nush
Member
The budget probably went into them reprising their roles.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Andor is a five-year story told over two seasons an 24 episodes leading up to where Rogue One begins
- Thread starter ManaByte
- Start date
The budget probably went into them reprising their roles.
Pegasus Actual
Gold Member
Rogue One was at least a solid spaceship battle porno whatever its other faults. But the problem with all this Star Wars shit is they just have to tie everything together. They make a Han Solo movie and he has to run into the "I don't like your face" guys and do the fucking Kessel Run in under 20 parsecs or whatthefuckever, and then at the end he's instrumental to founding the rebellion because of course he is. Obi-Wan's show couldn't just be some kind of interesting new Obi-Wan adventure... nah it had to do all the Skywalker things because of course it did.
This shit will never be interesting with that kind of storytelling. Someone needs to tell the writers that it's a big galaxy.
This shit will never be interesting with that kind of storytelling. Someone needs to tell the writers that it's a big galaxy.
jufonuk
not tag worthy
IDKFA
I am Become Bilbo Baggins
Nobody_Important
“Aww, it’s so...average,” she said to him in a cold brick of passion
If its as good as Obi-Wan was then I am on board.
Disney continues to make their TV stuff amazing and their movies Shit when it comes to Star Wars.
Disney continues to make their TV stuff amazing and their movies Shit when it comes to Star Wars.
jufonuk
not tag worthy
Mandolorian. Was and still is the best Star Wars series to date. Now they are trying to use it for spin off of other series and drawing the sky walkers into it. I am worried it will go to shit.
Pick a genre. Throw in Star Wars leave the movies out of it, we know by the name they share the same universe. So don’t worry about it. go nuts profit.
Pick a genre. Throw in Star Wars leave the movies out of it, we know by the name they share the same universe. So don’t worry about it. go nuts profit.
Last edited:
Rockondevil
Member
Eh so bored of Disney and not wanting to use Space Wizards (not that they do it well when they do).
It's such a Disney thing to have normal people can be just as good.
I'll likely give it a go, because why not.
It's such a Disney thing to have normal people can be just as good.
I'll likely give it a go, because why not.
HoodWinked
Member
this show is kind of getting screwed
rather than getting to release after the high off the Mandalorian, it's releasing while everyone is starting to get Star Wars Fatigue. Also it's a side story of a side story so it's rather unappealing and knowing the fate of the character also makes the stakes even lower.
rather than getting to release after the high off the Mandalorian, it's releasing while everyone is starting to get Star Wars Fatigue. Also it's a side story of a side story so it's rather unappealing and knowing the fate of the character also makes the stakes even lower.
Exactly this. Ill continue to beat this drum. I am tired of Star Wars TV shows. Mandolorian Season 1 was great, besides that these all should have been single, tight focused films.
Disney starting their own streaming service + COVID + the Solo "flop" was the worst thing that could have happened to Star Wars. Now everything should be a tv show becuse Disney will have the most margin and least possibility to lose money. Also shitty plots, worse costumes and actors, and everything worse in general.
Doom85
Gold Member
I’m assuming you’re excluding Ewan McGregor from that. Dude has been great in everything I’ve seen him in recently: Christopher Robin, Birds of Prey, and Doctor Sleep. I’ve not seen Obi-Wan yet but I’d be shocked if he phoned it in.
I’m assuming you’re excluding Ewan McGregor from that. Dude has been great in everything I’ve seen him in recently: Christopher Robin, Birds of Prey, and Doctor Sleep. I’ve not seen Obi-Wan yet but I’d be shocked if he phoned it in.
Obviously im not talking about Ewan McGregor but I am talking about the sort of side characters etc. Also its cool that they got Tamura Morrison to play Boba Fett but his acting is ... wooden, to say the least.
Last edited:
ManaByte
Banned
The EU cult on the internet is convinced George secretly loved the EU and read all the books, but the reality is he never read any of them.
George DID read and enjoy the comics as a visual medium. He actually went and bought all of the original art for Marvel's recent Han Solo mini-series because he liked it so much.
Toots
Gold Member
"How can i portrait someone so utterly different, so detached from both feminine and masculine physical attributes?...
-Just draw a bald uggo, and don't forget to shave their eyebrows fore the extra alien look."
Everything is so depressingly unoriginal in western mainstream entertainment nowdays
Shame that Disney's star wars only taste like reheated fast food and not J-LO's cooch
ItsGreat
Member
I don't think I'd be so 'meh' about it if Disney had actually created decent TV shows with Mando and Obi Wan.
All the shows they've made so far have been trash.
Poor acting.
Poor Dialogue.
Poor story beats.
Poor in universe logic choices.
Poor crowd scenes.
They're too busy trying to tick all the right boxes for maximum reach. When really they just need to let someone tell a story.
The best kids TV shows are the ones that don't treat the watchers as kids, they just tell a story.
Disney needs to stop molding the show to fit certain demographics and just let the creators tell a story.
