This is not comprehensive as I only reviewed all posts on those I didn't have reads on, and I'll mark them out for reference. What I would like to do next is check Bowlie's posts to see if it seems more likely he killed N1 or 2. I suspect we're at 1.5 kills per night now and am curious whether Shelly blackmails the night of the kill or the day before.
1. Barrylocke [m] - Died N1
2. Bowlie [m] - Died N2
3. CornBurrito [m] - has a history of driveby votes and lazy overreaction in the game. If items weren't confirmed I would think him scum but it's still pretty convenient it didn't go through last night. Reluctant town read, possible neutral. Second most dangerous role revealed. Town, but scummy.
4. Crimsonfist [m] - like CB, has demonstrated multiple instances of lazy overreactions. He started the Kalor bandwagon and has gone after several inactives, which is fine, but also their replacements. Easy targets with some lazy logic is an easy way to keep an active vote. Especially if you leave it there after prods are answered. I'm curious to look into what inactives he's left alone, if any. Scum.
5. EzekelRAGE [m] - I get town reads from Zeke though I believe he has the most dangerous revealed role to town. As has been pointed out, he can dick us over just as easily as he can save the day. I think town needs to get a leash on this power somehow. Town, maybe neutral.
6. Hipster Cthulhu [m] flatearthpandas [m] - confirmed town. As far as hipster, he never did anything scummy in my eyes. He was a new player and demonstrated that, but he didn't do anything scummy. Votes right now are a lazy excuse to avoid scum hunting imo. Again, town.
7. Kalor [m] - Died D1
8. Matt Attack [m] - posts infrequently but is not inactive. Responds when summoned which shows intentional lurking without hiding it. I see nothing suspicious in the content of his posts and he did deliver the dissertation on TWE. Null, leaning town.
9. QuantumBro [m] Drago [m] SalvaPot [m] - Talk about overreaction. I found nothing too concerning about QB's intro. His "I lost one game doing this" post was probably the most suspicious to me. Honestly, I think suspicion on Salva based on QB is lazy and hard-headed. Kalor, confirmed town, claimed familiarity with the community QB hailed from and also saw nothing suspicious about it. That isn't to say he wasn't scum, but I want the discussion more on Drago and Salva because harping on QB seems extremely lazy. Null.
*10. Redfalco [m] - Maybe the most inactive person in the game with something like 8 posts to date. That said, his frequency is increasing of late and I find his reasoning to be sound and thoughtful. Town.
11. Ri'Orius [m] - Died N2
12. RobotNinjaHornets [m] - Died N1
13. roytheone [m] - my GOAT brethren. Very active with meaty posts but perhaps my previous experience with him leaves me wary. Null read. I think there's more that can be revealed about the blackmail.
14. ScraftyDevil [f] - confirmed town. Would like to see her more active. I get that people are horrified at the idea of people hiding in her shadow but she is the only one we can all 100% believe is at least trying to act in favor of town and I think we could use some more directed activity from her. Town obvs.
15. squidyj [m] - rubbed the wrong way by him abandoning a prod vote on me and clearly avoiding conversation in favor of some sort of nameless pressure. Seeing as I know I'm town and scum can be reasonably sure I'm town, any shift actions towards me have to be read as scummy. Apart from that, I've been reading him town.
*16. StanleyPalmtree [m] - nothing really stuck out to me. He's fairly inactive but hasn't done anything scummy imo. Caught some of CB's oversensitive useless belaboring early game. Null.
17. StarSketch [f] - as started before, I find her claim/gambit good enough that other scum targets would be a better lynch. Keeping scrafty alive is extremely important imo. That said, scum read.
*18. TheGoddamn [m] - I reviewed all his posts and really still have nothing to say about him. Curious. Null.
19. TheWorthyEdge [m] - Died D2 - Who stood to actually gain by that meltdown? It certainly wasn't me, as some would imply. That's where I intend to look tomorrow.
20. Xamtheking [m] - really shaky reason for cop claim. Has only "cleared" town. Survived a 2 kill last night which is increasingly suspicious if it seems Bowie killed N1 and Shelly killed N2. Null read.
*21. Zubz [m] - Not a lot of strong feelings. Warning bells with him commenting on N1 and missing the opportunity to change his vote but then he had a solid pick and town ML'd anyway.
2 and 3 are about just as likely to me. I have played a game with town Star before and honestly, she was very confused about a lot of things there too. I wouldn't be surprised if she genuinely read her role pm wrong. However, it could just as easily be a cover for her to hide her mistakes behind as a scum making shit up. For now, I am not going to vote for her since the power she claims is not an easy one to hide with, if she is lying that will probably become clear eventually, but I will keep my eyes on her. .gif)