• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Billy Hachet's Egg go bye bye, Vgcat's style

Zapages

Member
Another week and another panel filled with Vgcats love. The Furry's back... I think the author took GAF's advice about animation being an option, but why does he have to torture us with the animation in his comics.

060227.jpg
 
16 panels too long.
yeah, you heard me 16

...but they could've just moved the last panel to panel 6 and it would've been better.
 
I had to look it over like 3 times to make sure I wasn't missing something profound and now I want my 5 minutes back.
 
It could've been funny. Three years ago, and with half of it cut out. I don't even usually participate in these topics, but this one is ridiculous.

You guys forgot to mention the horrible flashback transition.
 
Ah yes, tons of witty framerate jokes. You're all uniquely funny. Good job, gentlemen.
 
I think VGCats tries to outlame itself. It does a too many panel comic and peoplecomplain. Then it does a Sixth Sense comic and people cry old. So they're like... we'll do both! So they pick a random game from years ago that few people played and run the same panel over and over.
 
I like the first revision. What if, instead of saying "Dumbass" he said something like "Now to fertilize this egg..."

What's the deal with VG Cats anyway? I mean, it's never even remotely funny.
 
D-X said:
I really hope Scott doesn't read GAF


Wouldn't it be helpful to know his supposed to be funny webcomic lacks any semblance of humor? Or timeliness? And who even played Billy Hatcher when it came out? Could this comic be any less relevant?
 
Why the fuck does VGCats keep doing comics about ollllllllllllld fucking shit? It probably would have actually been funny for once if it hadn't been a bajillion fucking panels.
 
Only the alternates saved the thread :lol good job... vgcats is beyond self-mockery at this point, simply incredible...
 
Gigglepoo said:
Wouldn't it be helpful to know his supposed to be funny webcomic lacks any semblance of humor? Or timeliness? And who even played Billy Hatcher when it came out? Could this comic be any less relevant?

It would, were it actually the case. But anyone going to GAF for constructive criticism is hopelessly misguided to begin with.
 
I think the most common constructive criticism is the fact that the comics have way too many panels.

It's like he thinks more panels = more funny. The seem to be getting longer each time too.

The funniest ones he's done have been short.

021206.gif
 
MattKeil said:
It would, were it actually the case. But anyone going to GAF for constructive criticism is hopelessly misguided to begin with.

Better not tell some of those OT Gaffers then
 
Shalomi said:
so am I the only one who likes VG cats, if only for the expressive artwork and the Tom nook comic?

gtfocopy39sx.jpg


Great Rumbler said:
I laughed a bit when the egg cracked and the chicken fell out. But then it just kept going and going...

Same here. I really can't imagine why anyone would add all that crap after it.
 
I think it went from sad to gross to meh.

The revision with 3 panels was great though.

Maybe we should just thank him for making easy-to-photochop panels.
 
Top Bottom