• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

AusPoliGAF |OT| Boats? What Boats?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Shaneus

Member
Both men and women can have "fat traps". Just look at Latham.

It's hardly a sexist comment. Has he had a history of saying sexist things before?
 

Dead Man

Member
You said you didn't want to downplay this, but to me downplaying this is exactly what you're doing. AFAIK I haven't been mentioned by Bolt, although even if I was how does that affect anything?



See now what is happening when the shoe is on the other foot? Accusations of reaching. Wondering why gender is being brought into the equation.
If the line is whether or not something is explicitly gendered, then here's another Hansard extract, from Julia Gillard:

Why are YOU bringing gender into the comments that were made when everyone can have a fat trap?
 

hidys

Member
Speaking of insensitive...

http://parlinfo.aph.gov.au/parlInfo...dr/3a654fac-ced2-4c1d-90c3-e3ad3511096e/0000"



Why would you say that about a female MP?

It's pretty fucked up how casual sexism like this barely goes unnoticed.

I'm amazed Warren Snowden is still in parliament I don't know why he still has per-selection.

Even so, the comparative reaction is still way off-balance. You know why I had to link to Hansard? Because this is not being reported anywhere. Absolutely anywhere.

I should've made the more apt comparisons I wanted to make, like to Tony Abbott winking or that damn menu thing that a family printed out or the meow to Penny Wong. Journalists went nuts over those.

Wait you think this is the equivalent to those?

It's certainly unprofessional and could be considered casual sexism but it isn't remotely like any of those.
 

Fredescu

Member
You said you didn't want to downplay this, but to me downplaying this is exactly what you're doing.

I don't want to suggest that I approve of the behaviour, but that does not change the fact that everything you've brought up in comparison has been worse.


AFAIK I haven't been mentioned by Bolt

Might have been a different Mike that brought it to his attention.



See now what is happening when the shoe is on the other foot? Accusations of reaching. Wondering why gender is being brought into the equation.

Hey, I think there is decent likelihood that Snowdon is misogynist, and even that his outburst in particular was misogynist and not something he would say about a man. It ranks pretty low on your list of examples of explicit misogyny though, no? If you can establish a pattern of behaviour with Snowdon in the way that is obvious to everyone about Abbott, then I'll agree with you on that point.
 

Yagharek

Member
Even so, the comparative reaction is still way off-balance. You know why I had to link to Hansard? Because this is not being reported anywhere. Absolutely anywhere.

I should've made the more apt comparisons I wanted to make, like to Tony Abbott winking or that damn menu thing that a family printed out or the meow to Penny Wong. Journalists went nuts over those.

This is an incredible over reaction.

Snowdon was rude, that's it. If we expected politicians to be polite, respectful (which we should, but we know they aren't) then it might stand out. But it isn't even on the same planet, let alone postcode, as the ones directed at Gillard, for example.
 

Yagharek

Member
What the fuck, Queensland?

more broadly, what the fuck, Australia.

Why isn't this more prominent than any other domestic security issue?

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-09-...domestic-violence-victims/6767000?section=qld

Queensland Police Commissioner Ian Stewart is looking at ways to better protect domestic violence victims after three horrific deaths and one attempted murder in just four days, allegedly at the hands of former partners and a parent.

Two women were killed on the Gold Coast this week, a six-year-old girl was allegedly murdered by her father in Brisbane's north and a woman was lucky to survive a machete attack in Wacol.

One of the Gold Coast victims, Tara Brown, 24, was killed less than a week after she sought help from police, only to be turned away.

The young mother was allegedly run off the road by her ex-partner and repeatedly bashed with a metal plate while trapped in her upturned car on Tuesday.

Her ex-partner and alleged former bikie Lionel Patea, 24, was charged with attempted murder, but that is expected to soon be upgraded to murder.
 

Fredescu

Member
Yeah, it's pretty bad. This screenshot of the Brisbane times front page did the rounds a fair bit:

COgJPciUEAAX1mV.png



Male violence is pretty bad.
 

Fredescu

Member
A daily reminder this was set up at the start of the year
http://www.theguardian.com/global/n...re-not-statistics-deaths-in-australia-in-2015
200 million cut to domestic abuse by this government, IIRC
while they awarded Rosie Batty australian of the year
never fucking forget

The Libs closed 80 of the 100 womens refuges in NSW not long after they came to power here too.

When was that taken? Recently?

