Support NeoGAF

[Sajko]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 83
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 78
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 92
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 88
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee- 76
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 71
Game 7. Cuphead - 82
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 76
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 90
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 85
Game 11. Prey - 81
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 83

 

[Infest]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 82
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 84
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 89
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 86
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 83
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 72
Game 7. Cuphead - 72
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 75
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 91
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 86
Game 11. Prey - 74
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 85

 

[DagnastyEp]

Interesting choice of games. I'll throw my hat in for this year.

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 83
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 88
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 92
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 89
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 79
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 80
Game 7. Cuphead - 88
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 78
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 93
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 90
Game 11. Prey - 86
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 87

 

[black070]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 81
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 85
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 89
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 86
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 79
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 80
Game 7. Cuphead - 86
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 79
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 91
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 89
Game 11. Prey - 82
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 85

 

[Courage]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 77
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 82
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 93
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 86
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 83
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 78
Game 7. Cuphead - 85
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 73
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 87
Game 11. Prey - 84
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 83

 

[Amory]

Halo Wars 2 - 68
Horizon: Zero Dawn - 85
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 93
Mass Effect: Andromeda - 90
Yooka-Laylee - 84
Sonic Mania - 80
Cuphead - 88
Crackdown 3 - 72
Super Mario Odyssey - 91
Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 82
Prey - 70
Assassin's Creed - 71

 

[Dragonslayer_023]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 78
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn 84
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild 86
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda 82
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee 74
Game 6. Sonic Mania 72
Game 7. Cuphead 72
Game 8. Crackdown 3 78
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey 88
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy 86
Game 11. Prey 84
Game 12. Assassin's Creed 80

 

[fargofallout]

I was going to scold you for not having Read Dead 2, but I think everyone would have guessed it will be delayed. That's what I would guess.

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 81
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 84
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 91
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 87
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 83
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 72
Game 7. Cuphead - 77
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 79
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 89
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 90
Game 11. Prey - Delayed
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 80

 

[DrD]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 83
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 88
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 93
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 89
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 84
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 78
Game 7. Cuphead - 85
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 81
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 93
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 88
Game 11. Prey - 87
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 86

 

[Plum]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 79
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 84
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 90
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 75
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 70
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 82
Game 7. Cuphead - 72
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 70
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 84
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 81
Game 11. Prey - 83
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 81

Lets see how I do!

 

[Dalibor68]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 82
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 84
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 91
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 82
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 80
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 63
Game 7. Cuphead - 71
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 71
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 85
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 88
Game 11. Prey - 86
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 85

 

[Disagree Guy]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 78
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 85
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 89
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 80
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 78
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 89
Game 7. Cuphead - 74
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 75
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 88
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 83
Game 11. Prey - 74
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 82

I wanted to put Sonic Mania at 99 but I'll do realistic scores

 

[ohdearohdear]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 80
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 84
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 92
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 90
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 77
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 80
Game 7. Cuphead - 82
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - Delayed
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 93
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 85
Game 11. Prey - 87
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 78

 

[His Majesty]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 77
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 82
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 85
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 86
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 65
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 68
Game 7. Cuphead - 77
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 59
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 81
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 80
Game 11. Prey - 90
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 82

 

[Xumbrega]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 86
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 87
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 94
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 91
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 70
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 82
Game 7. Cuphead - 88
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 81
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 90
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 88
Game 11. Prey - 77
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 91


I think AC will be a nice surprise this year after the hiatus

 

[Roboculus]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 82
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 88
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 93
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 84
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 83
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 84
Game 7. Cuphead - 85
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 85
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 85
Game 11. Prey - 87
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 83

 

[Tagg9]

Great concept.

