-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Call of Cthulhu Mafia |OT| Nuts on this island taste insane! Yum Yum!
- Thread starter Zatoth
- Start date
Blargonaut
Banned
He's not Town, trust me.
If I get lynched (which is likely and entirely justifiable) Matt Attack is going to win today, but I think we ALL know who's going to "win" today.
Help me out on these two a bit. Your other ones were vague but the reasoning was there but these two don't make sense to me. Scrafty has gone back into the background a bit but she did bring up Charleston which had been previously a buried point and, whether I like it or not, Neuromancer has at least been active in trying to get support against me.
Matt Attack would be winning today. I gave you a slight victory for your help but he would still be the only winner today if he is a neutral role that just needs to kill you.
Blargonaut, again you're full of it. Why do you insist on claiming I'm not town sometimes, but then freely admit that: 1) You have no proof of other player's roles. 2) You brought me up to mess with me.
Also, is there any way we could kill Matt AND Blargonaut in this day phase? There's a possibility that's an option if we're concerned about letting someone else "win" today.
Blargonaut
Banned
He's not going to "win" tho
Your browsing history will remember him as the Ephialtes to my Leonidas.
I'm fine with letting Matt Attack win today, it seems likely that a game win for him gives town a win for all of day 2.
Blargonaut
Banned
Lord of Castamere
Member
I have similar feeling. It doesn't really matter if Matt Attack is lying about his win condition.
Blargonaut
Banned
Yeah, but he's not going to "win" tho
Well he came in and made one good post i will give him that but something about him not being there just gave me this uneasy feeling.
Regarding Neuromancer , he made a good point against you, i will give him that, i agree with him with you just being vocal aswell but since he was just barely vocal in this game gives me an uneasy feeling and a feeling of Cult from him.
If Blarg's not the killer, somebody is still going to die tonight.
I'm not so sure Matt Attack's win condition is us lynching Blarg. It makes sense that it would be at a cursory glance, but if Blarg dies to cult tonight, then does that mean Matt Attack is just screwed? Does he just lose and stay on the island, or just lose and die? Usually neutral win conditions rely on the role to accomplish some set task before they die, not before somebody else dies. If I'm understanding this correctly, it sounds like a pro town role that he just threw out into the open way too fast.
You say that about nearly everyone.
Ok and my question on Scrafty?
True, but the killer wasn't something we were going to be able to prevent anyway, we have no clues towards that yet. I'm still hoping for a vigilante that is town aligned since they did KO a cultist on night one.
Regardless of Matt Attack's role as town or neutral, it doesn't really change my feeling on the Blarg vote.
I am sorry my dear!
Blargonaut
Banned
lol you're all so full of doubt and vinegar
Everything I've been stating since I dropped my Rubiks Cube has been the 100% verified truth
Once I get lynched, Matt's gonna win through my "win", he can't surf without his surfboard. I thought I put an end to the role speculation regarding the pair of us but it seems like you all doubt me for some reason
Everything I've been stating since I dropped my Rubiks Cube has been the 100% verified truth
Once I get lynched, Matt's gonna win through my "win", he can't surf without his surfboard. I thought I put an end to the role speculation regarding the pair of us but it seems like you all doubt me for some reason
Wait, was this part about Scrafty? Nin, pronouns. She is still a she lol
Yes it was , Sorry about that once again. I dit not know that and i corrected myself ;P
Blargonaut
Banned
nuh-uh
Hmm, ok, you're still holding my vote for awhile longer while I see if there is anything else worth asking. Do me a favor and speak up more, all of your reads are extremely vague and I can't really tell if they mean anything to me.
Maybe we should just lynch anyone who Blarg was not suspicious of at some point during the game. That's gotta be only 1 or 2 people right?
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
I've slept on it and I agree with Darryl. Blarg is not a threat. I'd much rather see him get night killed than eat a lynch that could go to a possible Cultist. I think the idea that the Cult gets a "super kill" out of him is a paranoid fantasy. And besides, as I said to Neuromancer on the first day, our job is to kill Cultists, not to keep Tourists alive. We're not doing our job by killing Blarg.
Zatoth listed me as voting for Coppanuva, but I actually unvoted last night. However, in the name of making it official:
VOTE: Coppanuva
Not that it matters. You're all too busy jumping at shadows to play the damn game.
Zatoth listed me as voting for Coppanuva, but I actually unvoted last night. However, in the name of making it official:
VOTE: Coppanuva
Not that it matters. You're all too busy jumping at shadows to play the damn game.