Yesterday: https://twitter.com/alanvaarwerk/status/641773202381893632
 

Shaneus

Member
God, if that's the sort of shit they say when they don't see microphones in plain sight, imagine what's being said away from any cameras or microphones.
 

JC Sera

Member
how did abbott get elected again
like for a moment, did the country what a stupid backwards sexist racist fuckwit he was?
god
I hate this country so much, but the main reason I hate it is because I know it can do so so so so so much more better
 
how did abbott get elected again
like for a moment, did the country what a stupid backwards sexist racist fuckwit he was?

No, the country is full of backwards, sexist, (racist and homophobic just to give you a couple more for free) fuckwits.

Abbott is exactly what the country voted for and what it deserves.
 

jambo

Member
how did abbott get elected again
like for a moment, did the country what a stupid backwards sexist racist fuckwit he was?
god
I hate this country so much, but the main reason I hate it is because I know it can do so so so so so much more better

I think a whole bunch of reactionary idiots wanted to vote out "Juliar" and didn't think about the consequences.
 

Arksy

Member
Given what I know now and given everything that's happened, I'd still have voted the same way I did back in 2013.

*Braces himself*
 

darkace

Banned
how did abbott get elected again
like for a moment, did the country what a stupid backwards sexist racist fuckwit he was?
god
I hate this country so much, but the main reason I hate it is because I know it can do so so so so so much more better

As much as I hate him, Abbott was a great opposition leader (helped along hugely by a lazy and pathetic media). It's just that he's utterly failed to transfer that to being a Prime Minister, and even the almost explicit backing by our major media organisations are now failing to cover up his gaping shortcomings.

I think Bill Shorten said it best when he referred to him as the 'Opposition Leader-in-exile'.

RE: Peter Dutton. I honestly can't believe that those words came out of his mouth.

Like I'm fairly sure I heard those words come out of a Captain Planet villain when I was a kid, and now we have him saying them.
 

D.Lo

Member
Everybody knew they'd be pricks.

Nobody thought they'd be this incompetent.

Howard's Government were a bunch of pricks, but I guess they had Keating's booming economy to ride on so never had to make hard decisions.
 

hidys

Member
As much as I hate him, Abbott was a great opposition leader (helped along hugely by a lazy and pathetic media). It's just that he's utterly failed to transfer that to being a Prime Minister, and even the almost explicit backing by our major media organisations are now failing to cover up his gaping shortcomings.

I think Bill Shorten said it best when he referred to him as the 'Opposition Leader-in-exile'.

Let's be fair here Labor's leadership merry go round and constant destabilization from certain people within completely cannibalized them.

I just hope future Labor government can learn what went wrong with that government so that it doesn't happen again.

Everybody knew they'd be pricks.

Nobody thought they'd be this incompetent.

Howard's Government were a bunch of pricks, but I guess they had Keating's booming economy to ride on so never had to make hard decisions.

I wouldn't exactly call a mining boom Keating doing but he was definitely a pretty awesome treasurer.

Given what I know now and given everything that's happened, I'd still have voted the same way I did back in 2013.

*Braces himself*

Your very brave decision has ensured that Australia will never again be ravaged by the threat of boats.

Thank you and God bless.
 

D.Lo

Member
I wouldn't exactly call a mining boom Keating doing but he was definitely a pretty awesome treasurer.
They had a booming economy before the mining boom.

well
at this point I'd rather turnball takeover > shorten
so I can't 100% blame you for that sentiment
I'd almost agree with that

Shorten is a visionless, poor performing career politician with nothing to offer Australia. He's a pathetic debater, poor public speaker, shows no spine, has no principles (stabbed both Labor PMs) and is a massive drag on Labor.

Labor overall would be much better than the largely talent-vacuum coalition, but with Sharten it's kind of a 'shit I have to vote that pathetic muppet into power' instead of feeling like an actual positive.
 

darkace

Banned
Let's be fair here Labor's leadership merry go round and constant destabilization from certain people within completely cannibalized them.

Absolutely, but it was Abbott who really kicked off the leadershit after he helped in bringing Rudds' polls back to Earth.
 

