Captain Toad
doesn't need me to "defend" him here but this is really, really simple, and Im sure you realize it, but in case you're not trying to be obtuse on purpose, I'll spell it out real simple for you.
He is saying that Game Pass might be worth 10 dollars a month. But that's not really the cost, because only a complete idiot would pay 10 dollars a month when it's so incredibly easy to get it
far cheaper. You understand that right? The problem with Game Pass is not the value it provides to the player, but the expectations it will engender among people who like top quality games and then start expecting them for next to nothing. Look at the comments among Game Pass holders in the RE Village thread as a prime example. It's already happening.
Also, your "$6300 dollars worth of games" link is a terrible way to look at the service. Your
time is what is most valuable, and you're never going to play all of those games. So you won't get that "value" out of the service anyway. I'll make the analogy I like to fall back on. No one walks into a Sizzler and goes "there is thousands of dollars worth of food for me to eat at the salad bar!" ... Because you can't possibly eat all that food. It doesn't matter you have "all you can eat." And then the food at the salad bar is not good, and not what I want. I would much rather
pay directly for
high quality food I want. Now GP might start getting some of those games that are worth the full price (Starfield), but ... man has it been a slow roll out. The service is nearly five damn years old now! Half a decade old!
Here is the other disconnect you, and so many others, seem to suffer. If the fiscal years aren't looking good because they can't make money selling games, guess what happens? Just take a guess.
And no, people were not looking for a rival to game pass. Not that I saw. The only people talking about that are Xbox only gamers who were setting this update up to be a "failure." Set up a false expectation, that no one in the real world really has, so you can immediately cry foul when it's inevitably not that thing. The fact you think you deserve an endless supply of AAA games for little to no money, and that you don't care at all about the people who provide that hobby to you ... What do you think that says?