Battle of the sheer sexiness factor: PSP vs. iPod
- Thread starter Pedigree Chum
- Start date
Deg said:
That's what I was wondering too, in the official PSP pics that Sony showed, there was no yellow bit and then they just stuck it in in the final product. It kinda sticks out and ruins it's sexiness a bit considering it's yellow and the PSP is all black.
JackFrost2012
Banned
GSG Flash said:
I dunno, I kinda like it. It's like a beauty mark on the otherwise sleek and black PSP ... yes I know it sounds like I'm trying too hard to justify but I think it adds a nice assymetrical detail. I <3 PSP
MrPing1000
Member
psp looks like an 80's throw back vcr type thingy
The Take Out Bandit
Member
I'm sorry, but your Nintendo handheld is in another castle.
Why do I get the feeling DCharlie somehow managed to get the gigantic PSP instead of the standard release model?
Deg said:No.
The way they did transparency on the face buttons seems cheap. I like the shoulders and the metalic partsbest parts IMO. The grill bit didnt need to be there(too busy). Much of the buttons could have been on the outside. The system is wider than i expected. More than even the DS! Which is big compared to GBASP as it is.
Dont like the curvature on the left and right ends, would have been nicer if it was fully flat. Screws are on the sides. Yellow bit! why?
Plastic gets smudgy presumably due to super smooth plastic.
Overall its hot for a game device. Much nicer than DS IMO although thats not why i am buying the PSP over DS. I might skip both yet.
GBASP:
The most unique looking handheld console.
The smallest. The smartest.
Will win sales war too like PSOne did
You're complaining about a "cheap" appearance, yet mention the SP? SP is a cool design, but it looks pretty cheap in person...
u_neek said:
Dunno about that, but the Japanese prefer things small. They think the iPod is big and prefer the mini or flash players, so PSP's size might not fair well with them.
Keep in mind the iPod's been around for years and still no one's come close to its interface or iconic design, not even Sony.
DCharlie
And even i am moderately surprised
i liked the ipod until all the friggen Apple fans in the office started bugging the shit out of me.
"you use a PC at home??!?!? GET A MAC, you can run all your stuff on the PC via emulation!"
".... and my games too! ha ha ha"
"yes!!! and they'll run faster on a Mac"
"... errr... okay... so how does it handle my graphics card?!"
"... in emulation! god, do you know nothing about the G4 processor?"
"... that's it ... you guys are fucking morons"
or the classic
"when i hook my ipod up to my mac, it RECOGNISES IT!!! Lets see windows do that!"
errrr.... okay.
anyways... the PSP is more sexy IMO. I also had outrageous problems with my Ipod which made me want to smash it to bits.
"you use a PC at home??!?!? GET A MAC, you can run all your stuff on the PC via emulation!"
".... and my games too! ha ha ha"
"yes!!! and they'll run faster on a Mac"
"... errr... okay... so how does it handle my graphics card?!"
"... in emulation! god, do you know nothing about the G4 processor?"
"... that's it ... you guys are fucking morons"
or the classic
"when i hook my ipod up to my mac, it RECOGNISES IT!!! Lets see windows do that!"
errrr.... okay.
anyways... the PSP is more sexy IMO. I also had outrageous problems with my Ipod which made me want to smash it to bits.
Between the PSP and the iPOD the PSP is the better looking device. However, if we were to include the iPOD Mini in this discussion that would get my vote.
Now that you mention it I wonder how the PSP will hold up image-wise. Yeah, handhelds are and will probably always be in the realm of geekdom but considering all the multimedia functions and the type of marketing that will likely accompany the PSP I wonder if the PSP will be able to overcome this image. If there's one handheld that can do it it's most likely to be the PSP.
u_neek said:
Now that you mention it I wonder how the PSP will hold up image-wise. Yeah, handhelds are and will probably always be in the realm of geekdom but considering all the multimedia functions and the type of marketing that will likely accompany the PSP I wonder if the PSP will be able to overcome this image. If there's one handheld that can do it it's most likely to be the PSP.
Doom_Bringer
Banned
PSP looks better than ipod.
JackFrost2012
Banned
Even though the PSP is long and wide, it's thin and sleek as well ... like a DVD case. The DS, despite a smaller footprint, has a lot more visual weight to it. I don't think any Japanese people will think the PSP is "too large."
JackFrost2012 said:
Yeah the DS is thick. Thinness matters quite abit. Although width isnt exactly great either with DS. DS is the biggest of the three but its not surpising i guess since it has a two screens clam shell design.
loxy said:
I am sure only the geeks are buying it
thats why its outselling everything right now.radioheadrule83
Banned
white iPod / iPod photo >>>>>> PSP / DS
iPod is just masterful design. The two tone (metallic / white fibre glass) is good to look at, and the design is functional too. The user interface doesn't protrude out towards you, and in practical terms - it's as user-friendly as you can get. PSP looks quite complicated in comparison. But then - we have to remember that iPod isn't made to play traditionally complicated video games. As for DS Vs PSP, I like both equally in visual terms I think, although I know I'm gonna scuff my PSP to bits).
iPod is just masterful design. The two tone (metallic / white fibre glass) is good to look at, and the design is functional too. The user interface doesn't protrude out towards you, and in practical terms - it's as user-friendly as you can get. PSP looks quite complicated in comparison. But then - we have to remember that iPod isn't made to play traditionally complicated video games. As for DS Vs PSP, I like both equally in visual terms I think, although I know I'm gonna scuff my PSP to bits).
The iPod could afford to get away with its beautiful design. It set out to appeal to high earning trend-setting mid-twenties types who were willing to pay a fortune for a flash MP3 player. Lets not forget that besides the touchwheel and the slick casing, the battery, screen and software on the iPod are nothing worth shouting about. You pay for the slick design rather than the tech.
The PSP incorporates a bright, huge, clear beautiful screen, PS2-comparable innards, analogue controls, optical drive and the base set of Playstation controls in its design. This is a major design hurdle when you wish to cram so much and make it look sexy. The fact that they succeeded is quite an achievement. I agree that some of the facia buttons and perhaps the grill could have been moved/removed but on the whole I think it looks very nice indeed. And besides, its all rather irrelevant when that screen gets switched on...
Just as an aside - the original PSP mockup was mooted to have iPod like controls if you remember:
The PSP incorporates a bright, huge, clear beautiful screen, PS2-comparable innards, analogue controls, optical drive and the base set of Playstation controls in its design. This is a major design hurdle when you wish to cram so much and make it look sexy. The fact that they succeeded is quite an achievement. I agree that some of the facia buttons and perhaps the grill could have been moved/removed but on the whole I think it looks very nice indeed. And besides, its all rather irrelevant when that screen gets switched on...
Just as an aside - the original PSP mockup was mooted to have iPod like controls if you remember:
worldrunover
Member
The PSP is the sexiest piece of equipment I've ever seen.
With that said, all things considered GBA SP has the best design for a handheld system there is.
With that said, all things considered GBA SP has the best design for a handheld system there is.
Red Dolphin
Member
Honestly why didn't Sony put the "analogue stick" in the primary position instead of the D-pad? It looks very uncomfortable to stretch your thumb down to use it. Otherwise you wouldn't have much of a grip on the left side of it.
As for the sexiest? I really don't know. They both look great for different reasons.
As for the sexiest? I really don't know. They both look great for different reasons.
Lord Error
Insane For Sony
Hmm, between the white iPod and the black PSP, I think I'd go with PSP, with iPod very close second. I think the visual design alone puts them both on par (with each having different pluses) but the PSP tech just pushes it ahead, when you see the screen at work, sleekness of the user interface, etc.
I agree. the quality of plastic and overal build is just not there to even be compared with PSP, Ipod or the best designed Ipaq or Clie PDAs, IMO.
evilromero
Member
Eww, the PSP has too much clutter around the border. Look at the bottom with all of the buttons just filling in space. And then if you look at the system's top it is not nearly as pretty as some would have you believe. The iPod wins by far with its beautiful simplicity. The PSP just looks too busy.
Musashi Wins!
FLAWLESS VICTOLY!
I think the IPod has better overall aesthetic design. And the DS is fugly compared to both.
But as a gamer, it's impossible to ignore that screen...and those graphics on a handheld!
PSP = flawlessvictory!
But as a gamer, it's impossible to ignore that screen...and those graphics on a handheld!
PSP = flawlessvictory!