JC Sera

Member
the only time shorten has ever shown anything close to character and a spine is that pub video, which felt like an engineered stunt in hopes of viral spread, almost as to copy the success of gillard's sexism speech

also I just like turnball better, him and the liberal back benchers that tried to get the marriage bill through are the redeeming/saving grace of the liberal party in my eyes

my point was arksy's sentiment is not 100% ungrounded
it aint sensible
but I could potentially see where he was coming from
 

darkace

Banned
Turnbull is responsible for gutting the NBN, which would have been the greatest government infrastructure program ever in Australia, with hugely positive effects for the country for decades to come.

All so he could allow Foxtel to have a few more years without real competition. And it's not like he doesn't understand what FTTP would have done for Australia, as I suspect is the case with most of the Liberal Party dinosaurs; he has his own money invested in FTTP in France.

The man is a fucking traitor.
 
Turnbull, as nice as he is, would ultimately be constrained by the hardline right-wing of the Coalition in so many ways. That, and he crippled the NBN, though I imagine it's partly due to him being forced to toe the line.

Turnbull being at the helm isn't gonna do much if the rest of the party is a bunch of incompetent wankers. Shorten may be something of a fop, but at least he's got a much better team overall behind him. At least Labor actually have policies to take to an election, and there's other stuff that's been practically stated that Labor will do such as grandfathering negative gearing.

But, yeah, the whole neoliberal "debt is bad mkay" dogma is infuriating. Howard and Costello, in hindsight, were probably the most fiscally irresponsible PM and treasurer duo in Australian history.
 

Dryk

Member
Turnbull, as nice as he is, would ultimately be constrained by the hardline right-wing of the Coalition in so many ways. That, and he crippled the NBN, though I imagine it's partly due to him being forced to toe the line.
I mean the last time Turnbull tried to break ranks we ended up with Abbott
 

Yagharek

Member
Turnbull is responsible for gutting the NBN, which would have been the greatest government infrastructure program ever in Australia, with hugely positive effects for the country for decades to come.

All so he could allow Foxtel to have a few more years without real competition. And it's not like he doesn't understand what FTTP would have done for Australia, as I suspect is the case with most of the Liberal Party dinosaurs; he has his own money invested in FTTP in France.

The man is a fucking traitor.

The Infrastructure* Prime Minister
 

JC Sera

Member
Wtf is wrong with Mackay
I know two people who came from there that said its an absolute shit hole
and then theres the whole fucking rapist police

also sorry about my turnbull comments I forgot about the whole NBN thing, ugh
 

D.Lo

Member
But, yeah, the whole neoliberal "debt is bad mkay" dogma is infuriating. Howard and Costello, in hindsight, were probably the most fiscally irresponsible PM and treasurer duo in Australian history.
We had an economic boom, followed by a mining boom, combined with selling (in today's dollars) $200m+ in government assets, and yet now the country and government are in massive debt. Labor spent just the last few bucks in the bank to avoid a recession during the GFC (and Rudd tried to save a little cash with the mining and carbon taxes, but we all know how that went).

Howard and Costello were like irresponsible lottery winners who got drunk and kept spending even while the winnings were drying up.
 

Yagharek

Member
A traditional owner of Cape York, Gerhardt Pearson, has also criticised Mr Dutton's comment.

"We are constantly burdened with the view espoused by the likes of Dutton; it's one of soft bigotry and low expectations, and it continues to dominate policy responses," he said in a statement.

"Dutton's joke using this tired old stereotype reminds me of how white superintendents ran our lives — dressed in their safari jackets and white helmets, pipe in their mouths, hands in their pockets — and how they would look down at my hard-working grandfather, mother or brother, as if they were his slaves."

Aboriginal Labor senator Nova Peris interpreted the comment as a sign "Tony Abbott and the Liberals don't take north Australia very seriously".

The Prime Minister has recently visited Cape York as part of his week in remote Indigenous communities.

Senator Peris said the references to "Cape York time" and "water lapping at your door" were disrespectful and made "a mockery of their [the Government's] commitment to north Australia".

http://mobile.abc.net.au/news/2015-...may-have-killed-civilians-report-says/6748230

gerhardt-statement-data.jpg


Dutton is a candidate for worst politician in australia. Tough field though.
 

darkace

Banned
Wtf is wrong with Mackay
I know two people who came from there that said its an absolute shit hole
and then theres the whole fucking rapist police

also sorry about my turnbull comments I forgot about the whole NBN thing, ugh

I have quite a few family members in Mackay, nice enough people, vote almost straight Labor, and agree with many of their policies in governance (which is quite surprising considering they work in a very highly specialised, very high paying mining field), they just have real problems with foreigners.

