Is that your final answer? Do you think he's the scummiest of Kalor's past voters?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Arkham Asylum Mafia |OT| It's time to kill the Bat
- Thread starter franconp
- Start date
Is that your final answer? Do you think he's the scummiest of Kalor's past voters?
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
No, I'm saying that if I survive today, I'm subbing out.
To be clear with Terra, it's not the reads I thought to be flippant or unnecessary, but the follow up reactions to getting heat from the acohrs switch.
I already saw your reads list and appreciated it, btw, was just looking for an update heading towards the end of the day. Looking for fresh peeks.
I already saw your reads list and appreciated it, btw, was just looking for an update heading towards the end of the day. Looking for fresh peeks.
I think it's strange he was against Terra, but once the Terra bandwagon started going, he voted for me instead.
Feels like he saw a Terra lynch incoming, and didn't want to be implicated in the aftermath so set his vote elsewhere
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
DAY 1 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
Terrabyte20xx (4)
Kalor 434
Natiko 450 632
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689
Mazre (3)
acohrs 422 689
Natiko 632
Terrabyte20xx 648
Royal_Flush 745
Lifeline 747 750
Lifeline (3)
Terrabyte20xx 214 449
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
batsnacks (3)
Sorian 669
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753
Natiko (2)
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676
Fat4all (1)
*Splinter 579
Kalor (1)
batsnacks 140 702
*Splinter 235 579
SexyFish 289 688
MickD 533
Lifeline 693 747
StarSketch (0):Natiko 232 450
Dr. Worm (0):Sorian 491 669, Lifeline 496 506
Sorian (0):Faddy 98 499
acohrs (0):Lifeline 173 216, Lifeline 374 496, Terrabyte20xx 449 501
Timeaisis (0):Sorian 78 287, SexyFish 270 289
SexyFish (0):Timeaisis 207 511, Sorian 287 491, Dr. Worm 318 753
No active vote for Day 1: AbsolutBro, Mazre, Nudull, StarSketch, That Dude John, Verelios
Day 1 Postcount: *Splinter 20, AbsolutBro 13, acohrs 39, batsnacks 38, Dr. Worm 54, Faddy 42, Fat4all 70, Fireblend 23, Kalor 16, Lifeline 52, Mazre 8, MickD 27, Natiko 50, Nudull 5, Royal_Flush 13, SexyFish 25, Sorian 69, StarSketch 11, Terrabyte20xx 29, That Dude John 3, Timeaisis 22, Verelios 21, Zippedpinhead 10
Day 1 ends:
13 votes for majority
Terrabyte20xx (4)
Kalor 434
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689
Mazre (3)
Natiko 632
Terrabyte20xx 648
Royal_Flush 745
Lifeline (3)
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
batsnacks (3)
Sorian 669
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753
Natiko (2)
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676
Fat4all (1)
*Splinter 579
Kalor (1)
MickD 533
StarSketch (0):
Dr. Worm (0):
Sorian (0):
acohrs (0):
Timeaisis (0):
SexyFish (0):
No active vote for Day 1: AbsolutBro, Mazre, Nudull, StarSketch, That Dude John, Verelios
Day 1 Postcount: *Splinter 20, AbsolutBro 13, acohrs 39, batsnacks 38, Dr. Worm 54, Faddy 42, Fat4all 70, Fireblend 23, Kalor 16, Lifeline 52, Mazre 8, MickD 27, Natiko 50, Nudull 5, Royal_Flush 13, SexyFish 25, Sorian 69, StarSketch 11, Terrabyte20xx 29, That Dude John 3, Timeaisis 22, Verelios 21, Zippedpinhead 10
Day 1 ends:
13 votes for majority
I know that feel.
Why should I defend you? I don't know your alignment.
I haven't attacked you, that's the best you're going to get at this point. And acohrs is right that you're expecting us to defend you for meta reasons but complain when meta is used against you.
Tempted to vote you just for this.
I'm going to bed soon, will check the vote count and make my final vote.
bs you haven't even mentioned me this game until now and I've been trying to get your attention for a good half of this phase. You would have said this at the time if you actually thought it.
Well, I apologize if my remarks ruined your enjoyment. It's all just a game - I didn't intend anything past that. If you do sub out hopefully you continue to play in future games. I know the moderators will work in private to place people in games that aren't ones people they have trouble playing with are in if you let them know via PM.
Let me get this quote out of the way then talk about my thoughts on the rest of this catch up. I don't know what bat was doing when he called you top town for voting Kalor. Originally, I thought he was egging you on and it was a jokey label but no punchline ever really came, honestly nothing really ever came out of it so it seemed off I guess?
--------
That said, Lifeline, what the hell was that spark of clarity all of a sudden? You've spent all day tooting a group read (bad play) then suddenly something sparkled through and you knew that competing wagons is the best chance for success (good play) and then you went right back to bad play by asserting that mafia could just vote off wagon if the competing wagons are both town and they would just look great for it (no they wouldn't). That and how you suddenly started flailing has me a little confused. Now I'm stuck in a position where I think bats is sketchy as fuck but his points on you are sounding more and more right.
