I'm trying to wrap my head around this case against Star. First she claims Jailer, which is an existing role that functions exactly as claimed going by the wiki, including allowing usage of non-killing roles. And this isn't a backtrack, she outright states that in her initial post.
She then states that she was confused when Scrafty received an item, as a clarification:
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=197088509&postcount=1561
Then when pressed later, she says that she assumed that roleblock blocked both ways.
So the point of contention is that she was confused about her role at a point before she claimed, and then admitted that confusion later.
So I'm wondering now, is this a mistake that a scum player would make if they were fake claiming a role, or is it a mistake that a townie would make if they were confused about their role. Because if the item receiving thing was called out later as a contradiction, then yeah, obviously scum, lynch away, but it wasn't.
And seeing as the role exists on the mafiascum wiki, if it was a fake claim, then I assume that's where she got it from, and it would have been picked specifically to avoid the item contradiction, so why admit the confusion at all?