• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Are there any MANLY console RPG's out there?

Aside from the upcoming X360 version of Oblivion, there seems to be a complete dearth of acceptably macho RPG's available for consoles. I know there's plenty of mature themes and dark subject matter in a lot of the Japanese console RPG's that have dropped in the past couple of years, but for the most part they always come packaged with at least a couple of androgenous protagonists and a healthy dose of effeminate anime art.

Where does a guy go for a serious, manly RPG that doesn't have a wacky sidekick, homo-erotic fashion design, or a lack of depth? Its like I want to pick up the new Gauntlet just because the trappings suit my taste, but I don't want to feel cheated by the relatively narrow gameplay/storyline that usually accompanies hack-n-slash affairs of its ilk. Is there such a game, or just wait for Oblivion? Buy a new PC? Gah..
 
I owned KOTOR for a month, but I didn't like the combat system. I hate trying to manage realtime battles in games like that and turning it on turn-based just made it awkward for me. Maybe I didn't give it a fair shake, but it got stale..
 
KOTOR is anything but stale, and contains one of the most fun and dynamic combat system ever.

Can anyone name a single RPG that lets you blow back waves of enemies with a single attack? You just feel powerful, and using every character's individual abilities makes it really dynamic.

Plus, the story is tops for any game this generation, and also very different for each set of choices and each playthrough.
 
Speaking of manly I can't wait to play the Conan MMO. Hacking off enemy limbs while dressed like a barbarian, awesome.
 
Speevy said:
KOTOR is anything but stale, and contains one of the most fun and dynamic combat system ever.

Can anyone name a single RPG that lets you blow back waves of enemies with a single attack? You just feel powerful, and using every character's individual abilities makes it really dynamic.

Plus, the story is tops for any game this generation, and also very different for each set of choices and each playthrough.

I'm saying that it got stale to me...kinda stupid arguing quality to someone who already bought, played, and sold the game..no?
 
Shin Megami Tensei: Digital Devil Saga fits that description perfectly.

But if it's raw MANLINESS you want, it's not an RPG, but

90_7.JPG


*Grunt* *Grunt* *Grunt*
 
I dunno but I'm having a great time with DQVIII there is not homoeroctic protagonist, the characters are extremely likeable, the anime look may turn you off, but if you can tolerate that you are in for a treat oh and the story is very lighthearted don't expect a dark and angst-ridden story in this one.
 
Are PC titles not an option? Consoles don't really excel in the mature characters and storylines area for RPGs, since the bulk are imported titfests or angst ridden conflicts with the ultimate force of chaos
 
Date of Lies said:
The Ogre games were the manliest japanese rpgs ever created.

not withstanding the mild homosexual undertones between the main character and his childhood friend in Ogre Battle 64, I agree.
 
are you manly? Do you work out? Do you dress in a non-emo/metrosexual way with non-emo/metrosexual hair? Then shut up. I'm sure you do 90 percent of guys do.
 
Zilch said:
In my mind, a macho manly game would be much more homoerotic than anything made in Japan.
Nah, you just don't see where he's coming from. What Ned, and a few others, wants is an RPG with this hulking, barbarian type hero. Somebody with muscles so huge he can barely wipe himself, and who can make the villians of the world cower in a fetal position with only a single scowl.

You see, this makes the RPG manly. You'd be handed a protagonist that simply rips off people's heads on a whim, and then uses their neck as a urinal. This hero would be hard-fucking-core, to the point that NOBODY would dare fuck with him. And when some cocky villian got the idea to defy this unspoken rule of non-fuckery-with-the-barbarian-protagonist, watch out, as there'd be enough blood spilled to make the biblical tales look like Sesame Street.

In case you're not getting where I'm coming from, here's an example cutscene:

The protagonist stands with a horde of brigands upon a hilltop, surrounded on all sides by thousands of Orcs at the base. One wave presses forward, Orcs and Brigands clash -- limbs are flying left and right, blood spurting everywhere, bodies piling up so high on the ground that the battlefield is starting to take place on-top of them, as there's no other choice.

Soon, another wave of Orcs strikes, and then another... After a few, the last of the brigands fall, leaving only our protagonist -- shirt torn, shield well worn, and his body caked in blood from head to toe. Another wave strikes, this will be the last... Before they get there, the protagonist sheds his tathered shirt entirely, and grips his blade. One Orc, then two, rush towards him blades in hand, followed shortly by an earth-rattling sound of clashing steel.

