Let's... let's not. Elden Ring had some things going for it, yeah. And... its idea for its open world was not one of those things.
Actually, I can't think of a less appealing open world. It's literally the worst of any serious game I've ever played. And Soulslike combat itself is
not good
, either. I'd rather do Skyrim's wiffle-bat combat any day of the week, because at least I occasionally pull out a bow or a spell and get to aim with some measure of skill.
My ideal ES game has Dark Messiah's combat. Wrapped up in some RPG mechanics, of course.