Karma Kramer said:
This whole conversation has turned ridiculous and anecdotal. The idea that blacks are dumber criminals therefore they get arrested 10 times as often despite using/selling drugs just as much as white dealers/users is ridiculous in many ways, but it doesn't even refute the main point I was trying to make.
Don't get hung up on the insult. It was a flippant comment. Let's say that black criminals are just as smart as their white counterparts since I don't want to be banned and I also have no stats to back that up- purely anecdotal. Let's say they don't sell drugs in obvious ways with a bigger staff(probably 20-30 times more than their white counterparts, but I digress). The point is that they are in trouble because, immoral laws or not, they are breaking them. I will never get how anyone things the drug trade overall is anything but immoral, but I'm in the minority on that one.
Anyway, how on earth is it more ridiculous to say that catching blacks is easier since they are in plain view (If someone doesn't believe that, they have never been in the inner city) than saying that the ENTIRE justice system made up of all races and classes is favored heavily against black people as if they are merely standing around doing nothing like their white counterparts? You answer that and I'll back off of it.
The reality is clear as daytime crack selling on 5th & Jefferson. Again, not realizing the truth about something is what causes blacks to be exactly where they are in the inner city.
Racism exists in the justice system for sure. I mentioned before that I was pulled over on a charge of carrying grapefruit juice at 3 in the morning during finals. That was the only time it happened and I was never in danger of spending time in jail for it (I wish since I could have used the lawsuit money). But systemic and universal? No way. Racism can't be blamed for legitimate bad behaviour even if one choose to not define it as bad behovaior. That's not your call.
These drug laws have no affect on drug production/use... for the thirty years we have been having this war, there has been no improvement.
This is true because the drug trade is more lucrative (For some at least) than the risk of prison time involved. However, this does not mean that one immoral policy is going to be able to improve the lives of people/victims of another immoral policy. Allowing drugs to flourish legally in the black community will destroy that black community as easily as the liquor store on every corner does.
It is an immoral policy and only leads to continuation of addiction through generations. If blacks, who have been oppressed clearly as of 50 years ago, are being affected by these laws by a larger margin, it does not matter the circumstances that led to their higher incarceration rates... what matters is these unnecessary and ineffective laws are continuing to oppress a minority that is still trying to become socially equal to whites. That is why the continuation of the drug war is a continuation of slavery... because it doesn't do what it intended (stop drugs).
This is simply not true. No one is slaves to the drug war. It's a voluntary army. You don't blame the voluntary circumstance for the state you're in. It insults the people living a decent life in the inner city, the ones who escaped that life (Many friends and family are only 2-3 generations out of poverty), and totally ignores the reasons for the high incarceration rates- the method of distributing.
It ignores a real solution and replaces it with a reason for mediocrity that isn't shared by a large portion in the black community- so it in turns insults them as if we're freaks for actually living the American (White?) dream when it is easier to do in the 21st century.
Drug addiction is rampant across all races and classes, so addiction is not primary reason. Criminal activity is. Inner city though has a huge abundance of supply that will only get larger with the abolishment of laws. It will not help the black community beyond the drug business owner who doesn't even live in the community.
The rebuttal to this will be of course, well they shouldn't break the law and should clean up their act. Interesting point, and I agree... however the method currently being used does not help to solve this. Black and white people use drugs equally... drug use comes down to social conditions and economic stability. Poor people use drugs, it has nothing to do with the color of your skin, but environment. And if current drug laws do nothing to fix these environments, continuing them is admitting support to oppression.
Well, the breaking the law part for sure. Don't be an idiot and break the law. That's a no brainer. However, the clean up your act part is not easy at all and I never indicated it was. How could it be considering how easy it is to stay addicted? No one is saying people should get arrested soley for being addicted to drugs. But they should definitely be arrested with whatever years are tied to the crime for distributing it.
Doing anything else does not help the black community at all which is kind of what I thought the thread was about, not whining about why black criminals are incarcerated more as if a freed crack dealer is anything to cheer.