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 90
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 88
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 94
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 78
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 86
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 68
Game 7. Cuphead - 79
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 72
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 89
Game 11. Prey - 77
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 72

 

[Daedardus]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 84
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 91
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 95
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 84
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 79
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 67
Game 7. Cuphead - 76
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 63
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 89
Game 11. Prey - 86
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 72

 

[T.O.P]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 85
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 79
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 91
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 88
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 84
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 72
Game 7. Cuphead - 89
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 82
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 85
Game 11. Prey - 82
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 83

 

[CouchMaster]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 84
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 88
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 95
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 81
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 80
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 83
Game 7. Cuphead - 83
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 77
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 89
Game 11. Prey - 82
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 88

 

[blakep267]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 83
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 78
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 95
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 86
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 80
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 75
Game 7. Cuphead - 79
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 80
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 95
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 86
Game 11. Prey - 87
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 82

 

[DKHF]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 80
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 86
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 91
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 83
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 80
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 79
Game 7. Cuphead - 79
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 78
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 90
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 86
Game 11. Prey - 82
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 83

 

[swarley64]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 -- 82
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn -- 93
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild -- 96
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda -- 75
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee -- 85
Game 6. Sonic Mania -- 89
Game 7. Cuphead -- 83
Game 8. Crackdown 3 -- 73
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey -- 94
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy -- 90
Game 11. Prey -- 83
Game 12. Assassin's Creed -- 81

 

[hatchx]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 80
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 87
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 92
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 80
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 71
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 84
Game 7. Cuphead - 83
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 78
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 86
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 85
Game 11. Prey - 70
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 82


It's really hard to guess too high with the way reviewers are these days.

 

[ASilentProtagonist]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 81
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 84
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 92
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 78
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee- 73
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 74
Game 7. Cuphead - 81
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 76
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 90
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 85
Game 11. Prey - 81
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 83

 

[IcyRhythms]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 84
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 71
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 93
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 90
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 84
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 76
Game 7. Cuphead - 88
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 80
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 97
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 91
Game 11. Prey - 86
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 90

 

[5taquitos]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 82
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 93
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 94
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 89
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 85
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 83
Game 7. Cuphead - 89
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 87
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 94
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 93
Game 11. Prey - 82
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 91

 

[GunBR]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 80
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 84
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild -94
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 89
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 87
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 80
Game 7. Cuphead - 72
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - Delayed
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 90
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 90
Game 11. Prey - 85
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 82

 

[tayls129]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 77
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 86
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 93
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 78
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 85
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 82
Game 7. Cuphead - 74
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 71
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 91
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 86
Game 11. Prey - 84
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 77

 

[CrazyHorse]

Do you guys seriously think that BoTW will get less than 95? It will be up up there with GTAs, Mario Galaxy and OoT. We are talking more like 97/98.

 

[Sanctuary]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 79
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 83
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 92
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 88
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 90
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 72
Game 7. Cuphead - 80
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 78
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 96
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 87
Game 11. Prey - 84
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 81

 

[Xumbrega]

Do you guys seriously think that BoTW will get less than 95? It will be up up there with GTAs, Mario Galaxy and OoT. We are talking more like 97/98.

there will be a single 60~70 clickbait score that will lower the score a bit as always

94-95 it's a safe bet

 

[Malakiax]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 77
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 82
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 91
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 88
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 69
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 77
Game 7. Cuphead - 66
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - Delayed
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 90
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 83
Game 11. Prey - 80
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 82

 

[Duo014]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 75
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 84
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild -90
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 84
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 84
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 72
Game 7. Cuphead - 77
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 77
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 80
Game 11. Prey - 84
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 83

 

[FelipeMGM]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 84
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 85
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 90
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 86
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 85
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 80
Game 7. Cuphead - 76
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 75
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - Delayed
Game 11. Prey - 84
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 80

 

[CrazyHorse]

there will be a single 60~70 clickbait score that will lower the score a bit as always

94-95 it's a safe bet

I see. Well a few of those could do it. Maybe Metacritic should use the median score instead of an average?

 

[soheil]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 82
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 86
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 92
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 87
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 83
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 81
Game 7. Cuphead - 85
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 75
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 91
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 88
Game 11. Prey - 80
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 84

 

[hatchx]

Do you guys seriously think that BoTW will get less than 95? It will be up up there with GTAs, Mario Galaxy and OoT. We are talking more like 97/98.

I think this too, based on what I've seen, but there's a strong hate for Nintendo out there. Click bait sites like Polygon will drag it down with 7's.