Their views (at least on immigrants, they're considered practically socialists by their friends) are symptomatic of many who live in the city. George Christensen, while slightly more extreme, really isn't that far off your average voter in his electorate.

I think that there was a map showing the viewpoints of voters in their electorates on a whole range of issues. North Queensland is far and away the most xenophobic area in Australia.
 

Yagharek

Member
I have quite a few family members in Mackay, nice enough people, vote almost straight Labor, and agree with many of their policies in governance (which is quite surprising considering they work in a very highly specialised, very high paying mining field), they just have real problems with foreigners.

Their views (at least on immigrants, they're considered practically socialists by their friends) are symptomatic of many who live in the city. George Christensen, while slightly more extreme, really isn't that far off your average voter in his electorate.

I think that there was a map showing the viewpoints of voters in their electorates on a whole range of issues. North Queensland is far and away the most xenophobic area in Australia.

How many fish and chip shops per capita are there in Mackay? How many are run by redheads?
 

Yagharek

Member
Well I guess there'll always be people against equality, science, freedoms and good management.

To be fair, the last labor government had descended into farce after multiple rudd challenges. An Abbott government is a high price to pay, but if it produces a more settled, responsible labor government that can win in 2016 and keep the neocons out for a decade or more, it might be a necessary evil.

Australia needs to see how bad an ideological, anti science demagogue can be in order to make a sensible choice next time.

Don't get me wrong: if you voted for Abbott you're a fucking moron, but it might not be all bad if people pay attention.
 
So Barnaby Joyce is saying new coal project aren't economically viable.

I mean the last time Turnbull tried to break ranks we ended up with Abbott
Exactly. Turnbull can't risk taking any substantive action on anything remotely moderate or progressive without a right-wing revolt.

We had an economic boom, followed by a mining boom, combined with selling (in today's dollars) $200m+ in government assets, and yet now the country and government are in massive debt. Labor spent just the last few bucks in the bank to avoid a recession during the GFC (and Rudd tried to save a little cash with the mining and carbon taxes, but we all know how that went).

Howard and Costello were like irresponsible lottery winners who got drunk and kept spending even while the winnings were drying up.

Yeeeeeeeep. Then again, I guess the libs aren't exactly fans of Keynes.
 

munchie64

Member
To be fair, the last labor government had descended into farce after multiple rudd challenges. An Abbott government is a high price to pay, but if it produces a more settled, responsible labor government that can win in 2016 and keep the neocons out for a decade or more, it might be a necessary evil.

Australia needs to see how bad an ideological, anti science demagogue can be in order to make a sensible choice next time.

Don't get me wrong: if you voted for Abbott you're a fucking moron, but it might not be all bad if people pay attention.
Yeah you're right. I've been reading some detention centre stuff and probably over reacted.
I wouldn't have liked another Labour government if one had got in way back then.
 

Yagharek

Member
Someone has to be against all that stuff. If not me, then who? :S

Not baiting, serious question. Feel free to ignore.

Why did you vote LNP? Aside from being a member, what was your reasoning? Was it a vote against Labor, or a vote in favour of specific LNP policy?

Happy to answer reciprocal questions (I voted Greens upper and lower)
 

Arksy

Member
As always, happy to answer.

I definitely believe in a small government classical liberal philosophy of society, which is why I joined the party in the first place, believing them to be the closest political party that aligns to my beliefs.

That aside, there were a few hot button issues for me.

- Promise to repeal the carbon tax. This was the biggest issue for me. I've debated why I didn't like it a bunch of times here already in greater detail.

- Promise to repeal 18C of the Racial Discrimination Act. The LNP promised to repeal it I was happy aligning with a party that agreed with me on free speech. This was obviously dumped, but I couldn't know this at the time I voted for them.

- Plain-packaging. Nanny state policy that I disagree with, especially because it co-incided with a huge tax increase which is incredibly regressive.

- Anti-discrimination bill (dumped) - I know it was dumped but I thought it went too far on curbing political speech. Figured it proved the kind of philosophy the ALP had which made me rail against them even more.

- The ALP was chaotic and figured the change in government would at least bring some sense of stability. Happy to admit that the current government is also fairly chaotic, so I'm mostly wrong here.

- Worth noting that immigration didn't play at all into my vote. I didn't really think the boats were that much of an issue, but others obviously did.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom