was decided that what the film needed was a positive ending.

They shot one and stuck it in the film, tested it and it came back with even worse scores. At this point an exasperated Sony just said 'Fuck it!' and just decided to put it out as is.

We shall see how this pans out.

When you said Scooby Doo I was anticipating them running back-and-forth in a chase through different portals until Roland pulls the mask off of mean old farmer Flagg
 
I came off a bit strong, sorry all. Not feeling well this day.

I have a special emotional connection with this work because a few years ago I suffered a bad concussion and was mostly bed bound for a week, with only books on tape to pass the time. (Couldn't stand light, read, any video or screen....) The dark tower series took me in again and it's been special to me since then.

That's a legit reason to like them and a touching story so I hope you don't take my earlier joke seriously, I have a friend who suffered through a brain tumor and had similar books/movies/comics/etc anchor him through his recovery.

It could be that reading all the books at once has given you a different outlook on the story as a whole, but I've found that people who read them as they were written, or even just at any point before he shit out the last three, find his ending to be extremely insulting. I mean he literally shit them out. He wrote the first 4 books over the course of many years and then got distracted with other stuff and people kept asking him about it and he kept saying "I'm working on it I'm working on it" and then one day he got into a car wreck and went "Oh fuck I could die at any moment I better finish that magnum opus of mine before I die" and rushed them out the door just to end it before his death. And here he is decades later still kicking around so he totally could have taken his time with it but hindsight is 20/20. But when you've been reading his books for decades, and stories upon stories are filled with connections to this series, and you're waiting and waiting for the end only to get something that even he admits was rushed out due to fear, that fucking sucks.

When you said Scooby Doo I was anticipating them running back-and-forth in a chase through different portals until Roland pulls the mask off of mean old farmer Flagg

A chase sequence through different worlds would literally be a dream come true, and what was promised for decades, over what we actually got at the end of the series.
 

- J - D -

Member
I know this is hardly a blockbuster, but this is the last "blockbuster" of the summer, right? What a sad way for summer movie season to go out.
 

kruis

Exposing the sinister cartel of retailers who allow companies to pay for advertising space.
At the end of the Variety article it says it's tracking in the mid-20's. I think you're right, but the short running time means more screenings, so you never know!

Once word gets out about the tacked on ending and the bad reviews start coming in, that figure is about to go down. This is the internet age, you can't hide turkeys anymore.
 

Jkmetal

Banned
Well it sounds like the film adaptation is gonna take an oy sized dump right on your chest.

Actually I think I'm just going to be pleased to see it on film. I don't really have any expectations and I'm not burning a friday or saturday night on this. If this was the first of four movies to translate the books into film, lord of the rings style, then yeah I'd be more invested.

Comics have been decent at least.
 
The sad thing is, this movie bombing (it will) is going to tarnish the Dark Tower saga for a long time. They should just rename it, sell the rights to Disney/WB/Marvel and have them make movies about the actual books :mad:

Im just mad...
 
It'll be like it never happened.

OYXehnC.gif
 

Stinkles

Clothed, sober, cooperative
What a wasted chance. And keeps everyone else away for twenty years.

Hope Dune has a smoother glide.
 

Dalek

Member
I heard a story about one of the test screenings where the cards distributed to the audience included a note asking them not to suggest recasting one of the leads because it was too late for that action to be taken.

I've also heard this is going to be an amazing piece of shit.

:(

I can't tell you how depressing this is for me. The Dark Tower is my favorite property of all time-I've read it my entire life and it means so much to me. To see it get this fate is just gutwrenching.
 

kevin1025

Banned
Once word gets out about the tacked on ending and the bad reviews start coming in, that figure is about to go down. This is the internet age, you can't hide turkeys anymore.

Very true. I went from a maybe to a no a while back, I can't imagine the many people it will lose when the first screenings start Thursday night.
 

FunkyMonk

Member
The sad thing is, this movie bombing (it will) is going to tarnish the Dark Tower saga for a long time. They should just rename it, sell the rights to Disney/WB/Marvel and have them make movies about the actual books :mad:

Im just mad...

Heck marvel did a decentish job with the comics, the gunslinger born is pretty good though I think they tailed off towards the end too, then again I stopped reading them halfway through The Drawing of the Three.
 
What a wasted chance. And keeps everyone else away for twenty years.

Hope Dune has a smoother glide.


I'll believe a successful adaptation of Dune when I see it. The only thing that gives me a semblance of hope is Villenueve's story telling sensibilities might gel with the source material.
 
Every fucking studio wants a "Cinematic universe" but nobody wants to do the actual work that Marvel did to create one. They want it now, not five movies later, NOW NOW NOW

But this movie was constructed in a way that could never lead to a CU, right?

The very nature of the movie concept is closing a loop on a story from books most possible audience members never read.

That might appeal to book readers but not with re-telling the whole thing in 90 minutes.

This movie reeks of misreading the dedication of a vocal minority.
 
Very nice GAF.

I'm enjoying the posts written by those boasting of how much they hated the books and when they jumped off, Great. You are all now a higher class of human like all full GAF members and only profess to appreciate universally acclaimed media.

I lurk a lot and don't post often due to how fucking negative this place is.

Good thing you decided to finally jump in and share some positivity.
 

Stinkles

Clothed, sober, cooperative
I'll believe a successful adaptation of Dune when I see it. The only thing that gives me a semblance of hope is Villenueve's story telling sensibilities might gel with the source material.

I think the book's reputation for being complex is exaggerated. The story itself is pretty doable. The sets and locations were bigger challenges and Lynch did a pretty good job artistically.

I have some faith.
 

Anoregon

The flight plan I just filed with the agency list me, my men, Dr. Pavel here. But only one of you!
Hollywood keeps trying to capture that Peter Jackson LOTR magic but all anyone has in them is Peter Jackson The Hobbit magic.

Real shame, I figured this wouldn't be very good but it would have been rad if it was.
 
Top Bottom