 

[Josh5890]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 75
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn 83
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild 97 Go big or go home
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda 84
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee 79
Game 6. Sonic Mania 80
Game 7. Cuphead 81
Game 8. Crackdown 3 74
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy Delayed
Game 11. Prey 80
Game 12. Assassin's Creed 77

 

[Acquiescence]

My No Man's Sky prediction fucked me over last year. Thought that would be a critical darling for sure.

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 80
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 87
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 93
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 89
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 82
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 77
Game 7. Cuphead - 78
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 75
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 86
Game 11. Prey - 82
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 87

 

[CaptainSmirnov]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 80
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 86
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 93
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 86
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 80
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 75
Game 7. Cuphead - 78
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 79
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 91
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 88
Game 11. Prey - 81
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 84

 

[bombshell]

Halo Wars 2 - 74
Horizon: Zero Dawn - 89
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 93
Mass Effect: Andromeda - 87
Yooka-Laylee - 85
Sonic Mania - 72
Cuphead - 81
Crackdown 3 - 67
Super Mario Odyssey - 88
Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 92
Prey - 86
Assassin's Creed - 84

Delayed is worth 5 points if it is delayed until 2018. If it is delayed to a later point in 2017, delayed is worth 0 points.

You have the wrong years in the OP text for the delayed rule:

"A guess of delayed will only score if the game is delayed until 2019. Any score guesses for games delayed until 2018 will score 0 points."

 

[daveo42]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 79
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 86
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 94
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 86
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 89
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 75
Game 7. Cuphead - 80
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 83
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 95
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 93
Game 11. Prey - 86
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 85

 

[Platypus]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 82
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 85
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 94
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 88
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 80
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 80
Game 7. Cuphead - 80
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 75
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 93
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 85
Game 11. Prey - 77
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 80

 

[Cornbread78]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2- 81
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn- 90
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild- 94
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda- 84
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee- 78
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 71
Game 7. Cuphead- 72
Game 8. Crackdown 3- 80
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey- 90
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy- 89
Game 11. Prey- 76
Game 12. Assassin's Creed- 82

 

[Nickle]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 : 84
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn : 88
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild : 95
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda : 90
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee : 82
Game 6. Sonic Mania : 86
Game 7. Cuphead : 78
Game 8. Crackdown 3 : 83
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey : 92
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy : 91
Game 11. Prey : 88
Game 12. Assassin's Creed : 88

The only one I'm relatively confident in is Zelda, even Skyward Sword got a 93.

 

[TheMagicMax]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 83
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 86
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 95
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 84
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 87
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 84
Game 7. Cuphead - 80
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 75
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 93
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 89
Game 11. Prey - 86
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 84

 

[#sorrynotsorry]

Updated the rules slightly regarding how answers should be submitted. It's ok if you already posted and it doesn't match. I'll only apply those new standards moving forward (and will try to get those people who mess up anyway). Glad to see the response so far! Almost exceeded last year's already.

You have the wrong years in the OP text for the delayed rule:

"A guess of delayed will only score if the game is delayed until 2019. Any score guesses for games delayed until 2018 will score 0 points."

Thanks! Updated.

 

[Greatest Ever]

Everyone should give Assassin's Creed an 83.

Do you guys seriously think that BoTW will get less than 95? It will be up up there with GTAs, Mario Galaxy and OoT. We are talking more like 97/98.

It's a 3D Zelda game, reviewers have gotten harsher. Absolutely nothing about the game looks like it'll get a 95 so far. If anything, Zelda being a critical darling based on brand alone is why I think it'll get above a 90.

Because if Skyward Sword can get a 93, anything can.

 

[Eylos]

Game 1. Halo Wars 2 - 76
Game 2. Horizon: Zero Dawn - 86
Game 3. The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild - 95
Game 4. Mass Effect: Andromeda - 87
Game 5. Yooka-Laylee - 82
Game 6. Sonic Mania - 72
Game 7. Cuphead - 77
Game 8. Crackdown 3 - 73
Game 9. Super Mario Odyssey - 93
Game 10. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy - 89
Game 11. Prey - 80
Game 12. Assassin's Creed - 80