• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Batman [Mafia] |OT| The mafia game Gafia deserves , but not the one it needs

SkyOdin

Member
Oh! I see, never mind then. I'm not used to always reading one's entire post if I'm directly quoted. Since I pretty much always have this thread open, I'll go for what appears to directly be referring to me, and then I'll overlook the rest later.

Sorry about that, SkyOdin, though you could probably see my confusion.

It's alright. Sorry if my post was confusing to read.
 

Sorian

Banned
It would simply be bad play for me to just go along with these statements.

Furthermore, these sorts of posts give the posters in question (Karkador and El topo, to be clear) an excuse to not address the criticism themselves. If they feel that other people are supporting them, it takes away any pressure I can put on them. At the start of this Day phase, people pointed out how I made an error by taking the pressure off my vote too readily with my statement. This is the same sort of thing, just with a different mechanism.

You aren't wrong at all. You just have to remember that your opinion and vote are your power. I may be defending someone because I find them to be town so far but that doesn't mean you can't keep attacking them. One person jumping to another person's aid isn't the end of the world for your attack, it just means you have more convincing to do. I could be right or wrong when it comes to my read on a person but either way, my reads and my acting on them let me read other people as well depending on how they act and respond.
 

SkyOdin

Member
I shouldn't bring up previous games too much, but this line of thinking was exactly the one I had when I started as a newbie and people were telling me a certain player—who acted very peculiarly—was "always like that." As someone who doesn't have knowledge of how the players previously played, you should be wary about habits you think are alarming. But, as someone who is familiar with that particular player, I do know that this is how they always behave, even when they are Town, so it's not a particularly compelling point to me (or others who also know this).

I'll keep that in mind. I guess that is the nature of this game that everyone will have different ideas of what makes a compelling argument. As far as I can tell, my only solution is to keep making arguments. If they stick, they stick. If not, then that's fine. At least this will keep the discussion moving and help me figure things out.
 

Flame_AC

Member
As I detailed earlier today, I think, (I can find the post if you really want, I think it was my big "reads list" post), there is a scenario where Mazre is an important town PR that is acting selfishly purposely to stay alive and unhindered. This is all WIFOM for scum so I really don't mind talking about it openly. Do you not worry that he is a doctor for example that did this hoping to brush away night kills?

I knew I left something out of my post, I even made a mental note about that post you made. I get how you could say that a strong PR claiming ordinary, and very early on, will probably mean that scum will avoid them. However, there's lingering doubt that I'm going to have, much like if someone were to claim miller. (Does anyone want to do that by the way? I'd love to have an easy target for the lynch today.) Sure, they could be a PR, but they could also be scum hoping people use the line of reasoning you are right now. Mazre's claim puts them in the town spotlight, but not enough to usually get lynched, that's good for scum. Anyone who claims is worth an eventual lynch, rapidly, preferably. The only reason not to lynch a claim is if they have demonstrable proof. Mazre, if they are a PR, should have just kept his head down and banked on a 1/15 chance that he gets killed tonight.

Basically. He could also be scum and your reasoning would clear him, which I don't think is a good idea. Besides, if we're wrong, then it's just an ordinary townie that we're losing.
 

Sorian

Banned
I knew I left something out of my post, I even made a mental note about that post you made. I get how you could say that a strong PR claiming ordinary, and very early on, will probably mean that scum will avoid them. However, there's lingering doubt that I'm going to have, much like if someone were to claim miller. (Does anyone want to do that by the way? I'd love to have an easy target for the lynch today.) Sure, they could be a PR, but they could also be scum hoping people use the line of reasoning you are right now. Mazre's claim puts them in the town spotlight, but not enough to usually get lynched, that's good for scum. Anyone who claims is worth an eventual lynch, rapidly, preferably. The only reason not to lynch a claim is if they have demonstrable proof. Mazre, if they are a PR, should have just kept his head down and banked on a 1/15 chance that he gets killed tonight.

Basically. He could also be scum and your reasoning would clear him, which I don't think is a good idea. Besides, if we're wrong, then it's just an ordinary townie that we're losing.

As good an explanation as I could expect. I agree with you for the most part. It's just not the lynch I'd want to do day 1. There is the small doubt that this bad play was made from a good place but more than that I don't like pursuing the easier lynches on day 1. As time goes on, yeah, we do need to toy with the idea of odd gameplay that has gone on too long but day 1, I would rather dog others and see how they react. For me right now, that's you and Coppa. You've actually been fairly eloquent since the post where I called you out which is cooling me off a bit on you.
 

Flame_AC

Member
As good an explanation as I could expect. I agree with you for the most part. It's just not the lynch I'd want to do day 1. There is the small doubt that this bad play was made from a good place but more than that I don't like pursuing the easier lynches on day 1. As time goes on, yeah, we do need to toy with the idea of odd gameplay that has gone on too long but day 1, I would rather dog others and see how they react. For me right now, that's you and Coppa. You've actually been fairly eloquent since the post where I called you out which is cooling me off a bit on you.

I blame my eloquence on the fact that I'm typing a research paper right now and this game is my distraction.

I disagree with you in that we should delay Mazre. I think that, for example, on Day 2 or 3, we are going to be more involved in scum hunting and so who is really want to go back and lynch someone who claimed ordinary when we could be flipping based on night actions and new developments. Would you agree that town PR's are unlikely to target Mazre now? After all, if he's ordinary no watcher/tracker cares about him, a doctor has no reason to protect, and a cop has bigger fish to fry. All that's going to happen is he coasts by because we are more involved with more interesting targets. I'm not saying we all rush to a Mazre lynch, but I certainly think that he is someone we should gravitate towards barring some sort of revelation.
 

SkyOdin

Member
As I've said earlier, I'm back and forth on lynching Mazre. The normal GCPD claim is pretty scummy, and is probably a net negative for the good guys. However, I doubt that Mazre is actually a villain. I just can't imagine that a villain would draw so much unnecessary attention to himself so quickly. I mean, stupid moves like that probably happen, but I don't really like the idea of lynching someone who logic dictates is likely not scum.

However, I also don't like the idea of giving Mazre a pass. I am also highly skeptical of a vanilla townie claim. So I suggest we pay very close attention to the rest of Mazre's behavior in addition to his claim, and judge him by that, keeping in mind his big anti-town role claim.
 

Sorian

Banned
I disagree with you in that we should delay Mazre. I think that, for example, on Day 2 or 3, we are going to be more involved in scum hunting and so who is really want to go back and lynch someone who claimed ordinary when we could be flipping based on night actions and new developments. Would you agree that town PR's are unlikely to target Mazre now? After all, if he's ordinary no watcher/tracker cares about him, a doctor has no reason to protect, and a cop has bigger fish to fry. All that's going to happen is he coasts by because we are more involved with more interesting targets. I'm not saying we all rush to a Mazre lynch, but I certainly think that he is someone we should gravitate towards barring some sort of revelation.

Ordinary is a funny claim, it boxes you in very harshly if you are lying. Any mafia game with PRs has a motion detector of some sort, whether it be a basic actual motion detector or something more specific like a watcher or tracker. If Mazre is lying about his claim this early, it's an uphill battle of not getting noticed from here on out. While you are right that a doctor has no reason to protect, I wouldn't write off a cop checking things out. There are a lot of great ways to play cop and a few of those strategies could point towards Mazre in the coming days. Let's not discount the presence of a vigilante or SK trying to get chummy with town who would blend in best by taking out our secondary lynch targets.

We agree though that a Mazre lynch is better than a shot in the dark though and if nothing really happens between now and day end then yeah, Mazre is the smart/safe lynch choice. I'd be surprised if this is the only defining quality of day 1 though based on how gafia games usually go and based on the general quietness that a sub set of players have been sitting in.
 

Flame_AC

Member
I just can't imagine that a villain would draw so much unnecessary attention to himself so quickly. I mean, stupid moves like that probably happen, but I don't really like the idea of lynching someone who logic dictates is likely not scum.

I don't know about that. I think one need only look at Love Boat for example and see that talented scum is not afraid to get right in the spotlight.

I wouldn't write off a cop checking things out. There are a lot of great ways to play cop and a few of those strategies could point towards Mazre in the coming days. Let's not discount the presence of a vigilante or SK trying to get chummy with town who would blend in best by taking out our secondary lynch targets.

Personally, I wouldn't check a claim like Mazre's, at least not quickly. As a cop in the early phases, I would much rather make progress definitively flipping people as town or scum which would then give the cop more credibility. I wouldn't want to check Mazre and then when it's time to post my findings to gain trust, I just say "Oh. Well Mazre's town." His claim doesn't help anyone besides himself or scum.

Also, I think that's a dangerous assumption to make that there is a tracker/watcher/etc. There isn't any guarantee that town has much going for it. Besides, he could be a ninja (would fit someone in the Batman mythos), and then having a tracker doesn't even help us.
 

Sorian

Banned
Personally, I wouldn't check a claim like Mazre's, at least not quickly. As a cop in the early phases, I would much rather make progress definitively flipping people as town or scum which would then give the cop more credibility. I wouldn't want to check Mazre and then when it's time to post my findings to gain trust, I just say "Oh. Well Mazre's town." His claim doesn't help anyone besides himself or scum.

Also, I think that's a dangerous assumption to make that there is a tracker/watcher/etc. There isn't any guarantee that town has much going for it. Besides, he could be a ninja (would fit someone in the Batman mythos), and then having a tracker doesn't even help us.

A cop clearing anybody is a boon, it doesn't matter how scummy the person was acting before the clear.

As for the tracker/watcher/voyeur (which would be useless in this specific example)/motion detector, I'm speaking on that from the place of building a game, it's rare not to include something along those lines because they tend to be easier to balance as they aren't as cut and dry as an alignment/role/name cop. But you are right that it would be a good play from a ninja, I hadn't considered that and claiming ordinary when you are really a ninja has few weaknesses.
 

Flame_AC

Member
A cop clearing anybody is a boon, it doesn't matter how scummy the person was acting before the clear.

I agree, but I would rather have more informative information such as your alignment or perhaps Xam/Kark. Mazre is more of a known quantity, at least we know what we're dealing with his potential claim.
 
3/4ths of the last page was cluttered with batcomputer/prep time nonsense. Something tells me mafia will be glad to see him live.
Something. But what?

VOTE: Karkador

insert coy one-liner here
Most are accepting karkador as town.
Batcomputer is starting to grow on me oddly enough.
Town Mazre was straightforward and aggressive. Neutral Mazre was silent but deadly. Who is this?

That's what I get for paying half attention whilst playing SFV. I meant Sorian.

I'm also wary of you, weemadarthur, for the same reason but to a greater extent because they are superficial means to appear helpful.

So your go-to is asking bad questions that aren't actually founded on reality, then.
Meanness. Plausible mafia.
 

Sorian

Banned
One of the games I read. Maybe night vale or woof, they all started blending together. He controlled conversation a lot.

I only question it because I don't think I've seen town Mazre in a long time. He was scum in night vale and I don't think he was involved in woof since that ran parallel with night vale (he could have been a rep and I'm hassling you for nothing, I didn't pay as much attention to the first half of woof as I could have).
 
I only question it because I don't think I've seen town Mazre in a long time. He was scum in night vale and I don't think he was involved in woof since that ran parallel with night vale (he could have been a rep and I'm hassling you for nothing, I didn't pay as much attention to the first half of woof as I could have).

I can't be certain which old game. But I kept looking at the posts and thinking "who is this? Mazre?!" Can't be election or season one or cthulu cause I didn't read those.
 

FluxWaveZ

Member
I guess I could go back and count them. It struck me as a majority. Do I take this to mean you think kark is scummy?

Like I said before, his alignment is uncertain and there is absolutely nothing that points to him being more town than not. Should I take what you're saying to mean you think he's town?
 

Sorian

Banned
Like I said before, his alignment is uncertain and there is absolutely nothing that points to him being more town than not. Should I take what you're saying to mean you think he's town?

I see you're still working on absolutes instead of adding a little bit of emotion/feeling to the mix. That isn't going to help us if you are town. Definitive proof of someone being town or scum is rarely going to come.
 
Like I said before, his alignment is uncertain and there is absolutely nothing that points to him being more town than not. Should I take what you're saying to mean you think he's town?

No, it means camjo is showing an opinion that isn't mob created.

My notes were a little cryptic because I meant to post that to myself in my private thread. I've been talking to myself a lot, keeping track of posts I think are noteworthy. Generally I would expand on my reasoning before posting here in public. You get a glimpse into why I didn't share my notes with people in college. They'd have failed due to all the missing segues.
 

FluxWaveZ

Member
I see you're still working on absolutes instead of adding a little bit of emotion/feeling to the mix. That isn't going to help us if you are town. Definitive proof of someone being town or scum is rarely going to come.

Obviously, but it's not even about absolutes. There's nothing there. There's bat-computer stupidity, pithy one-liners, general D1 philosophy expounding and attempts to make it seem like he has a power role he probably doesn't. I can't suss out any kind of opinion on alignment from this stuff. Town being unorthodox or mafia being unorthodox? No idea.

My notes were a little cryptic because I meant to post that to myself in my private thread. I've been talking to myself a lot, keeping track of posts I think are noteworthy. Generally I would expand on my reasoning before posting here in public.

...
 

If you want one, too, ask retro. A couple of us asked for our own boards over in the main thread after the main season ended.

Or maybe you're suggesting that I'm posting in the mafia chat, to my mafia buddies, that I think you behave like mafia. .... Nah, you're smarter than that.
 

FluxWaveZ

Member
If you want one, too, ask retro. A couple of us asked for our own boards over in the main thread after the main season ended.

Or maybe you're suggesting that I'm posting in the mafia chat, to my mafia buddies, that I think you behave like mafia. .... Nah, you're smarter than that.

The latter is why I think that was a crazy comment to make, but we can actually get our own private threads on Gafia now for note purposes? Huh, I had no idea, the comment makes sense in that context.
 

Camjo-Z

Member
We agree though that a Mazre lynch is better than a shot in the dark though and if nothing really happens between now and day end then yeah, Mazre is the smart/safe lynch choice.

Nobody has bothered defending him, which suggests to me that nobody particularly cares if he dies. Feels like a waste of time to be angling for him.

Personally, I'm more wary of the people who are way too eager to be leading the game. You, weemadarthur, SkyOdin. Lots of pokes, lots of little concerns, lots of dominos being set up for later. I'm also not a fan of the people posting just enough to look active but not really doing much at all, but it'd be premature to go after them D1. We'll see if they're still doing it D2 when there are actual things to talk about.
 

Flame_AC

Member
Nobody has bothered defending him, which suggests to me that nobody particularly cares if he dies. Feels like a waste of time to be angling for him.

That, or they know that we're just now halfway through Day 1 and votes are still very fluid for a lot of people. People rushing around to distract away from Mazre would look extremely suspicious right now, don't you think?
 

Camjo-Z

Member
That, or they know that we're just now halfway through Day 1 and votes are still very fluid for a lot of people. People rushing around to distract away from Mazre would look extremely suspicious right now, don't you think?

It's going to look even more fishy when they do it right before he dies.
 

Sorian

Banned
The latter is why I think that was a crazy comment to make, but we can actually get our own private threads on Gafia now for note purposes? Huh, I had no idea, the comment makes sense in that context.

I can confirm that you can have your own private board on Gafia. I've had one since season 4 though it's gone completely unused ever since Night Vale ended.

Nobody has bothered defending him, which suggests to me that nobody particularly cares if he dies. Feels like a waste of time to be angling for him.

Personally, I'm more wary of the people who are way too eager to be leading the game. You, weemadarthur, SkyOdin. Lots of pokes, lots of little concerns, lots of dominos being set up for later. I'm also not a fan of the people posting just enough to look active but not really doing much at all, but it'd be premature to go after them D1. We'll see if they're still doing it D2 when there are actual things to talk about.

My thought on the first half of this is the same as Flame's post below. Mazre is leading the race right now and people are talking about him but with the volatile nature that day 1 can take, your just as likely to get lynched as he is. Scum that can keep their cool know that they have no reason to worry about much yet if a teammate is getting votes.

As for the second half of your post. So, what's your intention for today then? You have a vote on Kark if I recall right? Would he fall into the category of someone eager to lead the game?

That, or they know that we're just now halfway through Day 1 and votes are still very fluid for a lot of people. People rushing around to distract away from Mazre would look extremely suspicious right now, don't you think?

Fake Edit: (This whole section is hypothetical on if Mazre were scum) Because I saw your new post. It would be fishy if they came in to support him last minute, sure, but you have to think of every possibility though. Mazre drew attention to himself. With multiple teammates, who is to say that there isn't one that jumped on an early bus just in case with the dual motivation of swinging a vote later on in the day? It's doubtful we will actually hit majority today and you can look at the cluster that was the ending of WWE day 1 to know that one vote can make the difference. In that scenario, no real defense is required, just a switched vote because "I thought this other person was more likely to be scum."
 

Karkador

Banned
Robin, can you hear me? What are you doing right now?

Robin said:
Hey, I didn't know you could....nevermind; what's up? I'm currently watching for some suspicious activity around Gotham and-

Forget that, Robin. I need you to write some things down for me.

Robin said:
Uh, is Alfred busy right now? Where are you, anyway? These guys look pretty shady...

It's the #scumreads, Robin. Just write this down:

-

Camjo-Z [m] - Fucks around for a good while during the early part of the Day (a silly fakeclaim, jokey speculation, declares that "Day 1 can plant a large smooch directly on my ass" when questioned, gives dodgy responses to questions. Speculates I'm Batman (presumably a Townie) by putting in enough effort to Batmanify my Rover avatar. Despite that, gives me some crap for my behavior. Seems like a useless dork today. Is not on Batcomputer's scumlist, is part of the 12/18. I give him 3/5 Town stars. Voted on by Karu.


Karu [m] - Relatively low activity. Drive-by votes on Camjo. Camjo responds a bit annoyed, throwing it back to him after weemad questions him. Camjo later claims "I'm not bothered by Karu's vote". Is on Batcomputer's scumlist. Is not part of the 12/18. Seems like a cautious Town in observation mode. 3.5/5 Town.


Coppanuva [m]- Relatively low activity. Doesn't seem to be positioning in any way right now. I see a person reading the thread and answering questions lobbed their way when necessary. Sounds like Town in scared/defensive/ignorant D1 mode. Not on Batcomputer's scumlist. Part of the 12/18. 4/5 Town. Voted on by Sorian.


Sorian [m] - Why am I not surprised? Most active poster in the game. Comes out with his pre-typed message at the start of the day. My fear with a player like this is that their idea of defense is offense - always be posting. Post enough, and people will accept it as reality. It's okay if he wants to spur conversation, but it's disingenuous (a bit slimy, even) to attack me for my behavior....but reap the benefits of actually giving him something to talk about. Sounds like Sorian....with an agenda. Batcomputer called him scum. Not part of the 12/18. 2/5 Town.


El topo [m] - Sounds pretty disengaged with the game, as if he's waiting for something. Seems neither invested in pushing a narrative, nor in the mood to flounder in the dark like a innocent Town. Seems so...neutral to it all. Batcomputer called him neutral scum. Part of the 12/18. 2.5/5 Town (you'll notice that's the middle). Voted on by weemadarthur.


weemadarthur - Surprisingly active for a new player. Surprisingly confident. Is it mad skills, or is it the backing from a scum team? Is being surprisingly tolerant of my habits. Bothers other players instead. It's kind of nice to not get hassled, for a change. Batcomputer did not call them scum. Part of the 12/18. Voted on by Fireblend (redacted as of this writing). 3/5 Town stars.


Fireblend [m] - Somewhat active. Went after weemad for a bit in response to weemad pushing him, and acta facetious ad frustrated about the Batcomputer, despite the Batcomputer clearing them. It's 100% objective, you know. Batcomputer did not call them scum. Part of the 12/18. 2/5 Town stars. Voted on by Sorian and weemadarthur.

-

Robin said:
Hey, uhh...are you almost done? I think I have to go..

Robin, I can't do this without you.

-

Flame_AC [m] - The "not moving my vote because of a no lynch" thing does seem sketchy and opportunistic. Leans towards 3 scum, or "could be 4 weak ones". Sounds like someone trying to mask the threat of the scum as much as possible. Voted on me hot out the gate. Going after Mazre after the Batcomputer cleared Flame-AC of all evil. Not part of the 12/18. 2.5/5 Town stars.


FluxWaveZ [m] - I really don't know right now. Semi-scarred from a past experience with you. Batcomputer did not call you scum. Not in the 12/18. ?/5 Town stars. I want to know more.


Mazre [m]- Makes bold predictions that Coppa and Flame will be lynched. Went from hating the Batcomputer, to sort of being okay with it (the Batcomputer is not okay with them). Is drawing a lot of votes from other players. Batcomputer thinks they're scum. They're in the 12/18. 3/5 Town stars. Voted on by Xamtheking and Fireblend.


Pop-o-matic [m]- Has one game-relevant post, offering some selective reads. Totally hates the Batcomputer, the method, and the madness. Coming into this game with a huge load of baggage from fuming at me for no good reason in a spectator thread in another universe. Kinda feels like his opinion hasn't interacted with that of another scum player. Batcomputer did not find scum. But it's ONE POST. Batcomputer didn't find scum. Is part of the 12/18. ?/5 Town stars. Voted on by Trigger.


Trigger [m] - Relatively low activity. Drive-by votes on Pop-o-matic. I dunno what else to say at this point. Batcomputer doesn't think they're scum. Part of the 12/18. ?/5 Town stars. Voted on by Sorian.


Xamtheking - Getting a lot of hostility from this player, despite expecting they'd be down for my brand of justice. It makes me think it's an act. It's very over the top. The Batcomputer did not find scum here. They are not part of the 12/18.

-

Robin said:
I...ran out of room on the Bat-pad. Are you done?!

The people will think it's weird if we leave anyone out, Robin. Are you sure there's no more room left?

Robin said:
I have to go. Don't stay out too late, it will worry Alfred.

-


SkyOdin [m]- He keeps poking at me to answer a question that I didn't really feel needed an answer. Sorry.


The Goddamn [m] - Don't know


TL21xx [m] - Don't know


Ty4on [m] - Don't know



--


Batcomputer said:
Greetings. This is the Batcomputer. Analysis complete. Beep.

Batcomputer's Most Wanted

Mazre [m] - Got voted on by Xam and Fireblend
Karu [m] - Nobody votes for them, Camjo antagonizes
SkyOdin [m] - Nobody votes for them. Votes Sorian.
Sorian [m] - SkyOdin votes for them. Votes on Fireblend, Trigger, thegoddamn, coppanuva


The players who were not voted on (the 6/18):

xamtheking - aggressive; votes on popular target mazre
ty4on - *shrug*
fluxwavez - *shrug*
karu - Votes on Camjo
SkyOdin - Votes on Sorian
flame_ac - Votes Karkador

Batcomputer said:
Beep beep
 

FluxWaveZ

Member
All this talk about Mazre's claim... Mazre, I'd like to actually hear it from you. Why did you claimed the way you did? Was it really to be quirky and to proclaim "to hell with conventional wisdom," or did you have a more meaningful reason than that?
 

Flame_AC

Member
Still going through your post Kark, but just so you know, I moved my vote away from you and onto Mazre last page I think.
 

nin1000

Banned
bla_1459116000.png
 

Camjo-Z

Member
As for the second half of your post. So, what's your intention for today then? You have a vote on Kark if I recall right? Would he fall into the category of someone eager to lead the game?

My vote on Kark was snark directed at his playstyle, hence no explanation save for "insert coy one-liner here". I'll move it closer to the end of the day when I come to a final decision on who to vote.

Speculates I'm Batman (presumably a Townie) by putting in enough effort to Batmanify my Rover avatar. Seems like a useless dork today.

1. I wouldn't exactly call spending 5 minutes with the polygonal lasso tool and paint bucket "effort"

2. I KNOW YOU ARE BUT WHAT AM I???
 

SkyOdin

Member
SkyOdin [m]- He keeps poking at me to answer a question that I didn't really feel needed an answer. Sorry.

It's cool. I am probably doomed to confusion until either this game is over and you finally break kayfabe or we both end up in the dead thread, but I can live with that. This post of yours at least helps me understand your thinking a lot better, though. It's interesting, thanks.
 
CURRENT VOTE TALLY:

Mazre (4)
Xamtheking .256
Fireblend .303
TheGoddamn .390
Flame_AC .439

Pop-O-Matic (1)
Trigger .236

Camjo-Z (1)
Karu .219

Coppanuva (1)
Sorian .310

Karkador (1)
Flame_AC .128 .439
Camjo-Z .356

Sorian (1)
SkyOdin .141

El Topo (1)
weemadarthur .304

TL21xx (0)
weemadarthur .165 .304

Trigger (0)
Sorian .146 .239

Fireblend (0)
Sorian .127 .146
weemadarthur .147 .165

weemadarthur (0)
Fireblend .139 .303

TheGoddamn (0)
Sorian .239 .310

No Lynch (0)
Karkador .209 .226


No active vote for Day 1:
Coppanuva
El Topo
FluxWaveZ
Karkador (has previously voted)
Mazre
Pop-O-Matic
TL21xx
Ty4on



Day 1 ends:
bla_1459116000.png


10 votes for majority
 

Trigger

Member
UNVOTE

He's posted now so there's no point in my vote. I'm not quite excited about the prospect of a Mazre lynch. I don't think that his claim was a scum gambit at all.
 

Karu

Member
UNVOTE

He's posted now so there's no point in my vote. I'm not quite excited about the prospect of a Mazre lynch. I don't think that his claim was a scum gambit at all.
Look at this...

I'm a generic GCPD officer. (To hell with your pre-typed post Sorian, and to hell with conventional wisdom)
I predict we will end up lynching Coppanuva and that I will have 0 votes on me by days end.
Remember this guys, it'll be important when we lynch Flame_AC on day 3.
Brash, provocant, nonsensical to a degree. He's here to provoke, bored Town wanting to stir something up.
 

roytheone

Member
tumblr_mmnhtgFdv41rrkahjo4_250.gif


Please note that in the Netherlands, the clock will be moved one hour forward tonight. I have no idea how the countdown timer handles that, so don't be surprised if the day's end time suddenly changes.
 

Karu

Member
I will go now, won't be here for the remaining RL-Day and Night. I have literally no idea when or if at all I will be available tomorrow. I will try, but dunno yet.
 

Trigger

Member
Look at this...

Brash, provocant, nonsensical to a degree. He's here to provoke, bored Town wanting to stir something up.

Brash town making a bad play, but I don't see the point if he were scum. He could be a lynch bomb, but I don't see why he would thrust himself into the spotlight.
 

Sorian

Banned
Brash town making a bad play, but I don't see the point if he were scum. He could be a lynch bomb, but I don't see why he would thrust himself into the spotlight.

You both seem to agree. This would be a terrible play for a lynch bomb by the way. The mindset when you are a lynch bomb isn't to go suicide right away, you're still a scum team member so that 1:1 trade is horrible numbers-wise.
 

Trigger

Member
Yeah, I was just spitballing possibilities. I don't see it as scum play, and I think it's odd that he's the "safe" choice.
 

Sorian

Banned
Yeah, I was just spitballing possibilities. I don't see it as scum play, and I think it's odd that he's the "safe" choice.

It's a policy lynch, that's pretty much all there is to it and that's why it's safe. Could he be scum? Yeah, slight possibility but I doubt any town members on that vote expect a scum flip, they are more ok with it though because logic says it's not a bad choice because if Mazre was this brash early he may cost us the game late phase but it is lazy to just accept it right now and that's it.

I'm flying back cross country today by the way so when I board in like a half hour, I'll be out for like 5ish hours.
 

Ty4on

Member
I'm not really worried about Flame. He seems a lot more relaxed and genuine than in Love Boat and was one of my first town reads.
I don't have much of a read on Wee, but they aren't really worrying me either. They're being quite direct and seem interested in what is going on.
Mazre I dunno. I'd like him to post a bit more though.
Kark didn't make a read of me which I find a bit weird. I'm not sure what to say about the batcomputer. Beep boop son?
Sorian is for better or worse looking like Sorian.
Flux is quiet. Weirdly quiet. Not in a barely posting manner, but he isn't saying much and posting quite soft opinions. I don't know if he's just a townie taking it easier* or a scum who doesn't want attention.


*I've been much more quiet this game as well. Hard to say why, but there isn't much to go on.

Vote: FluxWaveZ
 
Top Bottom