I don't find the relative "clutter" of the PSP's front face to be a detriment to its overall look because the secondary buttons are all flush with the casing, same color as the casing and relegated to a thin strip of space below the screen which draws attention away from just about everything else. They are unobtrusive as a result, IMO.
Now, let's compare the PSP to an Acura RSX.
VS.
The RSX has clean lines as well, but is bit more cluttered - what with being an automobile and all. The RSX' lines seem to flow better though - more organised. But it probably doesn't fit in a pocket - so minus marks on its size.
VS.
The RSX has clean lines as well, but is bit more cluttered - what with being an automobile and all. The RSX' lines seem to flow better though - more organised. But it probably doesn't fit in a pocket - so minus marks on its size.
Foreign Jackass
Member
The PSP has always been ugly. It's like a woman with a pretty face, but a body cluttered with pimples all over. iPod and DS are both lots prettier than this ugly piece of shit. Although the PSP kicks the DS's ass in technical terms, we're talking bout sexiness here.
Kleegamefan
K. LEE GAIDEN
PSP>>>>>ALL
Smiles and Cries
Member
The PSP Concept OWNS ALL!
From a design point of view, it's no contest -- the iPod destroys the PSP. The interface is genius, and in terms of its form factor being adapted for its purpose, it STILL hasn't been topped by its rivals after many years. 'Nuff said.
The PSP, although attractive-looking and futuristic and all that, is cluttered and too big to fit in a pocket. It truly is a "handheld," and will be bigger still when it's put into a case to keep it safe.
And yes, I agree with whoever said that the GBA SP design is underrated.
The PSP, although attractive-looking and futuristic and all that, is cluttered and too big to fit in a pocket. It truly is a "handheld," and will be bigger still when it's put into a case to keep it safe.
And yes, I agree with whoever said that the GBA SP design is underrated.
Just in case no one understood my previous post, I think you guys are comparing apples to oranges here. The iPod is a basic mp3 player while the PSP is a fricking handheld - of course the PSP is going to have more buttons and stuff.
Still, they're both shiny, cool looking gadgets - unlike the ...
Still, they're both shiny, cool looking gadgets - unlike the ...
There's ONE WORD on the face of the iPod, small symbols are used for everything else. It's a white opaque layer that's curved and simple.
The PSP is an assault on glare and words. Way too many leds and buttons line the buttom row, along with each neading their own explanation above it. The DS doesn't. Two leds, unmarked, you know what they are.
If Sony wuld release a PSP that was less reflective and reducded the words on the front of it, it would compete, otherwise there's not a chance.
Why even bother with PSP below the screen? Put it on the back or something, like Apple. You don't need to be constantly reminded.
The PSP is an assault on glare and words. Way too many leds and buttons line the buttom row, along with each neading their own explanation above it. The DS doesn't. Two leds, unmarked, you know what they are.
If Sony wuld release a PSP that was less reflective and reducded the words on the front of it, it would compete, otherwise there's not a chance.
Why even bother with PSP below the screen? Put it on the back or something, like Apple. You don't need to be constantly reminded.
Yeah, the PSP plastic looks so odd. Fingerprints and thumbprints look like they would stay on the PSP. Also, the PSP has 3 logos on it! Sony, PSP, and then the symbol. Everything is a button... I've always liked "volume" with slider control. PSP, everything is out in the open. DS on the other hand is hidden. You got a small, classic Nintendo logo with the system closed. Then when you open it, it's got the Nintendo DS written in GB fashion at the bottom of a screen. The D-pad and buttons are mirrored... DS is just a better design. Less is more.
PSP has the best screen, but I give DS the edge in design. You can't protect that beatiful screen... =(
PSP has the best screen, but I give DS the edge in design. You can't protect that beatiful screen... =(
Pedigree Chum
Banned
dark10x said:Wow, that's pretty crazy.
Agreed. When I got my DS, i was surprised at how unattractive the system looked...especially with Nintendo coming off the GBA:SP. PSP's got DS beat on sexiness factor, iPod is a tougher call, but I still like the look of the PSP better (gamer bias!
).dark10x said:Wow, that's pretty crazy.
Yeah, I can see that. Especially the 80's part. DS gives me a retro Game & Watch vibe, which I think is pretty neat. I'm more for minimalistic design of the DS rather than PSP.
Minimalistic handheld with 2 screens. :lol
Similar threads
- Poll