All the shows they've made so far have been trash.
Poor acting.
Poor Dialogue.
Poor story beats.
Poor in universe logic choices.
Poor crowd scenes.
They're too busy trying to tick all the right boxes for maximum reach. When really they just need to let someone tell a story.
The best kids TV shows are the ones that don't treat the watchers as kids, they just tell a story.
Disney needs to stop molding the show to fit certain demographics and just let the creators tell a story.
dr_octagon
Banned
I would like a show about the inter galactic trade federation and the politics, like Space West Wing.
General Grevious makes a cameo to file an application to build a death ray on a cargo transport.
Think of the adventures of embargos, disputes and aggressive diplomacy the fans are missing out on.
General Grevious makes a cameo to file an application to build a death ray on a cargo transport.
Think of the adventures of embargos, disputes and aggressive diplomacy the fans are missing out on.
trikster40
Member
Not sure they can do 12 episodes each season and not get boring. Boba Fett couldn’t even do 6 good episodes.
FunkMiller
Gold Member
The streaming wars are fast becoming the absolute death knell of focussed story telling. Now they all have to have enough content to justify their monthly subscriptions, every company is just throwing shit at the wall, and stretching out enough to cover eight to twelve episodes. I fully expect Disney to greenlight dull, pointless mini series about Bosk, Wedge, Max Rebo, and Lobot.
sol_bad
Member
Disney would still have internal numbers which would tell them if a show was a failure or not. It's the same with Netflix, these streaming services aren't free money to these companies. They still need to justify every show they produce, no idea what happened with Obi-Wan but generally Disney make some of the most expensive TV shows around. It's the reason Netflix cancel shows, low viewership = wasted money.
Last edited:
Of course but its less of a risk than movie theaters. IE the internal number is "lower" to some extent.
Thanks jerk, I am having nightmare flashbacks about those awful Trandoshan costumes in Book of Fett
Last edited:
sol_bad
Member
Imagine posting this sentence when apparently you don't give a fuck about the brand anymore...
GymWolf
Gold Member
Fair point, fuck disney.
BaneIsPain
Member
I don’t have any expectations. Maybe it’ll be a sleeper hit? Who knows?
But I’m definitely not eager to watch this.
But I’m definitely not eager to watch this.
Catphish
Gold Member
wtf are you smoking, and where can I buy it?
Fugitive Sex
Member
Shows I wanted that could have easily been made but will never be:
Boba Fett being a ruthless bounty hunter.
Darth Vader hunting Jedi and delving into the mysteries of the dark side, also focusing on his bizarre relationship with the emperor.
An Obi-Wan show where he is portrayed as the ascetic monk and guardian he was supposed to be, reflecting on the force and his failures, with much of the show showing us he and Anakin together, and Obi-Wan's perspective on events.
Some of that could have been worked into the shows that have already been produced, instead we got crap written by people who don't even know what Star Wars is, and actors who don't research their roles.
Boba Fett being a ruthless bounty hunter.
Darth Vader hunting Jedi and delving into the mysteries of the dark side, also focusing on his bizarre relationship with the emperor.
An Obi-Wan show where he is portrayed as the ascetic monk and guardian he was supposed to be, reflecting on the force and his failures, with much of the show showing us he and Anakin together, and Obi-Wan's perspective on events.
Some of that could have been worked into the shows that have already been produced, instead we got crap written by people who don't even know what Star Wars is, and actors who don't research their roles.
Nobody_Important
“Aww, it’s so...average,” she said to him in a cold brick of passion
What? You dont like their TV stuff? I have thoroughly enjoyed it. Especially Mandalorian and Kenobi.
Catphish
Gold Member
I liked the Mandalorian. That was quality. But the rest of it has not been a good use of my time.
And Kenobi. Dude. Don't get me started.
Nobody_Important
“Aww, it’s so...average,” she said to him in a cold brick of passion
Oh. Sorry to hear it.I liked the Mandalorian. That was quality. But the rest of it has not been a good use of my time.
And Kenobi. Dude. Don't get me started.
dr_octagon
Banned
I dunno who this is so I checked on Wikipedia.Are you a fan of Star Wars Minute by chance?
"Star Wars Minute has been called "the seed of a rapidly expanding podcast genre" by the pop-culture website The Ringer due to its minute-by-minute format, which has now bled into dozens of other podcasts analyzing films such as Back to the Future, The Big Lebowski and Goodfellas"
I don't understand if you're insulting me? I have no idea about podcasts other than the MMA DMT man.
Its a podcast where each episode discusses one minute of Star Wars, in order, starting with A New Hope.
Its great, very funny. They are up to Solo now. They did all movies in release order.
They always talk about how they want a political Star Wars drama like the West Wing which is why I asked.
dr_octagon
Banned
Laser swords, storm troopers, space battles, force and robots are overdone in the series, they should do some unique work and not just the visuals.
You could lean into the soap opera element rather than it being too serious. I think it could work.
dr_octagon
Banned
