You just answered my question on the previous page to the T with this post. I am currently sitting between an M2 in LBB and a Cayman S in Miami Blue. I've yet to have a chance to drive the M2, though, as no dealers around me have one sitting on the lot.
I'm thinking it's gonna be the Cayman S, and your post helps push me in that direction.
Oh! Well happy to help then.
As Evo said if you don't need the extra back seats (which only small kids could use, maybe a single adult kinda positioned sideways for a short trip, or also used as extra cargo space) then it's no contest.
However, just a fair bit of warning to you... Price wise at $66k the 718 Cayman S
starts at $4k more than a fully optioned out M2 and to be honest Porsche is king of the option & packages. So you'd probably be looking at another $10k-$15k in options if you really wanted the car you were looking for. And if you buy one directly off the lot it'd be hard to find a base Cayman S (especially the S) with no options as dealers love to tack those on (it's where Porsche makes their money). So ya... Let's say $75k-$80k vs $51k-$62k. That's a pretty big gulf, but maybe you're simply cross shopping regardless of price! If you can afford it, get it!
But if price is more of an issue, then I think you're better off comparing apples-to-apples with the base 718 Cayman (with
some options) vs the fully- loaded M2. Or get a slightly used 981 Cayman S (which could go down in price a lot if people dig the 718, or hold value really well being the last NA Cayman... too early to tell!)
But Caymans are awesome. I bought one cross shopping a lot of cars, and it won out because they are so good for their price range. Mid-engine sports cars are like heroine.
Honestly, the M2 is a canyon-focused 2 series decked out with a spiffy new color with some more aggressive body work and some stick on carbon fiber interior bits. It's cool. It's fun, but if you can afford it get the Cayman.
Also the Cayman looks so darn good lol.
The dealer I was at had a couple of i8's on the floor, bunch of M6 GC's with competition packages, the only M2 for miles around, M4's, M5's, yada yada. Anyway as I drove away 3 salesmen walked up to me during a busy weekend day to drool over the car and complement the exhaust (which is freaking amazing, destroys the M2's exhaust, which again wasn't bad at all).
So ya... get a Cayman!
That blue looks really good on the new 718. Get the sports exhaust. It's bonkers.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ToZyuGlQBM vs M2 exhaust
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3AcBWuNikfI
That's a picture of mah hawtness vs an M2.
Hey, long time no see! Welcome back.
The M2 has been really intriguing me lately. I would love to take one for a spin. Thinking about picking one up as a daily. I'd get it in manual with that same blue color.
How do you think it would compliment the GT4 as a second vehicle? Worth it or go for something more practical?
Thanks! It has been awhile.
And of course you're thinking of dailying an M2... because if I was, you were! haha Someday we'll disagree on a vehicle we both like. Maybe.(Probably not).
Anyway, the GT4 is (of course) way more track focused than my car, so I'll just talk from my GTS perspective.
I felt like the M2 was far too similar to own as a second car. But when I hopped back into my car, the M2 smiles I had quickly drifted away as literally everything in that car was a downgrade to the Cayman.
So, personally, if I had a GT4 and wanted a DD I'd probably look for something that changes things up more than a worse version of my weekend/track car, ya know? The M2 is really trying to be an 1M for the masses (but it looks better and is better). I wouldn't go so far as to say "get something practical." I'd just say get something different. For me I think I'd
still want something fast, but that also offers a more plush experience. Doesn't have to have 4 doors, but I think it does need good functional back seats.
Didn't you used to have like an '08 C63?? I feel like you did.
Anyway in the $60k range I'd probably look into something used to get more bang for my buck. Maybe like a 2013/2014 RS5 (I have a soft spot for that car, so it might just be me). It's easy on the eyes, sporty, fast and fun, but also with plenty of comfort and it can carry 4 adult passengers. Now if the RS5 was your only car and you wanted a dual purpose DD & canyon carver? Then no, this isn't the bleeding knife-edge precision you'd want. But because you already have one of the best scalpels on the planet anything resembling it (unless you go upward) is a downgraded copy and will probably just leave you feeling frustrated. And since the M2 was a downgrade from a GTS, it'll be even more amplified to you.
Other $60k cars? Used Lexus RC-F, it's a track porker, but could be a fun road warrior. It's got a lot of fun japanese electronics. It's kind of a baby LFA. But worse on the track, but again who cares? You should check it out.
Obviously a '14 C63 AMG.
Or! A fun idea might be to keep it in the Porsche family and get a Macan S. Have you driven one? I have and it is literally the most fun driving SUV ever! It's an SUV that actually drives like a sports car. No hyperbole. It's an engineering marvel. I'd get one, but the wife doesn't want a 5 seater SUV, she wants 7 seater, so it's out. Seriously though... Test one! GT4 + Macan S? Pretty sick combo lol. (Or pay a lot more and get a Macan GTS).
I'd also offer up a used M4, but you know I hate the M4, having lived with it for a week.