Support NeoGAF

[Mazre]

4 way tie at 2 according to the vote tool

Actually I guess Flame moved that to a 5 way tie

 

[Zippedpinhead]

Blarg also claimed as a "targeted" lightning rod but he made up a different story for what that meant. He said that he chose a player and that player would become a lightning rod for all effects that night. His sounded more like what I would define as a targeted lightning rod than what Flush is claiming to be. But again, it just sounds like a sloppy fake claim..

Thanks for the clarification, but what happens if he dies of poison tonight? What knowledge do we gain other than scum knows how to poison?

 

[Sorian]

Correct.



My short thoughts are all I've got so far. Sorian's vote isn't even worth acknowledging.

Also, this, this is scum Bronx. Not taking bait, hell, not even being willing to acknowledge the bait. This is a man worried about something but no one seems to care and there is only an hour left so I will move here

VOTE: Timeaisis

Partially because Flame just moved his vote there which means the lynch has a chance but more because I was split between CCS and him and honestly, his move to CCS looks like scum spewing someone town.

 

[Sorian]

Thanks for the clarification, but what happens if he dies of poison tonight? What knowledge do we gain other than scum knows how to poison?

Well, we would gain the knowledge of whether Flush was telling the truth or not. That would remove some of the murkiness but the play here has never told us anything to be honest. While it's likely that it's a scum poisoner, there is no definite to that so it doesn't even clear Fat (assuming the role claim was true) completely.

 

[AbsolutBro]

I'm having trouble building a coherent case of any form. I'm almost certain that Nudull is town, I'm still scumleaning Faddy, but considerably less than the past two days. Natiko has moved into the scum list for me, and Sorian is still in that null area. What little of Penguin there is reads town to me, while LP I still have no read on. rereading the thread hasn't really helped at all. I'm about to eat but will be on mobile, hopefully.

 

[Royal_Flush]

Going to bed now. I hope you'll do the right thing and lynch Mazre or AB. Or Bronx, I don't mind. Good luck.

Thanks for the clarification, but what happens if he dies of poison tonight? What knowledge do we gain other than scum knows how to poison?

Fat4all being very likely Town.

One more thing: If you're the poison doc with limited shots it's probably best to not even bother. If I survive I will be a huge discussion point tomorrow with literally nothing to be gained.

 

[Faddy]

Blarg also claimed as a "targeted" lightning rod but he made up a different story for what that meant. He said that he chose a player and that player would become a lightning rod for all effects that night. His sounded more like what I would define as a targeted lightning rod than what Flush is claiming to be. But again, it just sounds like a sloppy fake claim.



I think everyone can tell. I still think your tunnel is weak.



That's the game state now. What's the excuse for day 1 and day 2? No matter how you slice it Time has been throwing shade with no bite since day 1. If anything, I'm actually surprised he moved off of Faddy and didn't just ride that through to day end but then again, a Faddy lynch hasn't seemed to likely of most of today. He went to someone else who had a better chance of being lynched.

I see there is no rebuttal of the action of Natiko on how he has targeted weak players and not engaged or challenged any high volume players.

 

[Royal_Flush]

Oh, for the love of god, don't lynch Timeasis. We can't afford lynching more semi-active people. They get mowed down by NKs anyway.

 

[CCS]

I have to go to bed, hopefully I'll wake up alive

 

[Mazre]

I'll probably regret this but we don't seem to be making much progress.

Natiko is not scum, that much I can confirm based on last night.

I'm Clayface, a Hider.

I hid behind Natiko last night and didn't die, therefore he isn't scum.

I chose not to hide N1 out of an abundance of caution.

 

[Fat4all]

I'm having trouble building a coherent case of any form.

I'm fucking feelin' ya right now.

I'm almost certain that Nudull is town,

This I'm not so certain on. They don't seem to have much to say, and have mirrored Time a bit in their reads today. I dunno if this is just similar to what they did yesterday with Time and my own arguments against Faddy, or what, but it's strange to see them latch onto other people arguments to try and make their own.

- Faddy really wiggled his way out of a lynch yesterday. I need to go back and analyze those turn of events.

A shame Faddy got away in all the crazyness, I feel like we had something there.

Dunno, a little iffy. Not much to go on.

 

[Fireblend]

Vote: CSS

My previous vote for Nudull was obviously a plea for opinions but I guess that was too lofty a dream. I feel somewhat good with this vote instead. Should break the tie and generate some reactions.

 

[Fat4all]

* edit: "They don't seem to have much original to say"

 

[Verelios]

Going to bed now. I hope you'll do the right thing and lynch Mazre or AB. Or Bronx, I don't mind. Good luck.


Fat4all being very likely Town.

One more thing: If you're the poison doc with limited shots it's probably best to not even bother. If I survive I will be a huge discussion point tomorrow with literally nothing to be gained.

If the poison doc saves you and then claims tomorrow there's no problem. Any other situation happening is going to be an unfortunate consequence for you.

 

[Faddy]

I'll probably regret this but we don't seem to be making much progress.

Natiko is not scum, that much I can confirm based on last night.

I'm Clayface, a Hider.

I hid behind Natiko last night and didn't die, therefore he isn't scum.

I chose not to hide N1 out of an abundance of caution.

Does hiding behind scum automatically kill you? Because there are 4 or 5 scum out there and probably a vig so doesn't hiding increase your odds of death.

 

[Royal_Flush]

I'll probably regret this but we don't seem to be making much progress.

Natiko is not scum, that much I can confirm based on last night.

I'm Clayface, a Hider.

I hid behind Natiko last night and didn't die, therefore he isn't scum.

I chose not to hide N1 out of an abundance of caution.

Didn't they give you names to fackeclaims or something in the Scum chat?

 

[Sorian]

I see there is no rebuttal of the action of Natiko on how he has targeted weak players and not engaged or challenged any high volume players.

It's not my job to rebut that. I think he is town for completely unrelated reasons but if you want my honest opinion of where your theory falls out, it is in your definition of "weak" players. You are merging that into the definition of low post count players as well when that isn't the case. Just because you are churning out posts every few minutes does not make you a strong player, I'd still consider you weak as well since you don't play the field and more focus on one or two players at a time. On the flip side, Time is low volume but I would consider him a strong player since his points tend to be concise and direct when he does post.

I used you and Time as the examples because I think your logic fails considering Time is Natiko's current obsession and he hasn't seemed to care to go after you at all.

 

[CCS]

Guys, I can claim now before I sleep if you're going to push me forward as a lynch candidate. Quick yes/no?

 

[Verelios]

I'll probably regret this but we don't seem to be making much progress.

Natiko is not scum, that much I can confirm based on last night.

I'm Clayface, a Hider.

I hid behind Natiko last night and didn't die, therefore he isn't scum.

I chose not to hide N1 out of an abundance of caution.

Hmmmm, do you die hiding behind scum?

 

[Fireblend]

I'll probably regret this but we don't seem to be making much progress.

Natiko is not scum, that much I can confirm based on last night.

I'm Clayface, a Hider.

I hid behind Natiko last night and didn't die, therefore he isn't scum.

I chose not to hide N1 out of an abundance of caution.

So you die if you hide behind scum? Seems pretty risky tbh. Did you believe you would be targeted for NK?

In fact, if hiding behind scum kills you, wouldn't it be riskier to have done so last night when more townies were dead?

 

[Fat4all]

i'd not claim unless you absolutely have to

 

[Fireblend]

Vote: CCS

Sorry for the typo

 

[Verelios]

Something about your claim is odd Mazre buddy

 

[CCS]

i'd not claim unless you absolutely have to

Problem is once I go in five minutes I can't defend myself any more.

 

[Royal_Flush]

Didn't they give you names to fackeclaims or something in the Scum chat?

Still waiting for the implication of this to hit. Come on guys, you can figure it out what I just said.

 

[Sorian]

Oh, for the love of god, don't lynch Timeasis. We can't afford lynching more semi-active people. They get mowed down by NKs anyway.

This logic doesn't hold when we are losing. We need to find scum now not keep pecking off at the bottom and hope to luck out on quiet scum.

I'll probably regret this but we don't seem to be making much progress.

Natiko is not scum, that much I can confirm based on last night.

I'm Clayface, a Hider.

I hid behind Natiko last night and didn't die, therefore he isn't scum.

I chose not to hide N1 out of an abundance of caution.

Didn't they give you names to fackeclaims or something in the Scum chat?

Probably but that was a weird initial reaction.

 

[Mazre]

Does hiding behind scum automatically kill you? Because there are 4 or 5 scum out there and probably a vig so doesn't hiding increase your odds of death.

Hmmmm, do you die hiding behind scum?

So you die if you hide behind scum? Seems pretty risky tbh. Did you believe you would be targeted for NK?

In fact, if hiding behind scum kills you, wouldn't it be riskier to have done so last night when more townies were dead?

Yes I die hiding behind scum. Hiding serves as a weak cop that can clear town though. So not hiding every night is a wasted opportunity. Not hiding N1 comes down to a lack of information for making town v scum reads. N2 I had more information to at least take a more educated guess.

 

[CCS]

Still waiting for the implication of this to hit. Come on guys, you can figure it out what I just said.

Excuse us, we're slow today.

Mazre wagon time?

 

[Fat4all]

Problem is once I go in five minutes I can't defend myself any more.

It's you're gamble to take, in the end.

If you think it's beneficial for town to know, you risk night kill as well.

 

[Mazre]

Excuse us, we're slow today.

Mazre wagon time?

If you trust the word of the guy whose acted suspicious all day sure. Easy way to snipe a town on his way out.

 

[Sorian]

Does hiding behind scum automatically kill you? Because there are 4 or 5 scum out there and probably a vig so doesn't hiding increase your odds of death.

Hmmmm, do you die hiding behind scum?

Hider Definition

Still waiting for the implication of this to hit. Come on guys, you can figure it out what I just said.

What is the implication? That a claim can be fake? Or am I missing something obvious?

 

[Verelios]

Still waiting for the implication of this to hit. Come on guys, you can figure it out what I just said.

I mean...I got it but I'd need more certainty than that

 

[Royal_Flush]

What is the implication? That a claim can be fake? Or am I missing something obvious?

You do. That's my name.

 

[Verelios]

I thought the implication was that he's(RF) clayface so Madre just used his name

 

[Fat4all]

Yes I die hiding behind scum. Hiding serves as a weak cop that can clear town though. So not hiding every night is a wasted opportunity. Not hiding N1 comes down to a lack of information for making town v scum reads. N2 I had more information to at least take a more educated guess.

I honestly don;t see why you wouldn't hide night 1.

The possibility to know for certain whether or not someone is scum is worth risking your life for as a town, imo.

 

[Fireblend]

Oh

Unvote

 

[Verelios]

Well, well, well, counterclaim Mazre?

 

[Mazre]

Well, well, well, counterclaim Mazre?

If you trust the word of the guy whose acted suspicious all day sure. Easy way to snipe a town on his way out.

He's full of crap. End of story.

 

[Fat4all]

so royal is claiming to be Clayface?

don't they give you roles as scum that haven;t been picked as roles for the game?

 

[Sorian]

You do. That's my name.

I didn't remember you claiming a name with your power but I see Verelios said it as well so I must have just missed it. So that means one of you two fucked up because it's doubtful Fran gives a used name out to scum chat. So now the vote is between you two.

Mazre, if you're Clayface why didn't you say something to the obvious lie earlier?

Flush, can you quote me where you claimed your role name so I know how long ago it was?

 

[Verelios]

RF wasn't going to be lynched today...unless you mean his poison? Or that there's no poison doctor? I'm unsure

 

[Faddy]

I'm more inclined to believe Mazre than Flush. If Flush is scum and poisoned and will flip, he has nothing to lose by counterclaiming Mazre.

For now UNVOTE

 

[Lone_Prodigy]

Flush is Clayface.

 

[Fat4all]

nothing like some down-to-the-wire anarchy to spice up a day

so it's claim vs claim of clayface now

if Royal is scum here, they are going fucking crazy with this and the poison claim

 

[Faddy]

UNVOTE

separate line

 

[Mazre]

RF wasn't going to be lynched today...unless you mean his poison? Or that there's no poison doctor? I'm unsure

He may or may not be poisoned, there may or may not be a poison doctor. Either way his lies have caught up with him and he's dead tomorrow one way or another. He's trying to cause as much damage as possible on his way out.

 

[Fireblend]

I didn't remember you claiming a name with your power but I see Verelios said it as well so I must have just missed it. So that means one of you two fucked up because it's doubtful Fran gives a used name out to scum chat. So now the vote is between you two.

Mazre, if you're Clayface why didn't you say something to the obvious lie earlier?

Flush, can you quote me where you claimed your role name so I know how long ago it was?

I don't think RF ever claimed being Clayface, he's counterclaiming the name now. He was talking about the implications of him asking Mazre if they didn't have fake names in the scum thread, obviously because he used his name, if he's telling the truth.

 

[Sorian]

Flush is Clayface.

And you know this because?

 

[Fat4all]

Flush is Clayface.

Are you 100% certain?

 

[Verelios]

That's a possibility...but it's pretty insane to thunder dome a situation like this. He'd have had to start planning since the day started to throw away his life today or tomorrow.