What's with the defeatist attitude? Now that's unlike you.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
I'm sorry if I'm rubbing people the wrong way, I'm just done have to explain myself over and over only to pretty much always die day one. This is a game and it's supposed to be fun, and it just isn't fun anymore.
I don't want to hurt my team(whether you believe me to be town or not I don't care) by voting myself out so I'm not going to.
None of this is because of anyone personally, It's just clear that I apparently don't know how to play anymore.
I don't want to hurt my team(whether you believe me to be town or not I don't care) by voting myself out so I'm not going to.
None of this is because of anyone personally, It's just clear that I apparently don't know how to play anymore.
Zippedpinhead
Member
For what it's worth, I am pretty sure you are town and have a vote for lifeline...
These top wagons, Terra vote feels like junk to me (though seeing his defeatist attitude makes me feel kind of eh, only saving grace is I know I did frustrate him in DR so I understand.). Mazre is fine but seems like the random chance option, I don't see any logic for Mazre aside from inactivity which is non-alignment indicative. I'm still thinking on the whole batsnacks vs. Lifeline thing. I very much think there is scum between the two now.
Zippedpinhead
Member
That should read "I" have a vote for lifeline...
Not really, there is material there already, if someone thinks the spot is scum, they should still vote for it. It isn't really a shot in the dark and, purposeful or not, I've seen scum sub out in this position and then the spot didn't get lynched for days because everyone was giving a new player to the game a chance.
I've been asking this for a while and it seems to me like it's a glorified inactive lynch so far.
You are both here now. If you want any sympathy about post counts you should make an actual effort instead of one and done driveby posts
Royal_Flush
Member
Mazre pretty much is random chance at this point. But the last couple of games I lost as Town (minus DR3 where Nantiko did a great job) were because the random chance people stayed random chance people and never got lynched.
Oth I'd also be on-board for lifeline or bats, though I'd prefer lifeline. The main reason I want to keep him around is that I like the craziness he brings in
You two are voting for each other, regardless of the reason, it is a thing. It's just not weighted as strong because my vote is hardly going to stay. I wanted to push something new in the time I knew I'd be afk but didn't expect to come back to this at all. It's painting Lifeline as a cornered baddie and Worm comes out looking weird in it as well which would be funny if Lifeline was scum and did the whole Worm part of his act as a distancing job.
Fuck it though so that the vote count can look more accurate.
VOTE: Lifeline
Though I'd prefer a bats vs. Lifeline wagon, I'd end up on Life in the end I think which means bats would need 2 more votes to even be tied at this point.
That's fair enough.
I'll stick with my guns for now, but I'm still eager for a more obvious chance at lynching scum. I'm looking through the amazed build up and not finding much convincing.
AbsolutBro
Member
Can someone not on mobile post the "who posted" link?
I want 0 post count sympathy. I think it's the worst metric in the game and least indicative of anything.
Lifeline seems super easily swayed here in the late part of the phase despite his convictions earlier on. Makes me lean town on him.
I'm still not crazy about Terra or Kalor as scum either, feels like they were the first players to say/do something a little out of line and have been stuck fighting that all phase.
Bats I could see being scum but his play so far in my mind doesn't warrant a day one lynch. If I were to vote for him at this point it would have to be as an act of self preservation not as any sort of discernment that he was scum.
Worms push on Batsnacks is honestly somewhat troubling to me.
Mazre pretty much is random chance at this point. But the last couple of games I lost as Town (minus DR3 where Nantiko did a great job) were because the random chance people stayed random chance people and never got lynched.