The protagonist swings around, chops off one Orc's head, then the other's. Another few rush the hilltop, reaching where he is... A few well-placed blows later, a few more Orcs lie slain before him. He grins, as there is only one remaining, charging steadfast towards him. He grips his blade once more, and throws his shield forward to block what will be the last of the strikes made upon him this day, and pushes the Orc past him to his side.

...Then, with a grace rarely seen in a barbarian, he twirls around behind this final Orc and lops off his head.

<Ned Flanders> *squeals like a girl* Look at his muscles ripple as he chops off that last Orc's head! OMG! This is fantastic! He's so manly, I want him! *swoons*

See, this is what they want. This is manly, and rugged, in an oiled-up wrestling match kind of way. Rippling muscles, covered in sweat and blood, ready to be positively ravished by the player's eyes, is the order of the day... and, well, to that I say: fap away, Ned Flanders, fap away.
 
Himuro said:
Actually, aside from Vaan FFXII looks more manly than MOST rpgs. Just watch the latest trailers.



Yeah, but he will make sure the other male characters get in touch with their feminine side.
 
Himuro, you know that pic is funny.

If they put Vaan (and no one else) on the front cover, US gamers would be afraid to buy it. :lol
 
203372.jpg


If you can find it. It probably costs all of 5 bucks now and is well worth it. The only downside is it takes up like half of a memory card and saving games and loading saves takes the better part of a year but the game is aces. No fluff, no anime crap, no homogenized angsty characters. Yes you play as a chick, but she is hot and kicks alot of ass and she rides a big red dragon that burns shit. They have tons of melee and ranged magical combat and you can ride the dragon around. Its a fun action adventure RPG that has a few problems, but its still a cool game with lots of open environments, quests, and dungeon to explore
 
It still has an anime style, and it's only sort of an RPG, but maybe you might want to check out Fire Emblem on GBA. The characters are a lot less fruity than in most Japanese RPGs.
 
The Bard's Tale.

I don't know how you get any more manly than "a quest for coin and cleavage."

Sure, it doesn't take itself seriously, but it's still half a victory.

Note my avatar. Can't get any more manly than thrash metal.
 
Arx Fatalis.

There.

You don't get more manly than that. Dark as fuck, glum as fuck, evil as fuck.

Oh and I'd say Dragon Quest VIII but that game has Hipsters.

GODDAMN HIPSTERS :p
 
More than manly in the muscular hero sense, he's probably referring to a more solemn story and environment. Something like Planescape Torment or Baldur's Gate II.
 
Scott said:
<Ned Flanders> *squeals like a girl* Look at his muscles ripple as he chops off that last Orc's head! OMG! This is fantastic! He's so manly, I want him! *swoons*

See, this is what they want. This is manly, and rugged, in an oiled-up wrestling match kind of way. Rippling muscles, covered in sweat and blood, ready to be positively ravished by the player's eyes, is the order of the day... and, well, to that I say: fap away, Ned Flanders, fap away.
Yea, just like how an adult fan of JRPGs, with their prettied-up, pubescent heroes, must be a pedophile. Nice avatar.
 
slidewinder said:
Yea, just like how an adult fan of JRPGs, with their prettied-up, pubescent heroes, must be a pedophile. Nice avatar.

Guys who demand 'manly' (generally western fantasy-style) RPG's are usually the ones who like to ridicule jRPG's, and accuse their fans of being pedophiles or homosexuals. Pity it bothers you when the other side hits back and scores. Deal with it.
 
Shinoobi said:
Skies of Arcadia?

winner

Vigoro.gif

I bet Vigoro would be real popular with Ned!
Gilder.jpg

But he's nothing compared to Gilder.

And yeah Wizardry, any console port of it, would work. You could make your character maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaanleee, as its just a PC rpg really.
 
Come on now, I mean, can't you tell who the real men are?
calintz_1024.gif

Read gamefaqs, a lot of posters on the Magna Carta message board seem to think Calintz is one of the most bad-ass guys out there (compared him to Yuri of Shadow Hearts they did too). uh, yeah... :D
 
Top Bottom