This isn't even close...the original still stands up as a movie I can watch several times a year, with fighting choegraphy that still holds up, a far more coherent plot, and some decent if cheesey humour. TMNT2 just struck me as a cash grab more then anything else...came out what, a year after the first movie? The climatic battle with Super Shredder lasted all of about 30 seconds...I think is friggin' intro was longer. And he did nothing but kill himself. :lol For that reason alone TMNT2 sucks.
The real question is, which April was/is hotter...Judith Hoag or Pagie Turco. It's a tough call for me...Judith had legs for days (which I'm a sucker for), is a natural red head (which I'm also a sucker for), and looks like a quality milf, while Paige looked extremely cute and innocent in her movie, but has since gone on to be NAKED in a few projects. Speaking for myself I couldn't go wrong either way, though I think Turco has aged better. So I'd probably go Judith back when the movies were out, while Paige wins out in the here and now.
Judith Hoag
Paige Turco