So I quickly decided to go ahead and watch the last movie for the eclipse scene.
Having reread that part of the manga just recently, I could replay it scene for scene. I also looked at the Charlotte sex scene at the end of the second movie.
They made some choices I really agree with. For example, in the manga, when Griffith comes to have sex with Charlotte, he's clearly and totally manipulating her. He comes in, he kisses her, she resists, but eventually gives in. In the movie, they gave her a greater degree of agency. Griffith offers to leave at one point, and when he gropes her, and she resists, he backs off, but then she places his hand on her breast again. It's a far more human depiction of the scene that demonstrates Griffith doesn't JUST see Charlotte as a means to an end. I feel that people often forget that Griffith did value the people around him pre-eclipse. His manga depiction isn't bad either, it shows him more desperate for some measure for control, so his advances despite her resistance make sense. But the movie depicted him in a different kind of vulnerable, where he was looking for acceptance (which he got, but it wasn't enough and not quite what he was looking for in any case) rather than control. And for all the rape it shows, it's good to show charlotte as actually wanting and making sexual advancements of her own volition as way of empowerment. So I actually prefer the movie version of that scene.
Still, I noticed when they cut stuff for time budget reasons. For example, the whole Wyland chase. While I'll agree that Wyland is a character isn't strictly necessary, I thought he made for a great piece of foreshadowing and a false sense of security. After Wyland finally dies, you think "oh, man, what an evil motherfucker. There's got to be a breather period after this, right?"
I also feel they cut some of Griffiths dream sequence, and that was one of the most important parts of it. Granted, it got the same gist of it, but...well, you know, devil is in the details.
And other than some CGness, the movies do the sheer, almost surreal, brutal horror of the Eclipse justice.
Having reread that part of the manga just recently, I could replay it scene for scene. I also looked at the Charlotte sex scene at the end of the second movie.
They made some choices I really agree with. For example, in the manga, when Griffith comes to have sex with Charlotte, he's clearly and totally manipulating her. He comes in, he kisses her, she resists, but eventually gives in. In the movie, they gave her a greater degree of agency. Griffith offers to leave at one point, and when he gropes her, and she resists, he backs off, but then she places his hand on her breast again. It's a far more human depiction of the scene that demonstrates Griffith doesn't JUST see Charlotte as a means to an end. I feel that people often forget that Griffith did value the people around him pre-eclipse. His manga depiction isn't bad either, it shows him more desperate for some measure for control, so his advances despite her resistance make sense. But the movie depicted him in a different kind of vulnerable, where he was looking for acceptance (which he got, but it wasn't enough and not quite what he was looking for in any case) rather than control. And for all the rape it shows, it's good to show charlotte as actually wanting and making sexual advancements of her own volition as way of empowerment. So I actually prefer the movie version of that scene.
Still, I noticed when they cut stuff for time budget reasons. For example, the whole Wyland chase. While I'll agree that Wyland is a character isn't strictly necessary, I thought he made for a great piece of foreshadowing and a false sense of security. After Wyland finally dies, you think "oh, man, what an evil motherfucker. There's got to be a breather period after this, right?"
I also feel they cut some of Griffiths dream sequence, and that was one of the most important parts of it. Granted, it got the same gist of it, but...well, you know, devil is in the details.
And other than some CGness, the movies do the sheer, almost surreal, brutal horror of the Eclipse justice.