Blargonaut
Banned
Please, the core of the game is town vs. mafia. Neutral roles are just there mucking things up from the get go. The faster we get them out of here, the less people we have running around who have a reason to lie. The fact that we get to remove a neutral role and we don't lose someone to the cult at night is just bonus. There's only two scenarios that we get out of leaving Blarg alive. The cultists get a bonus for killing him or they just ignore him and kill another town member instead. You've already said a bunch of times that the cult killing him would be a waste of a night just like if we used our lynch to block them, they aren't going to waste that night kill if there is no reward for them.
Blargonaut
Banned
The other shuttle crashed Rats, that payload's not going anywhere
The dream is dead
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
I know, Blarg. I know.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
The one good thing I see coming from Blarg's death is that all of you will be able to focus on what matters for the first time in this game.
ScraftyDevil
Banned
Well I did a big ol' chart last page but I guess we're not countin' that as productive now, are we?
There just ain't much to discuss as of right now. Charleston's a dead lead until we get to tomorrow cuz either Blarg or Mattack are definitely gonna die tonight and he hasn't given me more material to work with in the meanwhile. I've got no beef with you or Neuromancer as neither of ya have come across as 'specially suspicious to me.
Is there anythin' in particular you wanted me to comment on or were you just makin' sure I haven't folded on this hand yet?
Blargonaut
Banned
Stop taking credit for my work, Sorian. I know it's easy and convenient to plagiarise, but it's considered bad form in most academic circles.
Your chart was fine but it was just more a reiteration of what everyone knew as opposed to new information or reads. I wasn't expecting new info from you so that question would be more for Nin than anyone else. That being said, there is no reason to stifle any conversation just because the vote today seems decided. Rats looks like he will still fight for a Coppa vote and I'm not sure but Darryl is probably going to fight for something else too. If you have a lead you want to follow, all you have to do is ask the right questions. Anything you gain today just gives us a head start on day 3.
Just so you know, both Droplet and ScraftyDevil are girls.
Lord of Castamere
Member
Victim blaming.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
So we should kill him because the Cult gets nothing out him.
Better start rounding up the Ordinary Tourists, then.
Well considering those are my reads they should not mean anything to others but i will try to be more specific.
The last thing I want to do is take credit for some of your non-sense. That being said, what exactly was I copying from you in that post?
come on mate, you are like the billionth player pointing something out i appologized 20 minutes ago
enough is enoughBlargonaut
Banned
You tell me.
No, we should kill him because we do get a reward out of it. Last I checked, we don't get a reward for stringing up the ordinary tourists or Zatoth owes us some cookies for day 1.
If we leave him there and he is worth nothing to the cultists then all they are going to do is know that he is one player that they don't need to bother with because killing him won't further their goal as much as killing a tourist would.
I think, unfortunately, that we aren't going to get the information we necessarily want for the rest of Day 2 as everybody here knows they're safe unless their name is MattAttack or Blargonaut. I'm not saying we should end the day early, but I'm just putting it out there that we may be spinning our wheels until Day 3 starts.
Blargonaut
Banned
Sorian's clearly trying to cover up my list of suspected Cultists, people who've been constantly and conveniently harrassing my unique playstyle since the game began, by dismissing my explanation posts as nonsense.
Killing him trades him for a tourist essentially. The tourist that doesn't die has a range in value as they could be anywhere from ordinary to a power role, and a prolific poster to low activity, but at least that person won't be someone filling up the thread with distracting lies and confusion. Also the extra night is another night that any potential power roles can be active.
Blargonaut
Banned
Ya know, we still have one shuttle, it still has an operational Armadillo.
Maybe we should go to 800 feet.
Don't get me wrong, I actually like your short list of 4 that you posted recently but you've also randomly pointed at Coppa, Me, Darryl, etc. and you also put Matt Attack on that short list and let's be real, you only did that because you knew you'd still try to convince people for your life.
I was on your list of 4 who have consistently pulled for your death, yet I also have switched my tone on you and have given you your props for excellent puzzle creation. Where would that leave me?
Lord of Castamere
Member
You say "unique" I say "chaotic". What has your "unique" playstyle benefited the town besides chaos.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
We have a fundamental disagreement on this point. I think Blarg is more valuable to us later in the game. I say we wait to lynch him until we find another Cultist.
come on mate, you are like the billionth player pointing something out i appologized 20 minutes ago
You will repent for eternity!
If indeed killing Blarg today grants us an extra night where the cult doesn't kill anyone, then we've effectively just given ourselves another day phase to figure out who to next lynch. We don't get any information from the mafia night kill, because there is none, and chances are the only thing we get from tonight is being out one tourist because of our resident serial killer. We have a slight possibility that we have some information gathering roles that will be able to do something interesting tonight, but the chances of them, if they exist, getting anything useful from such a large cast is low.
If everyone thinks it's worth it for that, then by all means, let's kill Blarg today. But if not, just let the mafia handle it tonight or our future selves handle it later. Or if everyone's going to be distracted by him like this every day from now on, let's just kill him and get it over with.