Oth I'd also be on-board for lifeline or bats, though I'd prefer lifeline. The main reason I want to keep him around is that I like the craziness he brings in
Those "random chance" people are supposed to be dealt with via cop or vig if they are truly only participating the bare minimum and a real read can't be made. I get what you are going for but day 1 needs a strong lynch so that there is more to go about on day 2. Whenever we've done the inactive thing on day 1 then day 2 still, unsurprisingly, feels like more of the same with no real direction.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
DAY 1 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
Lifeline (4)
Terrabyte20xx 214 449
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
Sorian 781
Mazre (3)
acohrs 422 689
Natiko 632
Terrabyte20xx 648
Royal_Flush 745
Lifeline 747 750
Terrabyte20xx (3)
Kalor 434 777
Natiko 450 632
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689
batsnacks (2)
Sorian 669 781
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753
Natiko (2)
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676
Fat4all (1)
*Splinter 579
Kalor (1)
batsnacks 140 702
*Splinter 235 579
SexyFish 289 688
MickD 533
Lifeline 693 747
Sorian (0):Faddy 98 499
acohrs (0):Lifeline 173 216, Lifeline 374 496, Terrabyte20xx 449 501
Dr. Worm (0):Sorian 491 669, Lifeline 496 506
Timeaisis (0):Sorian 78 287, SexyFish 270 289
StarSketch (0):Natiko 232 450
SexyFish (0):Timeaisis 207 511, Sorian 287 491, Dr. Worm 318 753
No active vote for Day 1: AbsolutBro, Kalor (has previously voted), Mazre, Nudull, StarSketch, That Dude John, Verelios
Day 1 Postcount: *Splinter 21, AbsolutBro 14, acohrs 40, batsnacks 41, Dr. Worm 54, Faddy 43, Fat4all 75, Fireblend 25, Kalor 18, Lifeline 53, Mazre 10, MickD 27, Natiko 51, Nudull 6, Royal_Flush 14, SexyFish 25, Sorian 74, StarSketch 11, Terrabyte20xx 30, That Dude John 3, Timeaisis 22, Verelios 21, Zippedpinhead 12
Day 1 ends:
13 votes for majority
Lifeline (4)
Timeaisis 511
Zippedpinhead 586
batsnacks 702
Sorian 781
Mazre (3)
Natiko 632
Terrabyte20xx 648
Royal_Flush 745
Terrabyte20xx (3)
Fat4all 451
SexyFish 688
acohrs 689
batsnacks (2)
Lifeline 750
Dr. Worm 753
Natiko (2)
Faddy 499
Fireblend 676
Fat4all (1)
*Splinter 579
Kalor (1)
MickD 533
Sorian (0):
acohrs (0):
Dr. Worm (0):
Timeaisis (0):
StarSketch (0):
SexyFish (0):
No active vote for Day 1: AbsolutBro, Kalor (has previously voted), Mazre, Nudull, StarSketch, That Dude John, Verelios
Day 1 Postcount: *Splinter 21, AbsolutBro 14, acohrs 40, batsnacks 41, Dr. Worm 54, Faddy 43, Fat4all 75, Fireblend 25, Kalor 18, Lifeline 53, Mazre 10, MickD 27, Natiko 51, Nudull 6, Royal_Flush 14, SexyFish 25, Sorian 74, StarSketch 11, Terrabyte20xx 30, That Dude John 3, Timeaisis 22, Verelios 21, Zippedpinhead 12
Day 1 ends:
13 votes for majority
Even worse than a Mazre lynch. I know Mick technically has more posts but Mazre at least said more. Mick would be a complete question mark.
StarSketch
Banned
He's pulled this same move in past games as both scum and town, actually. He freaks out whenever there's significant pressure on him.
I haven't really said anything because people have been making points faster than I can, but whatever the heck was going on with the vote bouncing was really weird. Super tempted to just go 'newbie town flailing' on Lifeline. But on the other hand that could be equally true of scum Lifeline, but that would also assume no one in his scum chat is helping him.
Batsnacks is pretty aggressive, but he appears to be consistent? The lack of reaction from lifeline is interesting though.
OP said:
Ummmmm...
If you are going to struggle against my vote, you would have been better off pointing out that I've been town reading you all day and now suddenly changed my mind, I give no shits that you have me pegged as scum. That's been your read of me all day, it's always been about how others have interacted with me and never about what I, myself, have done even though there are easy criticisms that could be laid on me. The stuff you do target that I did, never actually happened and when I point out to you that the posts you are quoting from me don't mean at all what you are trying to tell everyone they mean, you've ignored me.
on mobile, go to the bottom of the page and hit the 'Tools' button.
That leads to the 'who poster' link in the mobile version of the site
StarSketch
Banned
Already said I'm wary of MickD enough without his penguin soft claim that I'd vote for him.
Not a huge fan of any of these options... Was considering an "eh fuck it" vote on Mazre but it's not based on much and he just made this post:
That leaves me with Natiko. I think I'd prefer to lynch Acohrs first. I remember thinking "if acohrs is scum then Natiko probably is too, but I don't know what lead me to that.
Apart from that I've had a few small suspicions about Natiko... nothing I could ever put my finger on but a few others have raised similar concerns.
"Eh fuck it"
VOTE: Natiko
which I found myself agreeing with (except I'd swap Worm for Sorian in that last sentence).
That leaves me with Natiko. I think I'd prefer to lynch Acohrs first. I remember thinking "if acohrs is scum then Natiko probably is too, but I don't know what lead me to that.
Apart from that I've had a few small suspicions about Natiko... nothing I could ever put my finger on but a few others have raised similar concerns.
"Eh fuck it"
VOTE: Natiko
Terrible? I'm already criticizing the Mazre votes for the inactive lynch they're trying to accomplish. And I dunno about Terra, now I kind of feel like lynching him if only because disclosing he's thinking of subbing out is going to buy him more time for him and his replacement and that's a shitty way of getting out of the spotlight.