Instigator
Banned
Inspired by another thread.
Main consoles prioritized.
1. Sonic 1 (Genesis): This is hard. I know many people consider Sonic 2 better, but always felt Sonic was tighter, with greater level diversity, better character designs (especially enemies) and the best soundtrack in all Sonics. Furthermore, the special stage in this one is really the best one. A classic.
2. Sonic 2 (Genesis): Slightly faster and longer than Sonic 1. It has Tails which is probably the best designed 'Sonic friend' in any Sonic title. It also features a better and more complete two-player, split-screen game compared to what's available in Sonic 3. The special stage was novel and a great thing it could be played with two-players, but not really a match to the skills required in the one in Sonic 1 and 3.
3. Sonic Adventure 1 (Dreamcast): It's buggy, looks a bit rough around the edges, could have done without the overworld/adventure part and some of the extra characters too, but it remains the damned best Sonic in 3D for everything else it does. Some of the levels and soundtrack is top-notch. Lots of gameplay variety too.
4. Sonic CD (Sega CD): This one always felt like a sloppy remix of Sonic 1 to me. It has many similarities, especially with all the levels and animation cells, but the design is not quite there. The special stage is also a choppy, flat, Mario Kart clone. It still plays well enough and some of the soundtrack, even the notorious North American remix, is surprisingly good.
5. Sonic 1 (Game Gear/Master System): Approximation of Sonic 1 on Genesis for the most part. Doesn't look or play as fast, but a decent platformer nonetheless.
6. Sonic 3: This one was a huge disappointment to me. It was half of a game (the better half, but still...). Two-player game butchered to a ridiculously dumbed-down version, missing levels, Knuckles not playable in the main game. Despite it all, it did play like previous Sonic games on Genesis and the shield system was interesting. Though the art was questionable in some areas, the game could look stunning and un-Genesis like in some others. Perhaps best of all was the special stage, a technically impressive sphere world requiring quick reflexes and strategy.
7. Sonic Adventure 2 (Dreamcast): This game is really a shame. The demo was amazing and most of the Sonic/Shadow portion was definitely top-notch as was the graphics at the time. The Chao raising wasn't too bad either. But everything else is just awful and the game forced you to play parts you wouldn't have to play through in SA1. This game definitely marked the beginning of the end for Sonic Team as we know them.
8. Sonic Advance 1 (Gameboy Advance): Though looking like a SNES Sonic, it really plays like the Game Gear versions, with dumbed-down physics. The levels are big, it's fairly fast, it looks pretty enough. I'd say this one ain't too bad.
9. Sonic Advance 2 (Gameboy Advance): Same as above. This one seems a bit faster though. I still prefer the levels in the first game though.
10. Sonic & Knuckles (Genesis): The lesser half of Sonic 3. I personally think it doesn't look too good and only some of the later levels are worth playing. The lock-on feature is gimmicky, but I will concede Sonic 3 becomes a better game with it.
Main consoles prioritized.
1. Sonic 1 (Genesis): This is hard. I know many people consider Sonic 2 better, but always felt Sonic was tighter, with greater level diversity, better character designs (especially enemies) and the best soundtrack in all Sonics. Furthermore, the special stage in this one is really the best one. A classic.
2. Sonic 2 (Genesis): Slightly faster and longer than Sonic 1. It has Tails which is probably the best designed 'Sonic friend' in any Sonic title. It also features a better and more complete two-player, split-screen game compared to what's available in Sonic 3. The special stage was novel and a great thing it could be played with two-players, but not really a match to the skills required in the one in Sonic 1 and 3.
3. Sonic Adventure 1 (Dreamcast): It's buggy, looks a bit rough around the edges, could have done without the overworld/adventure part and some of the extra characters too, but it remains the damned best Sonic in 3D for everything else it does. Some of the levels and soundtrack is top-notch. Lots of gameplay variety too.
4. Sonic CD (Sega CD): This one always felt like a sloppy remix of Sonic 1 to me. It has many similarities, especially with all the levels and animation cells, but the design is not quite there. The special stage is also a choppy, flat, Mario Kart clone. It still plays well enough and some of the soundtrack, even the notorious North American remix, is surprisingly good.
5. Sonic 1 (Game Gear/Master System): Approximation of Sonic 1 on Genesis for the most part. Doesn't look or play as fast, but a decent platformer nonetheless.
6. Sonic 3: This one was a huge disappointment to me. It was half of a game (the better half, but still...). Two-player game butchered to a ridiculously dumbed-down version, missing levels, Knuckles not playable in the main game. Despite it all, it did play like previous Sonic games on Genesis and the shield system was interesting. Though the art was questionable in some areas, the game could look stunning and un-Genesis like in some others. Perhaps best of all was the special stage, a technically impressive sphere world requiring quick reflexes and strategy.
7. Sonic Adventure 2 (Dreamcast): This game is really a shame. The demo was amazing and most of the Sonic/Shadow portion was definitely top-notch as was the graphics at the time. The Chao raising wasn't too bad either. But everything else is just awful and the game forced you to play parts you wouldn't have to play through in SA1. This game definitely marked the beginning of the end for Sonic Team as we know them.
8. Sonic Advance 1 (Gameboy Advance): Though looking like a SNES Sonic, it really plays like the Game Gear versions, with dumbed-down physics. The levels are big, it's fairly fast, it looks pretty enough. I'd say this one ain't too bad.
9. Sonic Advance 2 (Gameboy Advance): Same as above. This one seems a bit faster though. I still prefer the levels in the first game though.
10. Sonic & Knuckles (Genesis): The lesser half of Sonic 3. I personally think it doesn't look too good and only some of the later levels are worth playing. The lock-on feature is gimmicky, but I will concede Sonic 3 becomes a better game with it.